I looked in about a million and one WalMarts ans Staples, and came up dry. Then I hit an Office Max. They had them with an introductory "buy one get on free" sale. So I got two for $6.99 USD. Nice!!!!!Hint - They weren't with the other Sharpies in the pen isle. They were on a cardboard endcap with a bunch of other various branded "back to school" items. I found them on my own, after two Office Max employees searched the whole store, and then told me that they didn't sell them.
Finally picked one up at a pen specialty shop a while ago. Not impressed with it. very thin shell with plastic mid section, coupled with thickness gives a very cheap feeling, and seems no more durable than regular sharpie. Especially for the price you can buy a whole pack of plastic sharpies. I'd stick with the cheap plastic one.
I personally really like mine. Not exactly sure what you guys are expecting TBH. It's a "Stainless steel Sharpie" and that's exactly what it is. For the money, I think people are expecting too much.