The best "bare bones" SAK.
-
@NutSAK said:
The Soldier and Waiter are great minimalist SAKs, as mentioned.I would also recommend:
Compact
Cadet
Cadet II
ExecutiveThe SAKofNuts speaks the truth. Those are all extremely capable for their size.
In particular, the Compact is one of my favorites for urban EDC; the Executive is much the same, only smaller.
My absolute best-bang-for-the-buck space-efficient SAK is an oddball one I got off eBay: an Executive with smooth alox scales. About as thin as a cellidor Classic, but with large and small knife blades, scissors, nail file, "orange peeler" (short serrated blade and small flat screwdriver, plus a sharp notch cutter that's great for cutting taped packages). I forget what Vic called that model, but they didn't make that many, especially in the smooth scales. Prolly a collector's item, but it's just too damn handy to NOT carry.
-
@Gryffin said:
My absolute best-bang-for-the-buck space-efficient SAK is an oddball one I got off eBay: an Executive with smooth alox scales. About as thin as a cellidor Classic, but with large and small knife blades, scissors, nail file, "orange peeler" (short serrated blade and small flat screwdriver, plus a sharp notch cutter that's great for cutting taped packages). I forget what Vic called that model, but they didn't make that many, especially in the smooth scales. Prolly a collector's item, but it's just too damn handy to NOT carry.Got a picture of that one?
-
I believe he is referring to the Director.
Bottom picture:
http://www.sosakonline.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=155&Itemid=35
Def
-
It would be an Executive if it is smooth alox. Look at the "Alcoa" knife on the left of that bottom picture. Aren't the Directors all stainless?
-
I like the Recruit. I have a Wenger Standard Issue, and it's great, but I never really need an awl. I like the Recruit's small blade to go along with it's main blade, and I LOVE the way the Red scaled SAKs' thinner blades slice. Much better then the more robust Alox models. Bare bones? Recruit all the way.
-
My absolute best-bang-for-the-buck space-efficient SAK is an oddball one I got off eBay: an Executive with smooth alox scales. About as thin as a cellidor Classic, but with large and small knife blades, scissors, nail file, "orange peeler" (short serrated blade and small flat screwdriver, plus a sharp notch cutter that's great for cutting taped packages). I forget what Vic called that model, but they didn't make that many, especially in the smooth scales. Prolly a collector's item, but it's just too damn handy to NOT carry.
Got a picture of that one?
Nope, and my camera's in the shop, unforunately. I'll try to remember to post a shot of it when Canon send my camera back.
-
@NutSAK said:
It would be an Executive if it is smooth alox. Look at the "Alcoa" knife on the left of that bottom picture. Aren't the Directors all stainless?Correctomundo! Mine's definitely not stainless. That Alcan knife looks like mine, except mine has plain silver alox scales, with no ad logo, just an anodized red Vic crest on one side.
-
My favorite 'bare bones' would be:
Farmer
Rucksack
Rambler
Victorinox Nylon Solo Plus The latest add to the list is from Felinevet and is amazing/
Bantam Alox I call it 'the Corona Special' Pop the Cap, slice the lime! -
Good to see you hangin out here Peter!
Def
-
Thanks Def! There is a lot of information here. I need to visit more regularly.
-
This is the best place to hang out Peter stick around and find out for yourself!
-
best minimal sak has got to be a lumberjack, and the alox one will be even cooler
-
Alox Bantam
-
Of current models, I would have to say the Compact or the Rambler. If including discontinued models, the Voyageur was the best.
-
It's hard to beat a Compact for how thin it is and all the tools you get in it. The scissors and the pen make it a must have and the unique nail file in the hook is great also
-
have to agree on the Compact which has the hook/file my Golfer lacked (still loved it though!). -
I don't have any of those but I agree with Soldier and Waiter.
Soldier as the absolut basics in a very beautiful form. Cutting, drilling, prying, scraping, screwdrivers.
Waiter even simpler but complete. Cut, light prying, scrape with corkscrew, drill plastic, wtv -
Agree that the Compact or Soldier are great knives that work way above their weight. Carrying something different in a minimalist SAK today a 108mm Solo Plus.

-
On any given day, what I need is usually substantially more than what most 'barebones' SAKs would have.
I need the woodsaw, almost every day. I also need a Phillips screwdriver and generally favour the inline over the back layer version, because having the corkscrew gives me a marlinspike and the ability to fix a colleague's glasses.
This requirement alone means most of the thinner SAKs are off the list, so I guess a Huntsman Lite or maybe an old Woodsman would tick the boxes... But then I've started finding the scissors and pliers getting more frequent use too - And this is why I started buying lots of SAKs! :D -
I find the Victorinox scissors to be one of the most useful SAK tools, but I don’t have a Compact yet. So my “bare bones” SAKs are the Pioneer X, Super Tinker, and Climber.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



