The Spirit has almost everything you could need for, except:
- Corkscrew. Maybe you never used one, but whenever you do need it, you'll be so happy to have it. I mostly use it to scrape dirt, or hardened mud from objects.
- Tweezers.
- Pincet.
- Micro screwdriver (can also be used as a small nail.)
- Needle.
- Awl with sewing hole.
My choice would be the Compact or Spartan. No need to carry two scissors, wood and metal saws.
If you're looking for a compact replacement in case you loose your Spirit, I would opt for the Handyman.
My advice is not to carry the knives in the same pocket. Or if you do, secure at least one with a piece of rope to your clothing. In case of emergency and exhaustion people tend to become careless. For example they unbutton their pockets, and do not close them afterwards. You bend over (no, my name is not Ben Dover) and the knives slip out of your breast pocket into the river, underbrush or deep snow.
I would prefer the Compact over the Spartan, avoiding the opener layer that we have on the Spirit already. I agree with the Handyman, one of my favorite models even though it doesn’t get much love around here.
I agree with securing SAKs, I had one slip out of my pocket more then once, so now they are always on a lanyard, micro clip or belt hanger
The Waiter I ordered came in today, so I will carry it starting tomorrow. Will see if I miss the Compact I used for the last few days.