I am not trying to have a clickbait title but I am seriously asking. I never had a smartphone growing up so I am not somebody that grew up with one attached to my hand all the 'time so I do remember life before them. I know a smartphone can't turn a screw or cut a package open but I think in some ways it is a multitool in it's own right. I guess just like my Leatherman Wave that once I started carrying it more I came to appreciate the sheer utility of it.
Yes, but not half as useful or trustworthy as ...
I think it is the ultimate technological multitool and remarkably similar in purpose. Most of the features can be done better with the appropriate dedicated tool but with a smartphone on hand you can access a vast array of technology in a sleek and pocketable package.I don't use or own one but I am very much aware of its utility. Were it not for the curse of social media having tainted its utility it would be very much part of my carry. A social media less smartphone would be a very interesting device that could maximise this advantage but it would not be worth investing in for any serious manufacturer so although they exist, they're simply old technology with a bunch of blocks added. Not really the same thing.
Most of the features can be done better with the appropriate dedicated tool but with a smartphone on hand you can access a vast array of technology in a sleek and pocketable package.
I only see my cell phone as a multi function device, but not a 'tool'.
a device or implement, especially one held in the hand, used to carry out a particular function.
Haven't thought of it like that, but you have an excellent point there. Maybe it's not the device itself but the way most people use it that triggers my disgust for it...
Maybe you just need a better phone/ better apps. Also it depends on your comparison for communication you can also compare it to a whistle or a mirror and I can tell you, the phone is much better than thoseI can pre-load Topographical maps of Switzerland, combined with the GPS it is awesome. And considering the quality of the maps and the screen I find it superior to most "dedicated navigation devices" (and those dedicated devices are not cheap, also chances that you have your smartphone with you is much higher). And it almost certainly does either off or on road better than the dedicated one.It even works better than a notepad (or can your notepad snap pictures and annotate them?) and you can send your notes to someone easily (I pretty much have stopped carrying a notebook/pen, I see no need for them anymore. I do carry a waterproof marker though).Besides, smartphones can do so much more than what you list. Identifying plants/animals, translating text, magnifying stuff and serves as spyglass (I actually use that frequently to read text that is just out of reach). It can store your survival cards, determine the speed you are going, entertainment, measure time, alarm clock, reminder etc. And functions like the ones ElvenBlade mentioned might not directly assist you in survival, but it frees up space you can use otherwise (for me, it allowed me to remove easily a dozen cards from my wallet, that is the size of a really decent compass.).Considering the size, that is an awful lot of functionality that not even a Spirit can match and even considering that it requires energy* a really good deal. Now I don't really believe it is the ultimate MT, but for its size/weight there is nothing better. And smartphones will get even better (e.g. distance measuring, lowlight camera etc) but the biggest jump forward will be when we get solid state batteries.* Yes, energy is a weakness of smartphones, but my 3 year old Galaxy Note 8 still runs 2 days with regular use. Admittedly, I'm not a heavy user, but it includes a bit of gaming, YT, Music, Wifi/Blutooth always on. If I had to rely on it, I could easily double that time. 2 more charges are about the size of a Spirit, but weigh less.
Do you know anyone who still uses his smartphone from 2007?
But like I said in my post above, maybe it's also the way most people use their smartphone that makes me dislike it so much... That and the fact that everybody expects you to be "available" every hour of the day. And yes, I can turn it off, but still, people won't understand why they couldn't contact me, or why I haven't read their email... I read my email while sitting behind my desk at home, nowhere else. And I only do this once a week or when I know somebody send me an email (which defeats its purpose, when they told me that they send me an email, they could've just skipped the mail and tell me what they had to say, or give me the document they wanted me to have in person).
The Garmin might be better, if you need better. For the majority of users a GPS system is about driving to location, not hiking. Of course you want a dedicated tool for a specific task but that's not what a multi tool is about. My wife is currently using a nokia of 2010 vintage and my nokia is a 2012 model if that helps. They don't make them like that any more but I have never known a cell phone which would give 'weeks' of battery life with regular day to day usage even in the golden age of small rugged phones, the nokia's, motorola's, etc. If you would provide the model number I'd be glad to look up the specs and compare its advertised battery life.
If anyone would start a discussion with me about how the saw on a multitool s*cks compared with the one hanging on the wall in the garden shed I'd try to explain that he's missing the point of the multitool .