Welcome to again Raven I will have to think a bit but hopefully someone else will be along shortly and be able to answer this question better than me
Well you got some good replies and I still wouldn't know what to recommend
http://skinthsolutions.com/product/xl-shield-sheath/ or http://skinthsolutions.com/product/2xl-shield/
+1 for the Skinth XL Shield. I use one to carry the same loadout as the OP but have a AAA light instead of the ferro rod. @ hiraethus: 2XL Shield isn't as tall and won't work for Surge. If you want a bigger solution than the XL you need the Mondo Shield.http://skinthsolutions.com/product/xl-shield-sheath/