I think it's worth noting that all serrations are not created equal. Just like PE blades, the cutting geometry of some is much better than others.Possibly fodder for separate threads, but for those (all four of us, apparently ) who see at least some redeeming qualities in CE blades for at least some applications:Do you prefer the serrations near the tip of the blade, and the plain section near the handle? Or would you rather have the plain section near the tip, and the serrations near the handle? Explain the reason(s) for your choice.How much of a CE blade should be serrated? Half? Three quarters? One quarter? Why? Does your answer change based on the total length of the blade?
1) I think the Vic type with the serrations towards the tip makes a lot of sense because that should give you the best leverage for cutting rope and such and the non serrated rear portion of the blade should give you the most control for cutting a feather stick or sharpening a pencil, etc.. However most knives are the other way around and that is what I learned on and have more of. Absolute best combo edge was on a Schrade CH-7 I had years ago. It would rip through palm fronds (palm fronds are my benchmark) without much effort at all and even out performed some fully serrated blades. If I'd had the sense to buy several of them I'd still be using it but I don't want to risk the one I still have. The worst combo edge or fully serrated for palm fronds are Leatherman blades, but most Leathermans have an excellent saw blade so I just use that instead.2) I think 1/2 serrated is enough for most tasks and probably the best compromise, but it can go to 3/4 and still be usable. I have a partially serrated rigging knife that is 3/4 serrated and the plain edge is at the tip and on this particular knife I always wish it had less serrations. My solution is to always carry 2 or more knives and use whichever one is best suited to a particular task.
I like serrated blades but I prefer a different kind of combo
That might be interesting depending on the rules and requirements of the challenge.
I'm thinking.... Simply.... Carry any multitool or single blade folder for the month as long as it has a combo edge. Skeletool, Trekker, PST-2.No fully serrated or plain edge blade allowed. The inspiration for this challenge comes from Leatherman advertisements that I had been looking at. Leatherman's catch phrase will be something about resourcefulness, and the tool being able to help with any job. Meanwhile, someone is bound to comment that they would prefer a plain edge. I said to myself... Maybe I would prefer a plain edge too, but... Out of the box, the tool would (or wouldn't) get the job done, edge style notwithstanding. So the challenge is... To use any one of the perfectly good tools like the Skeletool or Signal or Trekker, and see how you get on with the blade as is.
Anyone up for this in 2021?
This is one of the few pairs of EDC that I have new in box copies of.I have lived with the Delica for a long time and it could easily be my only knife any time. (Image removed from quote.)M(Image removed from quote.)
I’d be in EB
I would be interested too.
I guess I could use the Signal and get its badge, unless this gets its own dedicated one.
Do the serrated blades of the Wave/Surge/Rebar/ST300 count? Seriously. That tiny plain edge tip of the ST300 serrated blade is just brilliant.I usually use those for short draw cuts. Nothing too ambitious. But I had to wrap a birthday present, so I did a draw cut of about 50cm, about 1.5 ft. Man, did it knock it out of the park! I kept a steady hand, and dragged the blade tip along a straight line, and the wrapping was easy as pie.(Image removed from quote.)
No use going with a tool I've carried previously anyway. I'll go with the Signal maybe. I also have a Wingman. Weird. I can't think of any more, though I am sure I have more with combo edges. I must.
That's an idea - if we don't get enough people to get a Combo Edge badge, it makes good sense to use a tool that already has one, like a...Signal, Swisstool Spirit (with butter blade), Leatherman MUT, Spyderco, SOG Powerlock Victorinox Soldier or 111mmSkeletoolGerber MP 400or even the Discontinued MT or Off Brand MT badgesLots of great options
I could be up for this as well. I quite like the combo edge as it comes in handy for SAR stuff and, if I use my Gerber (work issue before the Surge trial) then it's handy for that as well So, here are my current options (can't use my Skele as the CX is P/E )