Lynn's First SAK Mod Build
-
@Sparky415 said:
But the clever SAK modders on here might have better advice
Dunno about clever, but my advice would be to go slowly with a light touch and check often. I've never felt that shims are necessary.
-
@Vidar said:
This is interesting to follow.
@Lynn LeFey said:
Oh... and it wouldn't help to replace the aluminum liners with brass, because then the stainless steel would be less noble than the brass, and the corrosion would most likely affect the stainless steel. So...

Brass contains significant amounts of zinc, so chances are that the zinc in the brass would be eaten away first. Hence the general rule to avoid using brass submerged in seawater. (As opposed to some bronzes which are very good for just that).
With galvanic corrosion the relative surface sizes of the metals matter a lot too in practical terms. So you can for instance use stainless steel nuts and bolts to hold together aluminium constructions, but the other way around would be bad.
According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galvanic_corrosion#Galvanic_series, brass has a lower anodic index than aluminium so the aluminium will corrode more/faster. I believe that the liners on older knives were not anodised, which would mean they're more susceptible to corrosion too. There may also be differences in the composition of the alloy.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I have an idea for peening, and want to throw it out there to see if it sounds reasonable. What i think I'm going to do on the first peens is the clamp the pin stock between two pieces of wood, then put an old spacer (probably one already broken) on top of the wood, then an old bushing. Then, peen the head into shape, and file flat. The wood 'should' hold the pin from slipping down. The old spacer is just there to support the bushing, and the bushing acts as the form into which the head is peened. If I break the bushing, meh. Get another used one. This should end with a pin head that is peened to the shape of the concave portion of the bushing. If anyone sees anything ludicrously wrong with this, please let me know. I'm really kind of winging it here. The pin in the pic below is not shown actually against the bushing, which is where it would be when shaping. Imagine this is after forming, and the pin has been raised.<a href="https://flic.kr/p/24vbgzE" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm1.staticflickr.com/798/40367944764_0b0302fae3_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
Just peen the pins into the bushes on the assembled knife. Build the knife onto over-length pins, then when it's fully assembled, position the bushes over the pins. You can use a spare liner to keep the bits in position while you work. Trim the pins with snips/pliers, then file flat leaving yourself 1-1.5mm of exposed pin on each side above the top surface of the bushing. Hammer away from there.
-
@hiraethus said:
According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galvanic_corrosion#Galvanic_series, brass has a lower anodic index than aluminium so the aluminium will corrode more/faster. I believe that the liners on older knives were not anodised, which would mean they're more susceptible to corrosion too. There may also be differences in the composition of the alloy.The question then is what brass? There are so many alloys called brass. What they have in common is that they contain copper and zinc. And zinc is the most common material for sacrificial anode use. (Just think of everything that is galvanized).
Brass is suspectible to dezincification where the zinc is selectively eaten away. There are differences between brasses - some additives help reduce the issue, and brasses with little zinc also have less issues. But unless one knows the exact brass alloy used, and the environment it will be used in, it might be safer to just use some better alternative.
Not many will store their SAKs in salt water anyway :)
-
Very interesting reading I might learn
how to do this properly with all these handy tips

-
This is interesting to follow.

@Lynn LeFey said:
Oh... and it wouldn't help to replace the aluminum liners with brass, because then the stainless steel would be less noble than the brass, and the corrosion would most likely affect the stainless steel. So...

Brass contains significant amounts of zinc, so chances are that the zinc in the brass would be eaten away first. Hence the general rule to avoid using brass submerged in seawater. (As opposed to some bronzes which are very good for just that).
With galvanic corrosion the relative surface sizes of the metals matter a lot too in practical terms. So you can for instance use stainless steel nuts and bolts to hold together aluminium constructions, but the other way around would be bad.
According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galvanic_corrosion#Galvanic_series, brass has a lower anodic index than aluminium so the aluminium will corrode more/faster. I believe that the liners on older knives were not anodised, which would mean they're more susceptible to corrosion too. There may also be differences in the composition of the alloy.
I thought that the only anodised liner is the one beside the corkscrew/backside philips (but not the one on the scale side).

-
Found info regarding this business of anodizing liners:
@MiniChamp said:
This is my first real post here on the MTO forum. I collect SAKs and I'm very interested in their evolution. I know this place for quite a few years and I learned a lot from reading posts here. Although I usually prefer to just read and learn, this thread touches something that I researched a little bit (by observing the SAKs in my collection), so it seems appropriate to point out what I know.While we are on the subject, I used to think that none of the liners on a standard cellidor were anodized, but the liner adjacent to the blade for sure is clear anodized (you can tell with conductivity test). No other liners are, but why did they do just that one liner and still do it currently? All current cellidor blade liners are indeed alox.
According to my observations, it's indeed true that recent (since some point in the late 1980's) regular-line 91mm Victorinox SAKs have exactly one anodized liner as Syph007 describes. It's the internal liner of the blades layer (namely, the central liner on a Spartan). The full picture, however, is more complex and is part the SAK evolution.
Victorinox used to anodize all aluminum liners of their 91mm and 84mm SAKs since around their official switch to aluminum liners in the very early 1950's (I'm not sure what was before then) to some point in the early 1970's (1973?). Then they completely stopped anodizing the liners of SAKs in the Elinox/Economy/Ecoline line. This change may have coincided (at least roughly) with the other changes that were made to this line around that time (change of tang stamps from big ELINOX over a crossbow to small ELINOX-SWITZERLAND-STAINLESS-ROSTFREI, change of corkscrew to a special economy version, change to polished openers, etc.). It persists to this day, so that except for the use of nylon scales, current ecoline/II versions of 91mm Victorinox SAKs differ from their regular-line versions also by lacking the anodized liner.
Anodizing of all liners persisted for regular-line SAKs until sometime in the late 1980's (1988-89?), at which time Victorinox stopped anodizing all of their liners except for the above mentioned single liner that still gets anodized on regular-line 91mm SAKs.
The next change involved only 84mm knives. They stopped anodizing all liners on all 84mm knives, so that current 84mm SAKs have no anodized liners at all. I don't really know when this happened. Possibly 2005, but for all I know it may have been several years earlier or later (I simply don't have enough 84mm SAKs to determine this at present).
As far as I can tell, Wenger never anodized any liners in their SAKs. This seems to persist for the Victorinox Delemont line.
I have no idea what happens with other sizes (like 111mm) of Victorinox knives that have some aluminum liners.
Finally, while I don't really know why they keep anodizing the particular single liner that they do on 91mm SAKs, my personal theory is that this is due to this liner having an exposed portion (next to the corkscrew/Phillips SD) that is visible and also tends to get easily scratched. Anodizing the corresponding liner usually helps to make this exposed portion look a bit nicer on used SAKs.
-
Thanks Pabs; I stand corrected.

-
No problem.

-
Awesome progress Lynn... can’t wait to see the finished project...
Hope you remembered to take pics of the parts?
Couldn’t find the pics I took for my master craftsman build, but here’s a pic of th parts that went into the Master Ranger build... just ignore the inline phillips layer...

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Pablo... interesting. Thanks.
However, anodized or not, the liners on that older Huntsman are shot. I'm interested to know now if the only unbroken one was the theoretically anodized one.
jaya_man... I posted the pics of the knives taken apart already in the thread. I actually used those pics once I cleaned the parts to reassemble layers already. I've taken apart enough tools (and forgotten to document parts positions) to at least not fall into that particular trap. But thank you for reminding me.
Hiraethus, thanks on that description of peening.
It was about to come up in my 'I don't know what I'm doing' list of questions. Saves me from looking (more) stupid. :DTo all, please don't feel like i'm ignoring your post if i don't respond directly. I'm reading them all, and taking them all in.
-
Next thing...
I... heh... I don't own a peening hammer, apparently.
And as it seems I've been forced into chemical warfare against my shower stall today, I don't know that I'll be able to get out to get one today. So, today, no progress.
-
That's ok we will wait

-
Awesome job! I have only done one SAK mod and after a couple years carry the scissors broke so I will redo that at some point.
One suggestion I heard here and tried was to put the brass pin in a drill then peen the end as it spins. Takes a while but then you get one side done outside the knife. You could even slide a bushing on the pin before you start so you know when the mushroom is the right size. I did not try that fearing the bushing would fly off!
I used a cordless drill with variable speed and it worked great using a small hammer.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Next thing...I... heh... I don't own a peening hammer, apparently.
And as it seems I've been forced into chemical warfare against my shower stall today, I don't know that I'll be able to get out to get one today. So, today, no progress.
Lynn seems to have lost the battle against the shower stall since we havent heard from him since... We are confident he fought bravely using his SAK...

Hey, that's an idea for a new useful tool on a SAK; a gas mask!

-
@Toppskarven . said:
@Lynn LeFey said:
Next thing...
I... heh... I don't own a peening hammer, apparently.
And as it seems I've been forced into chemical warfare against my shower stall today, I don't know that I'll be able to get out to get one today. So, today, no progress.
Lynn seems to have lost the battle against the shower stall since we havent heard from him since... We are confident he fought bravely using his SAK...

Hey, that's an idea for a new useful tool on a SAK; a gas mask!


P.S, Lynn is a She. ;)
-
Sorry for the delay in response.
Yes, Lynn is indeed a she.
Second, there is SOME progress but my garage, where I'm doing the peening work, is unheated, and it's been very cold here the last couple days.
Still...
<a href="https://flic.kr/p/25PTknP" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="https://farm1.staticflickr.com/880/41236010821_fac6911391_z.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>I am not all that happy with my work. I think I slightly bent both pins in the process, so... (sigh). I'm not sure if i should proceed as is or cut off what I've done and try again.
-
Those pinheads (lol) don’t quite look like they’ll fit in the brushings.

Maybe try peening while the pins and brushings are in the assembled knife?

What’s the worst that could happen? :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

Sorry... I'll start viewing peoples profiles and stop assuming..
.