Thanks for the replies. I now know what I have been doing wrong. I used to close the tool by first rotating both handles and then finally closing the pliers. When either one of those screwdrivers is deployed, the rotation step goes a bit further than usual. This leads to the plier point reaching the inside of the handle. When the pliers are forced shut afterwards, the plier point scratches the inside of the handle a little.
Apparently, I should close the tool in another sequence. First, rotate the handle opposite of the deployed screwdriver. Then, squeeze the pliers shut. Finally, rotate the handle on the side of the deployed screwdriver. This way, the plier point does not reach the inside of the handle.
I am sure a lot of people indeed close their tool in the second manner, but I saw many videos of people closing their tool in the first manner (which seems to be more straightforward), so I also did it that way. Now I know that, there is no problem anymore. I am very satisfied with the multitool on the whole. Although, what is with that huge empty space near the lanyard hole? Is it due to the Fuse adding only the scissors on the other side compared with the Kick and the manufacturer did not feel like putting another tool implement near the lanyard hole to even things out?