Importation ban on one handed opening knives in Australia

[turnsouth]

Something else to consider is whether or not the law will actually be enforced.  In California, we have a law that came on to the books a couple years ago that when ever you have your wipers on, you also have to have your headlights on as well, or get a citation.

In reality, I've never seen, let alone heard of, even a single incident of a CHiP or even a county mountie citing someone for no lights with wipers on...

You know, there is a backhanded reason for this, and that is to force the automakers to provide this as an automatic option on new cars. If they just passed a state law that says that all automakers must build this into new cars, they end up in court for years with the lawyers getting rich.

But doing it this way they cause the automakers to compete against each other, as in "You don't have to worry about the wiper law, our new cars take care of that for you".

[django.cj]

That Australian law is bs.  Sorry mates 

The lights on my truck go off when I turn it off, so my lights are always on, I never touch them.

[MultiMat]

As far as I've seen with these new rules, MT's may be excluded, as they're not yet seen as weapons in the eyes of 'Today Tonight' which as all Australians know is the source of all reactionary media smurf that results in stupid laws.

I, for one, am buying up every flipper and OHO knife I can afford while I can.

The laws might be stupid, but until Channel 7 is off the air, we're stuck with them.

I wonder which of us sells a kidney first to buy a locally/Aussie sourced Zero Tolerance flipper  . Man I wish I had known about them before the news laws came into effect .

I am as happy as anyone that OHO knives appear to be still available too Aussies , the thing I do resent is the possibility of having to buy exclusively from Aussie knife sellers to avoid the 'Russian Rollete' that Aussie customs puts you through when you privately buy a knife from over seas. I REALLY like the prices I have been paying for knives/MTs from US based sellers. There are some good Aussie knife sellers but you do still pay at least $20-$40 more for a knife than they go for in the US  . I am a bit of a tight arse but a extra $40 can buy you a nice knife or the better part of a Leatherman 

95% of knives I have purchased from overseas have been inspected by customs  , I wish the buggers spent more time looking for illicit drugs & less time looking at my knives/MTs 

[sjian]

In Canada all vehicles are required to have their lights on while moving.  It wasn't until the Maine Meetup a few years ago that I realized that wasn't the case in the US, and let me tell you, it was a bit of a surprise!

At least here in Ontario, all cars made in Canada automatically have "daytime running lights" on when the key is set to On or Start Ignition.  My friend from Australia didn't even notice it until I mentioned it to her.
I have a friend in the states that said recently made cars in the states have it too.  The purpose of it is to increase visibility which results in lower accidents.

[misscase530]

Total stupidity!!  Hate to digress from multitools to a political rant but I can't help it. 

These types of bans are a result of populist politicians pandering to real idiots.  I live in Canada where our Liberal party brought in a rifle/shotgun gun registry for rank political purposes as the first step in making guns illegal.  After 5 years and a couple BILLION dollars in money totally wasted, the current government is shutting it down.  The kicker is the bad guys still use guns that are shipped in from the states and really don't care about registries.  Not one life was ever saved because of this registry.  As for the police, no one bothers to check it, why would you bother.  In the end foolish politicians cost the Canadian taxpayer billions in setting up a useless bureaucracy that  made absolutely no difference in the crime rate.

A one handed opening knive or multitool is no more intrinsically dangerous than a sheath knife.  When you have idiot politicians, an incompetent and over lenient judicial system and a fluffy penal system that is geared to producing hard core criminals more than actually reforming people and giving them hope, then politicians will continue to focus on objects like guns or one-hand opening knives as "evil".  If we only ban them then crime will go down or completely disappear.  Of course the bad guys will easily continue to have their switchblades, blackjacks and one handed opening knives, cause they're bad guys and they don't care.  And lets not discuss the real problem, a retarded legal/penal system that creates criminals.  No, lets punish you and me who will be shafted the next time we are on a 30 foot ladder with one hand on a chimney for balance and the other needing to pull out the "new" Charge TTi to quickly cut some insulation.  Damn, have to use two hands, gotta go down.

Best thing you can do is become politically active to fight this kind of thing.  Politicians will sometimes surprise even themselves with the jack-ass things they say.  If you can raise publicity on the issue and make it embarrassing for them, tho the point that they look foolish, they will back away faster sailors with a 4 hour pass.

[Heinz Doofenshmirtz]

Something else to consider is whether or not the law will actually be enforced.  In California, we have a law that came on to the books a couple years ago that when ever you have your wipers on, you also have to have your headlights on as well, or get a citation.

In reality, I've never seen, let alone heard of, even a single incident of a CHiP or even a county mountie citing someone for no lights with wipers on...

You know, there is a backhanded reason for this, and that is to force the automakers to provide this as an automatic option on new cars. If they just passed a state law that says that all automakers must build this into new cars, they end up in court for years with the lawyers getting rich.

But doing it this way they cause the automakers to compete against each other, as in "You don't have to worry about the wiper law, our new cars take care of that for you".

Good point.  I personally think it's a good idea; I mean, it just makes sense.  99% of the time, when it's raining, it's also cloudy... not to mention reduced visibility from the rain, etc.

I'd certainly consider it a nice feature to have in a vehicle, that turning on your wipers also turns on your driving lights, at least.

[Tsquare]

I think I remember reading that after all the gun banning legislation that the crime rate in Australia went up like 400%.  You think they would have figured it out by now this will not help crime. 

[Grant Lamontagne]

You aren't insinuating that criminals commit crimes are you? 

While this is a pertinent discussion with regards to the topics this forum covers, let's be careful not to go too far into the political end of it, or else we may find a Mod having to step in.

Def

[MultiMat]

I think I remember reading that after all the gun banning legislation that the crime rate in Australia went up like 400%.  You think they would have figured it out by now this will not help crime.

Woo there buddy that figure is ridiculous , I feel a million times safer in most parts of Australia than I did in a lot of the US when I was there recently, I saw a awful lot of desperate people on the streets of the US.

You must remember North America's attitude to gun ownership is significantly different to the rest of the world. Me I am most comfortable knowing a mentally deranged person like Martin Bryant can not now  purchase & own a virtually military spec semi automatic rifle in Australia , just my opinion mind you.

Thread is not about guns though so back on topic.

I read on Australian Blade Forums of a chap that had the temerity to make formal complaints regarding seizure of his knives & subsequently had a visit to his personnel residence from Australian Customs officials to asses his knife collection. I find this a concern as these new laws cover importation of knives NOT knife ownership. I have asked him some questions & hope he has some luck with his fight with these heavy handed bureaucrats.

[Grant Lamontagne]

Again Mat, if there's anything Multitool.org can do to help, just let me know!

Def

[Tsquare]

My concern is that your ability to own multitools and the sort will be impaired. 

[joea]

My concern is that your ability to own multitools and the sort will be impaired.

Yes... that's a good point Tsquare. Politics aside, what is everyone's opinion on why they ban the
importation of an item but not the item itself? In this case multitools/knives. I can understand an
argument that you may not carry something in public but could still own it and use it on private
land as then is does not pose a threat to the public. I may not agree with this but at least I can
see what the argument is about. But if you can not import something because it is a dangerous
weapon than how can you still be allowed to own it. I can not see the logic. Maybe they hope
that over time the existing ones will break, wear out or simply fade away?
Also say they do ban the importation of one handed opening multitools and the blade breaks on
my Wave I suppose Leatherman would then give me a new two handed opening Wave?
That could be quite a cost to the company.
Does anyone know if this has happened in other country's? I know this can be an emotional
subject but I would like to know people's thoughts? Cheers, Joe.
     

[Santos]

I think I remember reading that after all the gun banning legislation that the crime rate in Australia went up like 400%.  You think they would have figured it out by now this will not help crime.

Woo there buddy that figure is ridiculous , I feel a million times safer in most parts of Australia than I did in a lot of the US when I was there recently, I saw a awful lot of desperate people on the streets of the US.

You must remember North America's attitude to gun ownership is significantly different to the rest of the world. Me I am most comfortable knowing a mentally deranged person like Martin Bryant can not now  purchase & own a virtually military spec semi automatic rifle in Australia , just my opinion mind you.

Thread is not about guns though so back on topic.

now here is the RUB. Austalians have never been entitled to gun ownership in the sense of self defense or 'i own one cause i wanna' . Its always been you need to have a legitamite reason.
What gets brushed over is Martin Bryant didnt acquire his guns legally, yeah it was through a dodgy arms dealer in the state of the lax gun laws. Port Arthrur was a tradgedy but the gun laws afterwards where really a giant exercise in smoke and mirrors and all that really changed was the removal of semi-automatic and pump action shotguns. (which incedently you are still entitled to buy ONE as a primary producer) The tune was sung that now people wouldn't be able to kill so many in such a short space of time... but i am positive that in that the reality is a lever/pump action rifle will do the same sort of result.

The gun laws didn't take guns off our streets, it just made it harder for law abiding citirzens.
Many aussies don't share their pro-gun views as its a social taboo. My aussie side of the family is fairly left wing and i honestly can say i shared your sentiment when i was younger Multimat... but having travelling the world and lived through many things i can honestly i understand it when americans chant "Guns dont kill people, people kill people"
My reply use to be "yeah but if they dont have guns..."

I often speculate what port arthur would of been like if it played out in a small county town in texas... or if Ghandi would of been so sucessful if he wasn't facing the british in india but Pol Pot in cambodia or some african warlord

Back to the knife laws, it won't be that bad, its a matter of how you handle it. I daily carry a Becker Remora on my keychain and a wenger. Most people are extremly suprised (and somewhat scandelised ) when they realise its there after knowing me for months or years... they just don't think..'"I am the type"
 Keep your nose clean and no one bothers you. Do something stupid like flash it at the wrong social moment or choose it over your fist and you have a problem.

I think ultimately we need to teach people responsibility, citizneship, integrity and self worth.
Instead we slap down ineffective laws and pass the buck.