Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Capability-to-Size ratio

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved General Tool Discussion
44 Posts 1 Posters 5.0k Views
  1. Home
  2. General Tool Discussion
  3. Capability-to-Size ratio
Capability-to-Size ratio
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • supratentorial Offline
    supratentorial
    Posts: 692
    supratentorial Offline
    supratentorial
    wrote on last edited by
    #14 Quote Reply

      @J-sews said:
      Okay, back on topic:

      I agree that the Vic Spirit is among the best (if not THE best) at cramming a lot of features into a small package. But are there any others that really stand out?

      How about the Leatherman Micra?

      I made an attempt to quantify "capability-to-size" ratio.

      Here's tools per gram:

      and here's grams per tool:

      From these comparisons, I'd say that the Victorinox Rambler has the highest "capability-to-size" ratio and the Leatherman PST and Victorinox SwissTool Spirit are tied.

      Here are the numbers that I used:

      And here's a list of the implements that I included in the tool count:

      Victorinox Rambler
      Small blade
      Scissors
      Nail file
      Screwdriver
      Bottle opener
      Magnetic Phillips screwdriver
      Wire stripper
      Toothpick
      Tweezers
      Key ring

      Leatherman PST
      Needlenose Pliers
      Regular Pliers
      Wire Cutters
      Hard-Wire Cutters
      Clip-Point Knife
      Metal File
      Wood File
      8 in. / 20 cm Ruler
      Can Opener
      Bottle Opener
      Small Screwdriver
      Medium Screwdriver
      Large Screwdriver
      Phillips Screwdriver
      Awl Punch

      Victorinox SwissTool Spirit
      Needle nose pliers
      Screwdriver (2 mm)
      Screwdriver (3 mm)
      Wire cutter(for wire up to a hardness of 40 hrc)
      Bottle opener
      Screwdriver (6 mm)
      Crate opener
      Combi-edge blade
      Scissors
      Metal file
      Metal saw
      Wood saw
      Reamer
      Phillips screwdriver
      Chisel/scraper
      Isolation length cutter
      Wire bender
      Wire stripper
      Wire scraper/round cutter
      Can opener
      Multi-purpose hook
      Hard wire cutter

      After I made the graphs I noticed that Leatherman lists two types of pliers for the PST and Victorinox lists one type of pliers for the SwissTool Spirit. I should have compensated for the difference but was too lazy to redo the images of the graphs. Even dropping one tool on the PST results in numbers that tie the SwissTool Spirit (see image below):

      1 Reply Last reply
      • I'm Still Bison Offline
        I'm Still Bison
        Posts: 3,592
        I'm Still Bison Offline
        I'm Still Bison
        wrote on last edited by
        #15 Quote Reply

          I don't know how it would work out in your calculations,but for a few grams more,with the PST II.you get scissors.

          I

          1 Reply Last reply
          • J-sews Offline
            J-sews
            Admin Team
            Posts: 23,224
            J-sews Offline
            J-sews
            Admin Team
            wrote on last edited by
            #16 Quote Reply

              @Bison56 said:
              I don't know how it would work out in your calculations,but for a few grams more,with the PST II.you get scissors.

              (I don't know how it works out in YOUR calculations either, but if that's a picture of you in your new avatar, I think you have more serious issues to worry about!) :P

              index.png

              In order to be certain of having the right tool for every job.........one must first acquire a lot of tools

              1 Reply Last reply
              • supratentorial Offline
                supratentorial
                Posts: 692
                supratentorial Offline
                supratentorial
                wrote on last edited by supratentorial
                #17 Quote Reply

                  @Bison56 said:
                  I don't know how it would work out in your calculations,but for a few grams more,with the PST II.you get scissors.

                  I also thought it would change things but according to Leatherman they are the same weight and (if I added correctly) have the same number of tools:

                  Needlenose Pliers
                  Regular Pliers
                  Wire Cutters
                  Hard-Wire Cutters
                  Straight / Serrated Knife
                  Diamond-Coated File
                  Cross-Cut File
                  8 in. / 20 cm Ruler
                  Can Opener
                  Bottle Opener
                  Extra Small Screwdriver
                  Medium Screwdriver
                  Large Screwdriver
                  Phillips Screwdriver
                  Scissors

                  Here's a new graph of tools per gram with additional multi-tools and an adjusted number of tools for the PST:

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • J-sews Offline
                    J-sews
                    Admin Team
                    Posts: 23,224
                    J-sews Offline
                    J-sews
                    Admin Team
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #18 Quote Reply

                      Hmm, excellent work Supratentorial. Clearly there is more to this than it first appears. One factor I see weighing heavily on your charts is inherent to the plier tools. The plier head itself must be strong, therefore it alone makes up a large percentage of the weight of those tools. A SAK or even a tool like the Micra with a lighter weight scissor head will compare favorably.

                      In order to be certain of having the right tool for every job.........one must first acquire a lot of tools

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • supratentorial Offline
                        supratentorial
                        Posts: 692
                        supratentorial Offline
                        supratentorial
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #19 Quote Reply

                          I wonder how the Wenger Rangers compare...For the sake of multi-tool science, please have felinevet send me one of those Wenger Rangers (with pliers) so that I can collect more data! :P

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • supratentorial Offline
                            supratentorial
                            Posts: 692
                            supratentorial Offline
                            supratentorial
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #20 Quote Reply

                              @J-sews said:
                              Hmm, excellent work Supratentorial. Clearly there is more to this than it first appears. One factor I see weighing heavily on your charts is inherent to the plier tools. The plier head itself must be strong, therefore it alone makes up a large percentage of the weight of those tools. A SAK or even a tool like the Micra with a lighter weight scissor head will compare favorably.

                              Tools per volume would be another means of calculating "capability-to-size" ratio but you run into a similar problem: The pliers takes up more volume than a scissor head, etc... Also, I didn't readily have access to the volume of each tool. :-\ The only way to avoid this problem is to compare each type of tool to similar tools (e.g. Rambler to Micra, or PST to SwissTool). But overall, the small Swiss Army knives have an impressive "capability-to-size" ratio.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • supratentorial Offline
                                supratentorial
                                Posts: 692
                                supratentorial Offline
                                supratentorial
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #21 Quote Reply

                                  The volume measurement may be a more appropriate measurement if (for instance) you are comparing a multi-tool made out of plastic or thin steel to a SwissTool. ...of course, a thicker steel will also increase volume.

                                  Since I wasn't up for calculating volume by water displacement... :P I did some rough measurements which included the lock releases on the SwissTool Spirit and the pins on the PST.

                                  It's late and I'm half asleep so I may have messed up in my calculations but it's about 4% in favor of the SwissTool by weight and about 4% in favor of the PST by volume.

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • Raukodur Offline
                                    Raukodur
                                    Posts: 1,614
                                    Raukodur Offline
                                    Raukodur
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #22 Quote Reply

                                      A better, and maybe more pragmatic way to do this is to actually look at each implement, and give it a point score depending on how useful it is in general and on average (you may get this info by looking at the thread made a long while back about which tools people use most on their multitools). Of course this will not be true for everyone, but it will give you a general set of rules to work with.

                                      Then you can count the tools on a multitool (maybe deducting a half point, or adding it on for an implement if it is especially well designed or badly designed) and compare that to BOTH weight and dimensions of the tool.

                                      The reason why I say both is because it is possible to have two really big tools, but one is much lighter than the other, or to have two tools of similar weight, but for one to be much larger than the other.

                                      I think if you could do something like this, it would give you quite good info.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • znapschatz Offline
                                        znapschatz
                                        Posts: 113
                                        znapschatz Offline
                                        znapschatz
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #23 Quote Reply

                                          @Bison56 said:
                                          I don't know how it would work out in your calculations,but for a few grams more,with the PST II.you get scissors.

                                          But you lose the awl, so it's a wash.

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • supratentorial Offline
                                            supratentorial
                                            Posts: 692
                                            supratentorial Offline
                                            supratentorial
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #24 Quote Reply

                                              @Raukodur said:
                                              A better, and maybe more pragmatic way to do this is to actually look at each implement, and give it a point score depending on how useful it is in general and on average ....Of course this will not be true for everyone

                                              I think you hit the nail on the head--the problem with assigning a score to each tool based on usefulness is that the usefulness of each tool will be different for different people. This isn't an exact science but the numbers give some indication that the SwissTool Spirit doesn't just blow other multi-tools out of the water. Using a point system like you suggest would lower the "capability-to-size" ratio of the SwissTool Spirit for me. I see most of the tools on the Leatherman PST II as "essential" but never use many of tools on the SwissTool Spirit (e.g. metal saw, wood saw, Isolation length cutter, Wire bender, Wire scraper/round cutter, Multi-purpose hook).

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • J-sews Offline
                                                J-sews
                                                Admin Team
                                                Posts: 23,224
                                                J-sews Offline
                                                J-sews
                                                Admin Team
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #25 Quote Reply

                                                  @supratentorial said:
                                                  .....the problem with assigning a score to each tool based on usefulness is that the usefulness of each tool will be different for different people. This isn't an exact science but the numbers give some indication that the SwissTool Spirit doesn't just blow other multi-tools out of the water. Using a point system like you suggest would lower the "capability-to-size" ratio of the SwissTool Spirit for me. I see most of the tools on the Leatherman PST II as "essential" but never use many of tools on the SwissTool Spirit (e.g. metal saw, wood saw, Isolation length cutter, Wire bender, Wire scraper/round cutter, Multi-purpose hook).

                                                  I agree with that logic.
                                                  For example, I suspect a lot of people ONLY ever use the pliers, a knife, and a screwdriver on their multitool. For such an individual, the ideal tool would be the smallest package that includes those three features.

                                                  In other words, for many folks, the Leatherman Freestyle might just have the highest capability-to-size ratio possible.

                                                  In order to be certain of having the right tool for every job.........one must first acquire a lot of tools

                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • Raukodur Offline
                                                    Raukodur
                                                    Posts: 1,614
                                                    Raukodur Offline
                                                    Raukodur
                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                    #26 Quote Reply

                                                      What I am suggesting would show that to be the case, since those tools you mentioned would have the highest scores, so the multitools which incorporate them, and do it well would score higher than those that don't or do so badly. This would be in relation to the size and weight of the tools, so a small light tool which incorporated the minimals well would score highest, as it should. Combination tools would obviously be a great benefit, since you get the positive score for both tools (maybe minus a half point each since they lose some funcionality be being combined) but lose hardly anything in terms of increased weight and size of multitool. Tools which are used less often would have lower scores, and so it would be a trade-off between the added points of incorporating the tool, to the added weight and size of the multitool for having incorporated the tool. For most tools I would guess that they still add something positive overall, but for some very rarely used implements there might actually be a negative overall score for having incorporated them.

                                                      Of course, this is easier said than done, but I do believe that if some time is spent, a rather general framework can be built to 'score' the different tools found on multitools.

                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • supratentorial Offline
                                                        supratentorial
                                                        Posts: 692
                                                        supratentorial Offline
                                                        supratentorial
                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                        #27 Quote Reply

                                                          @J-sews said:
                                                          ...For such an individual, the ideal tool would be the smallest package that includes those three features.

                                                          In other words, for many folks, the Leatherman Freestyle might just have the highest capability-to-size ratio possible.

                                                          It may...esp if we consider bit drivers as providing higher capability. Spoonrobot raised some important points earlier:

                                                          @Spoonrobot said:
                                                          ...Does the bit holder on current Leatherman models improve capability significantly or does it have the opposite effect since it reduces the overall amount of tools? Is there an overall standard or does it vary by person-to-person...

                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • supratentorial Offline
                                                            supratentorial
                                                            Posts: 692
                                                            supratentorial Offline
                                                            supratentorial
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #28 Quote Reply

                                                              @Raukodur said:
                                                              ...Of course, this is easier said than done, but I do believe that if some time is spent, a rather general framework can be built to 'score' the different tools found on multitools.

                                                              You're welcome to try it. There may be a point of diminishing returns but calculating volume by water displacement would also give better results. I'd be interested in seeing what you come up with. In case they are helpful for your calculations, here are the weights and volumes I used:

                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • I'm Still Bison Offline
                                                                I'm Still Bison
                                                                Posts: 3,592
                                                                I'm Still Bison Offline
                                                                I'm Still Bison
                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                #29 Quote Reply

                                                                  @J-sews said:

                                                                  @Bison56 said:

                                                                  I don't know how it would work out in your calculations,but for a few grams more,with the PST II.you get scissors.

                                                                  (I don't know how it works out in YOUR calculations either, but if that's a picture of you in your new avatar, I think you have more serious issues to worry about!) :P

                                                                  Not to worry ! It's only my yardwork attire,never know when the urge to tiptoe through the tulips will strike.

                                                                  I

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                                  • parnass Offline
                                                                    parnass
                                                                    Posts: 1,653
                                                                    parnass Offline
                                                                    parnass
                                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                                    #30 Quote Reply

                                                                      The following examples demonstrate the difficulty in determining a tool's capability.

                                                                      Both the Victorinox Spirit and the original Leatherman PST have Phillips screwdrivers. My PST's driver is more capable than my Spirit's driver because the PST grips the screw better and I can drive screws faster without deforming them as much.

                                                                      Another example is that the Leatherman SuperTool's Phillips driver is longer than the driver on my original Gerber palm-pinching multitool, so the SuperTool's driver can reach deeper recessed screws.

                                                                      Retired engineer, author.

                                                                      A man with one multitool always knows exactly which to use. A man with many multitools is never quite sure. - parnass

                                                                      Merit Badges
                                                                      Flashlight OCD Squad BO Tools Level 2
                                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                                      • supratentorial Offline
                                                                        supratentorial
                                                                        Posts: 692
                                                                        supratentorial Offline
                                                                        supratentorial
                                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                                        #31 Quote Reply

                                                                          @parnass said:
                                                                          The following examples demonstrate the difficulty in determining a tool's capability.

                                                                          Both the Victorinox Spirit and the original Leatherman PST have Phillips screwdrivers. My PST's driver is more capable than my Spirit's driver because the PST grips the screw better and I can drive screws faster without deforming them as much.

                                                                          Another example is that the Leatherman SuperTool's Phillips driver is longer than the driver on my original Gerber palm-pinching multitool, so the SuperTool's driver can reach deeper recessed screws.

                                                                          Good points!

                                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                                          • Grant Lamontagne Offline
                                                                            Grant Lamontagne
                                                                            administrators
                                                                            Posts: 68,016
                                                                            Grant Lamontagne Offline
                                                                            Grant Lamontagne
                                                                            administrators
                                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                                            #32 Quote Reply

                                                                              I agree that it's a good point, but that's also more subjective than quantitative, which is what I think we are going for here. If it's one thing we have proven here, it's that what works for one person really doesn't work for another. Many times I've looked at something and wondered what the heck they were smoking when they designed something, only to have someone else say how great it is. Of course it all sounds more in-depth than I think is necessary, it's still an interesting concept.

                                                                              We did something similar to this in SOSAK with SAK usefulness vs size, and that's a great concept, but as we eventually decided there, it boils down to which model has the tools you need. The Waiter for example has the absolute highest function to size ratio of any SAK available (especially when using Plus scales) and yet is virtually useless when you need to cut a branch or file your nails. Going with a function/size ratio often favors the smaller tools, but neglects the number of overall functions.

                                                                              Def

                                                                              EDC-TV
                                                                              SAKWiki
                                                                              GearFeed
                                                                              SAKSelector

                                                                              Merit Badges
                                                                              Charge Collector Reviewer Outdoor Cook MTO Tool BO Tools Level 3 Time Lord Level 3 One Piece Collector Airgun User Duct Tape Scale Changer EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Def's 50k Challenge Santa
                                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                                              • supratentorial Offline
                                                                                supratentorial
                                                                                Posts: 692
                                                                                supratentorial Offline
                                                                                supratentorial
                                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                                #33 Quote Reply

                                                                                  @Defender said:
                                                                                  Of course it all sounds more in-depth than I think is necessary, it's still an interesting concept.

                                                                                  Gotta agree with that also.

                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                                  Register Login

                                                                                  • 1
                                                                                  • 2
                                                                                  • 3
                                                                                  1. Home
                                                                                  2. General Tool Discussion
                                                                                  3. Capability-to-Size ratio
                                                                                  Reply
                                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  0% funded
                                                                                  • Login

                                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                                  • First post
                                                                                    Last post
                                                                                  0