Multitool.org Forum
+-

Hello Lurker! Remove this ad and much more by logging in.


1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison

J2000E · 11 · 629
« previous next »
Pages: 1   Go Down

se Offline J2000E

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
    • Posts: 256
  • Old school Headmaster
1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
on: November 16, 2025, 05:59:22 PM
Thought it would be nice to do a 1908 vs 1951 side by side comparison. My 1908 is from 1941 and the 1951 from 1951.

Size matters in some respect. The springs on the 1908 are a lot stronger.









Love them both.
« Last Edit: November 16, 2025, 06:23:40 PM by J2000E »

us Offline LoopCutter

  • *
  • Zombie Apprentice
  • ********
    • Posts: 12,686
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #1 on: November 16, 2025, 06:20:40 PM
I know since I was in the SAK thread I should know which is which!  :dunno:

Is the 1908 the longer knife with clip blade?  Also longer implements?

Just did not want to presume…

Both very beautiful examples for their vintage.


Oh my! Never mind, when examining the pictures I did observe the blade stamps, 41 and 51 , with the 41 the 1908 being longer. 🫣😊
If I start and end the day above ground, it is a good day!

Hope yours is as good!

A SMART man always knows what to say!
   A WISE man knows whether or not to say it!!!
Merit Badges Participate in a challenge by carrying  a Combo Edged knife or Multitool and post a photo of it  for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a Victorinox Cadet and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry at least one black edc item, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days.  Carry tools with single functions only. No multi-tools, no multi-layer Swiss Army Knives, no combo one-piece tools and post a photo for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry at least one red edc item, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Start a new thread with a photo of custom or non standard SAK scales in your collection Start a new thread with photos of a Japanese made PST in your collection Start a new thread or Post in a Challenge Thread and post a photo of a Spartan  for 30 days Start a new thread with photos of at least 6 SAKs of different frame lengths and/or shapes in your collection. Eg 58mm, 74mm, 84mm regular, 84mm slim, 85mm etc Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a keychain tool with pliers, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of a SAK-alike, aka multi-layered, knife-based pocket tools for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry at least one green edc item, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a SAK, duct tape, and paperclip, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a Leatherman Bond, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge and post a photo of a Utility Knife for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Delemont SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a challenge by carrying  a GEC knife and post a photo of it  for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of  a Leatherman Micra  for 30 days Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of  a Opinel  knife  for 30 days Participate in a challenge by carrying  a 100mm or 108mm SAK and post a photo of it  for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Vic Spirit MT for sixty (60) consecutive days.

us Offline LoopCutter

  • *
  • Zombie Apprentice
  • ********
    • Posts: 12,686
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #2 on: November 16, 2025, 06:26:39 PM
Would this be the knife I would be looking for if I sought my birth year knife?  1953

If I start and end the day above ground, it is a good day!

Hope yours is as good!

A SMART man always knows what to say!
   A WISE man knows whether or not to say it!!!
Merit Badges Participate in a challenge by carrying  a Combo Edged knife or Multitool and post a photo of it  for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a Victorinox Cadet and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry at least one black edc item, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days.  Carry tools with single functions only. No multi-tools, no multi-layer Swiss Army Knives, no combo one-piece tools and post a photo for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry at least one red edc item, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Start a new thread with a photo of custom or non standard SAK scales in your collection Start a new thread with photos of a Japanese made PST in your collection Start a new thread or Post in a Challenge Thread and post a photo of a Spartan  for 30 days Start a new thread with photos of at least 6 SAKs of different frame lengths and/or shapes in your collection. Eg 58mm, 74mm, 84mm regular, 84mm slim, 85mm etc Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a keychain tool with pliers, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of a SAK-alike, aka multi-layered, knife-based pocket tools for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry at least one green edc item, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a SAK, duct tape, and paperclip, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a Leatherman Bond, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge and post a photo of a Utility Knife for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Delemont SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a challenge by carrying  a GEC knife and post a photo of it  for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of  a Leatherman Micra  for 30 days Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of  a Opinel  knife  for 30 days Participate in a challenge by carrying  a 100mm or 108mm SAK and post a photo of it  for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Vic Spirit MT for sixty (60) consecutive days.

se Offline J2000E

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
    • Posts: 256
  • Old school Headmaster
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #3 on: November 16, 2025, 06:31:36 PM
The "1951" model from 1953 would be a nice birth year knife!

I am looking for the 1961 model from 1964 - to be my birth year knife.

cz Offline z1913

  • *
  • Hero Member
  • *****
    • Posts: 759
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #4 on: November 16, 2025, 07:03:14 PM
Quote from: J2000E on November 16, 2025, 06:31:36 PM
The "1951" model from 1953 would be a nice birth year knife!

I am looking for the 1961 model from 1964 - to be my birth year knife.
There is one 64 Wenger advertised right now (seller in Germany): https://www.kleinanzeigen.de/s-anzeige/wenger-delemont-red-alox-1964-original-swiss-army-knife/3133856646-234-8080
Merit Badges Start a new thread and post a photo daily of any SAK 74mm or smaller ( you can switch it up daily ) for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread or Post in a Challenge Thread and post a photo of a Spartan  for 30 days Start a new thread with photos of at least 12 SAKs of different frame lengths and/or shapes in your collection. Eg 58mm, 74mm, 84mm regular, 84mm slim, 85mm etc Start a new thread with photos of at least 3 different 130mm models in your collection Take part in the christmas pool or a rak type giveaway. Those wanting to say thank you for a rak may also nominate for the santa. Start a thread with photos of at least five different colored ALOX models in your collection For 30 consecutive days carry a SAK with a magnifying glass, and post a picture every day in the designated thread. Start a new thread with photos of at least 5 different 111mm models in your collection Start a new thread with a photo showing the Hook in use Start a new thread with photos of at least 12 different Wenger models in your collection Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Delemont SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Classic SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate and post a pic of your vintage SAK (1986 or earlier) everyday for 30 days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the minimal sak (2 layers or fewer) for thirty (30) consecutive days.

au Offline Echotech

  • *
  • Zombie Apprentice
  • ********
    • Posts: 11,361
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #5 on: November 16, 2025, 11:38:13 PM
Some lovely examples J2000E  :like:

The springs on the 1908's are usually real nail breakers  :ahhh but beautiful knives

For anyone interested in learning more about solider knives and their variants,  I highly recommend this site

https://www.couteaux-du-soldat-suisse.ch/J01/index.php/en/

 :cheers:

Merit Badges Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a Victorinox Cadet and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. For 30 consecutive days carry a SAK with a magnifying glass, and post a picture every day in the designated thread. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry at least one green edc item, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a SAK, duct tape, and paperclip, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of  a Opinel  knife  for 30 days Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Vic Spirit MT for sixty (60) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Alox SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. Carry an orange item and post a picture of it everyday for 30 days. Participate and post a pic of your vintage SAK (1986 or earlier) everyday for 30 days. Participate in a challenge thread and post a photo of a SAK Cybertool (any variant), Swisschamp, Champion or Toolchest for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the multitool for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of a different SAK each day for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Buck 112 Ranger for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the Vic Huntsman for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participants shall carry and use one Soldier knife, the model of their choosing, for the duration of the 90 days and post a picture each day. Participate  in a Challenge thread and post a photo of a LM Pocket Survival Tool for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Delemont SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. In this challenge,  carry one(1) Pliers-based or Non-pliers multitool that we always have prejudice against, hate or even fear and post a picture everyday for 30 days Start a new thread and post a photo of the leatherman (supertool, core, hacks) for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the minimal sak (2 layers or fewer) for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the multitool for thirty (30) consecutive days.

us Offline Farmer X

  • *
  • Zombie Apprentice
  • ********
    • Posts: 13,744
  • Master of the unexciting
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #6 on: November 17, 2025, 03:57:36 AM
A nice Soldat duo! :tu: The sharpened screwdriver side on the 1951 could be advantageous. And it looks like the 1908 may have had a pin replaced? :think:
USN 2000-2006

Culling of the knife and multi herds in progress...

If I pay five figures for something, it better have wings or a foundation!
Merit Badges Participants shall carry and use one Soldier knife, the model of their choosing, for the duration of the 90 days and post a picture each day. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Farmer X SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Delemont SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. Must put something in order and provide link to the post. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry at least one black edc item, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days.  Carry tools with single functions only. No multi-tools, no multi-layer Swiss Army Knives, no combo one-piece tools and post a photo for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread or Post in a Challenge Thread and post a photo of a Spartan  for 30 days Start a new thread with photos of at least 6 SAKs of different frame lengths and/or shapes in your collection. Eg 58mm, 74mm, 84mm regular, 84mm slim, 85mm etc Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of a SAK-alike, aka multi-layered, knife-based pocket tools for thirty (30) consecutive days. Find him! Participate in a Challenge thread, carry knife/tool with a blade 4" or longer, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry at least one green edc item, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a Victorinox Hiker, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Must start a thread with a photo of at least five (5) of your watches Build your own version of an MRE using off-the-shelf components, post a photo of the completed MRE and store at room temperature for 6 days or more. Consume the MRE after the storage period and post pictures and descriptions of the contents. Take part in the christmas pool or a rak type giveaway. Those wanting to say thank you for a rak may also nominate for the santa. Participate in a Challenge and post a photo of a Utility Knife for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in a Challenge thread and post a photo of a LM Pocket Survival Tool for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the multitool for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the pen for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread with photos of your zip ties in use

us Offline Myron

  • *
  • No Life Club
  • ******
    • Posts: 2,394
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #7 on: November 17, 2025, 05:23:47 PM
Great pictures!  I love both these models, but as Echo points out the M1908's can be quite the stiff nail breakers.  The M1951 much more pocket friendly, and represents a very fun collecting challenge, especially as it overlapped with the M1961, staying in production through 1964.  Fun stuff!

Myron
Merit Badges Participants shall carry and use one Soldier knife, the model of their choosing, for the duration of the 90 days and post a picture each day. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of an Old Cross SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a SAK Soldier for thirty (30) consecutive days. Take part in the christmas pool or a rak type giveaway. Those wanting to say thank you for a rak may also nominate for the santa. Start a new thread with a photo showing the Swiss Army Knife   Toothpick being used in an unusual way. Start a new thread with photos of at least 5 different 111mm models in your collection Start a new thread and post a picture of a fish or fishing kit with a multitool Must start a thread with a photo of your birth year SAK Start a thread with photos of at least twelve different colored ALOX models in your collection Start a new thread with a photo of your custom ALOX with scissors Must post a step by step pictorial of a knife or multitool modification (scale swap not included) Start a new thread with a photo showing the Hook in use Start a new thread demonstrating paracord knot tying Must start a thread with a photo of at least five (5) of your watches

au Offline Huntsman

  • Global Moderator
  • *
  • Absolutely No Life Club
  • *
    • Posts: 5,541
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #8 on: November 18, 2025, 12:15:37 AM
Fabulous post - J2000E

Right up my street - The evolution of SAKs is my thing

Good luck with finding the birth year SAK
Merit Badges Must update or add a page on SAKWiki Start a new thread with photos of a Japanese made PST in your collection Take part in the christmas pool or a rak type giveaway. Those wanting to say thank you for a rak may also nominate for the santa. Start a thread with photos of at least 1 MTO branded tool in your collection Start a new thread with a photo of your custom ALOX with scissors Must buy an item through the MTo Store Post your pocket dump photos then challenge two more members who must post their pocket dump photos within 24hrs for you to get the badge. Must post a step by step pictorial of a knife or multitool modification (scale swap not included) Must start a thread with a photo of your birth year SAK Must start a thread showing a photo of at least three BO tools Start a thread with photos of at least eight different colored ALOX models in your collection Start a new thread and post a photo of a flashlight as part of your EDC Start a thread with a photo of a repair you made with duct tape Start a new thread with a photo of custom or non standard SAK scales in your collection Must put something in order and provide link to the post.

au Offline Huntsman

  • Global Moderator
  • *
  • Absolutely No Life Club
  • *
    • Posts: 5,541
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #9 on: November 18, 2025, 12:20:35 AM
PS. And  those are two lovely examples of old Soldiers in great shape
I have one 1908 a Wenger '42 - So, like yours, it's fascinating to me that these SAKs were built in Switzerland, when Europe was at war!

And yes the springs on the biggie are very tough and it's surprising how much heavier it is!
Merit Badges Must update or add a page on SAKWiki Start a new thread with photos of a Japanese made PST in your collection Take part in the christmas pool or a rak type giveaway. Those wanting to say thank you for a rak may also nominate for the santa. Start a thread with photos of at least 1 MTO branded tool in your collection Start a new thread with a photo of your custom ALOX with scissors Must buy an item through the MTo Store Post your pocket dump photos then challenge two more members who must post their pocket dump photos within 24hrs for you to get the badge. Must post a step by step pictorial of a knife or multitool modification (scale swap not included) Must start a thread with a photo of your birth year SAK Must start a thread showing a photo of at least three BO tools Start a thread with photos of at least eight different colored ALOX models in your collection Start a new thread and post a photo of a flashlight as part of your EDC Start a thread with a photo of a repair you made with duct tape Start a new thread with a photo of custom or non standard SAK scales in your collection Must put something in order and provide link to the post.

us Offline cody6268

  • Absolutely No Life Club
  • *******
    • Posts: 6,230
Re: 1908 vs 1951 Soldat comparison
Reply #10 on: November 20, 2025, 11:46:15 PM
Nice pair!

When I first got my beater 1941, I ripped out one of my fingernails trying to open the screwdriver. That knife has to have the strongest springs out of all the knives in my collection. Oiling and cleaning made things better, but it's still strong on all four tools.
Merit Badges Participate in a Challenge thread, carry a Buck knife or tool, and post a photo every day for 30 consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge and post a photo of a Utility Knife for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread with photos of your chainsaws Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of a SAK-alike, aka multi-layered, knife-based pocket tools for thirty (30) consecutive days. In this challenge,  carry one(1) Pliers-based or Non-pliers multitool that we always have prejudice against, hate or even fear and post a picture everyday for 30 days Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of a 'folding hunter' knife that isn't a Buck 110 for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate and contribute in Challenge thread and post a photo of either an Axe, MT/Folding knife or Fixed blade (picked at the beginning of challenge) for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a Challenge thread and post a photo of a Spyderco knife for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread with photos of your titanium gear with a multitool or sak Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a SAK Soldier for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate in a challenge thread and post a photo of a SAK Cybertool (any variant), Swisschamp, Champion or Toolchest for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Fieldmaster SAK for thirty (30) consecutive days. Participate  in Challenge thread and post a photo of a Buck 112 Ranger for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the 110 knife for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the leatherman (supertool, core, hacks) for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the multitool for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the multitool for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of a flashlight as part of your EDC Start a new thread and post a photo of a traditional folder for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread and post a photo of the Vic Huntsman for thirty (30) consecutive days. Start a new thread with photos of your zip ties in use

Pages: 1   Go Up
 

Donations
Operational Funds

Help us keep the Unworkable working!
Donate with PayPal!
April Goal: $300.00
Due Date: Apr 30
Total Receipts: $155.65
PayPal Fees: $9.15
Net Balance: $146.50
Below Goal: $153.50
Site Currency: USD
49% 
April Donations

Community Links
Multitool.org
Multitool Gallery
Multitool Encyclopedia
SAKWiki
Swiss Army Knights

Powered by EzPortal