Most of the time, a few simple tools an knife are enough to get me by. I'm also usually not too far from dedicated tools, and often when I need a tool, I need something random or specialized enough it wouldn't be on a SAK. Therefore, I don't see much benefit in trying to expand tool selection and the accompanying weight. Maybe something like a Spirit with a plus kit would be able to solve ~75% of those kinds of needs, but I am unwilling to carry that all the time.
Starting in early 1990, I carried a Leatherman PST to work each and every day. Used the crap out of it. About 12 years later I upgraded to the OG Wave. Still carried it to work every day. Fast forward to 2006. I lost that job. Ending up here in Kentucky working for Toyota Logistics Services. We buy all the cars produced at the Toyota plant and installing various option before shipping them on to dealers/distributors.I continued to carry the Wave ( or any of the multiple Leatherman tools I had accumulated ) to work every day. Soon I realized I had no need for such a tool at work. So, I went thru numerous brands/styles of pocket knives, before discovering the world of the SAK. I have picked up numerous Vics, Wengers, Swizas and Boker Tech Tools. For several years I carried only my Wenger Soldier, bail included. I LOVED that knife, and still do! But eventually I started trying them all out. Everything from 58mm to the mighty 130mm versions. I have carried minimal and maximum. Executive to Ranger 78. I then modded a Pioneer X. Removed the blade and awl. That was tough because I LOVE that inline awl!! I also modded the can opener to resemble the small flathead on the Technician. I paired that (scissors, big flat head/bottle opener and modded can opener) with various knives. The main one, for a few years, was my Spyderco Autonomy 2. Loved that combo. Here recently, I reverted to only carrying my Blade HQ exclusive fat carbon-fiber scaled Cadet. Pretty happy with it. I have been required, lately, to open many cardboard boxes, and cut them up. Usually I use a utility knife for that, as my Cadet blade could not handle all that cardboard. I have used a few 93 and 111mm SAKs, my Benchmade Adamas and Spyderco Smock. But the amount of cardboard is just too much for regular knives. The utility knife, with replaceable blade, is much more slicey. Used my US Soldier yesterday and Locksmith today. Had to touch up the blades and both a few times each day. So, Monday when I go back to work, I’ll be dropping that Cadet into my pocket. It will disappear, but will have everything I really NEED while at work. (Image removed from quote.)(Image removed from quote.)(Image removed from quote.)(Image removed from quote.)(Image removed from quote.)(Image removed from quote.)Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
My view that the underlying quantum force beneath all of this EDC stuff - and MTO stuff - is the desire to feel good. To convince ourselves that we have some small degree of control in this cold, cruel world. It is almost wholly emotional in my view. If every one of us stopped carrying everything except the absolute necessities of car keys, a driver's license and a credit card, it unlikely that any of us would die or end up in the hospital. There is certainly a practicality to SAKs and EDC, but that is ancillary to the strong emotional force that compels us to EDC.Seriously - what person in his right mind would pay $275 for an Obsidian ARC? That's a wholly emotional venture, and even though I have ranted about the absurd MSRP, my emotions are dragging me toward buying one. I can see it happening. It has nothing to do with utility. A person focused solely on utility would never consider such a purchase.As the emotions wax and wane, so too does our EDC. Mr. Carl is a good example of this. He was always a minimal EDC dude, but now well into retirement even his formerly beloved Peanut knife seems to be too much for him. The psyche, the emotion underlying it as has changed. Its - again in my view - not something that derives from reconsidering how much utility we want in our pockets. with myself - until I change my mind.
Out of curiosity, with rotating through knives before you settled on the cadet, did you ever find yourself missing a tool you needed that you may have had if you carried a different one?
Drop your flashlight? Me, I would neve.... wait a minute. I dropped mine this week. Hard to find a black flashlight…
Good thoughts, and I think as well. Even being a minimalist like I am, with a relatively fixed and boring carry, here I am on the forums. There’s the emotional, feel good aspect at play. I wonder if it’s the same for Carl.
What am interesting and enjoyable topic! Thirty five years before I ever heard the term EDC I was regularly carrying a few "just in case" items with me every day. For a long time it was a watch, wallet, Classic, and Fisher Space Pen. Eventually, the classic was replaced with a Climber. For a while I went with a full size Leatherman (the first model released), then a Squirt. It wasn't too long before I felt the pull back to Swiss Army Knives and picked up a Rambler. That was around the time my daughter was born and I still consider it to be the ultimate dad knife. When she got a little older I started really getting into SAKs, and I now have an embarrassingly large collection that includes over 90 different models. I've tried everything from the afformentioned Rambler to a Swiss Champ, Cybertool, and Hercules. I bought an Executive when I heard they were going to be discontinued and that's the one SAK I can't go without. Around that same time I got my first Alox and the Pioneer/Soldier quickly became a favorite. All these years later my EDC is a bit more than it was in my youth, but it's still fairly minimal in my mind. It consists of watch, phone, wallet, key fob, Executive, and (usually) a Pioneer. Once in a while I also carry a Vic Money Clip since my wallet is very slim. I no longer feel the need to carry a pen, and I wish I could go without my phone. The Pioneer is sometimes replaced with another SAK on the 84 to 93mm range. That is typically a Cadet, Sportsman, Spartan, or 91mm Companion, but if the mood strikes it could be one of many other SAKs.
I’ve been toying with the idea of going back to the cadet as my primary carry in place of the pioneer, but around the property the larger drivers and more hand filling handles do come in handy. And the weight/size penalty over the cadet isn’t that much.
I'm with you; I've been switching between the Pioneer and Cadet lately, and while I do like the Cadet it just doesn't have the same feel as the Pioneer. The more robust tools and that fantastic inline awl are too good. Plus, I recently got a nice older red OC and I am finding it irresistible.
I have come to appreciate the Alox Bantam even more. A Leatherman Super Tool 300 has become an invaluable part of my work tool kit. But the work I do isn't exactly clean. I'm hesitant to use the ST300's combo tool to open a soda bottle. An Alox Bantam rides in my pocket, clean and ready to pop the top when I want a Mexican Coca-Cola or Fanta with lunch.