I was suggesting a First Mate as it has all the tools that you need, including the ring omission, just with the saw added, then I read again the original post.
IMHO, I would use a First Mate. If not, I would get one of the green Ranchers from Tim, which at the moment would be the best deal in terms of new SAKs with the marlin spike, and consider modding that (removing the anodizing and the ring holder, maybe replacing with some of that nice hard anodizing from Siph).