Should there be new age multitools
-
I have time now when I just rotate all the multitools I have. All are quite splended tools. And there has been reasons why got those.
Seems I am quite much fan of old designs like many others as well in forum. Vic pocket knives and followers of original Leatherman. Both have created many new concepts during the years. But still old designs are strong.
Should there be new age tools? Or should LM and Vic just make proven concepts stronger with minor updates? LM is doing new models but Vic quite much trust to swiss pocket knife concept.
On my point of view, Leatherman have great ideas with Leap and Signal. Counter weight to digitalisation people want "non digitalisation". Kids to learn use of tools. Adults and all move in nature. Saw some wood, make fire. Cut some food.
Packaging have changed so things like cork screw, can opener and even bottle opener are quite rarely needed. Mostly there is need for knife and scissors. Screw drivers are still needed quite often. And with pliers you can do lot of stuff.
But yes, just as idea I thoughted. There has been usb drives in tools etc. But at least I feel tools are better without any new age stuff and digital additions. Pure mechanical solutions.
-
One could argue that cell phones are new age multitools?
I do like the idea of quality multi-tools which lasts and actually work when you need them, and a new age version would be a lot less reliable to just work after laying around a while. Within machinery the frequency rate for issues goes something like this: Battery for stuff that has that. Corrupted software install. Electronics failure. Moving hardware. Other hardware. Things with batteries, software and electronics tend to die way way before any purely mechanical devices.
And I don't see much upside to mixing them together? A hardware multi-tool for hardware problems, and then a digital equivalent like a smartphone for software and electronics related stuff, seem like a good solution? I don't see any major benefit from combining two ergonomic solutions to one less so?
That said I think there are still great potential for innovation and improvements within purely mechanical multi-tools as well.
-
I would love some new features in MTs, but please don‘t put any digital crap in there. At least not until we have electronics that need minimum user interaction to function for at least 5+ years. I know, i am dreaming.I would like to have a flashlight in my MTs. Not that sorry, dim light Vic put into some of the SAKs. A nice torch with different settings. Those things got so small these days, it shouldn‘t be too much of a problem to fit something like that into a MT.
I would also like a package opener on a SAK. That way i wouldn‘t have to clean my blade every other day, because it has tape residue on it.
I have no use for the can opener and could live without the bottle opener as well. The package opener would fit in that place.I am sure people here could and have come up with some really nice ideas already, but somehow none of those make it into a final product

-
Agree. Mobile is kind of digital age multitool. And with mechanical multitools I as well see there is room for development and need in future as well. Now example in EU there are new directives planned that machines should be fixable. Again that is possible MT usage [emoji16]
So good clarification. Seperate digital and mechanical. And again mechanical does not need any digital additions. As that area is changing fast.
-
To a certain extent it has already been tried, with the 91mm Voyage and Traveller. There's also the Cybertool, designed to work on the modern digital multitools :D for the most part though, I too prefer to keep the mechanical and digital tools separate.
-
@SirVicaLot said:
I would also like a package opener on a SAK. That way i wouldn‘t have to clean my blade every other day, because it has tape residue on it.
I have no use for the can opener and could live without the bottle opener as well. The package opener would fit in that place.Or you could just use the can opener on the SAK as your package opener. It works pretty darn well for that. Even works on fiber reinforced tape without cutting too far into the package.
Personally I want to see the Wenger wrench on a Vic in place of the magnifier or light.
And 84mm scissors.
I'll settle for just the scissors tbh.

Oh, and I want Gerber to update the MPT with something similar to the LM Rebar. I hate the Geber MP 400/600 series and love my MPT even over the LM PST.
-Wes.
-
Personally I would love to see more Specialized multitools rather than all inclusive ones... The Crunch, Signal, Raptor, MUT, etc get much much more mileage because they do a significantly better job at specific tasks.
How I think of my EDC now is that I carry a baseline set of tools, and add in a specialized one for the moment.
My Baseline can be seen in my EDC from last sunday:

The core Knife (with keys) and Vic Manager make up my bread and butter. I then add in a true multi-tool from there that fills in the gaps.
Cheers,
H.G. -
@Wessaen said:
Or you could just use the can opener on the SAK as your package opener. It works pretty darn well for that. Even works on fiber reinforced tape without cutting too far into the package.Personally I want to see the Wenger wrench on a Vic in place of the magnifier or light.
And 84mm scissors.
I'll settle for just the scissors tbh.

Oh, and I want Gerber to update the MPT with something similar to the LM Rebar. I hate the Geber MP 400/600 series and love my MPT even over the LM PST.
-Wes.
I could, but i really don't like doing that. I prefer the package opener like the one on the dime. I would just like more options in general. There is not the perfect SAK for me coming straight from the factory.
I would have to mod it, but neither do i have the tools to do so, nor do i want to do it. -
I see cyber tool as a good effort. And still mech tool providing just smaller drivers. Just a bit expencive and heavy for purpose. Maybe would be best as plain driver layer, maybe with pliers. But I like the smallest CT, could see that EDC. In there you need to think that knife is also a handle to drivers. Very small drivers and a big handle is not the best solution. I would like to see those small drivers in solution like spirit plus where driver set is seperate. Or in small sak.
Again combine MT and digital devices, vic has watch and usb drive models. LM has now thread with watch. Still quite basic watches but anyway way to combine digital to mechanic. Those I don't see as success. I had gerber fit having flashlight. It dif not take long when light was broken.
-
I believe that the cyber tool is as old as me? :ahhh :D
-
[emoji16] Well quite much the point. There has been quite much time but seems no upgrades example to CT. After vic got wenger I think there are lot of good designs. But not much changes to offerings. Again that is also positive that prooven models exist still today. But I could see example vic variations could vary even more. Well minichamp and small tools have some new (did not check how old is minichamp [emoji16])
-
The way I see it is a tool is a tool is a tool. Unless we live in a future where everything is printed, and we no longer needs any screws, nuts, bolts, etc, there will always gonna be a need for tools, and multitools.
But with that said, I do see we might be able to use "new age" material which tools could be made stronger and lighter, scales that are indestructible and self healing, nano tech to allow something like a voltmeter or laser projected ruler inside the scale. And if that day ever comes, I would freaking love to EDC a Wenger giant for 30 days challenge, since it may weights a lot less, and just a pure fun to use and watch.
-
Of course we should have new age tools. :)
If not, us collectors would inevitably run out of good tools to collect and have to resort to a shark-frenzy of junky tool collecting. :D
-
No not until we need to work on New Age Fasteners!
And the idea that we would not have interchangeable bits for those fasteners makes this a non starter too.
Combining electronics into everything just seems idiotic to me too?
When I need a light it is usually to see what I am working on anyway so having it in another tool makes little sense at all and I will ALWAYS have a real light on me anyway.Finding a way to include more real functionality into the form of tools we like now is another thing altogether and would be a worthy concept though.
The Cybertool is really the only tool with a different idea for a long time and it is no Spring Chicken at all!Keeping bits inside a Handle or in a convertible tool is a great idea if implemented in a great way and this is where I would like to see improvements along with tools that might cater to slightly specialized jobs as long as they are not at the expense of the basic jobs they should still be good for too!
I bought the Klien MT as it was cheap but it is almost useless it turns out as it has fixed bits for the drivers. What could they have been thinking there? How much cheaper could it have been to make that way in the end?
For example a tool with useful stripping and crimping for Telcom Work would be something that I would gran right away,like I already have with a few that I thought would work for this but ended up not getting the job done at all!?!?!
-
There's rarely a scenario where one size fits all. That said, I like to see boundaries pushed even if I don't want or need the items that push them. Gshock tech in a SAK scale? I have a couple of the SAKs with electronics and they are ok. Not my thing but neat enough. I also have the CTs which are very neat. I have to older LEDs ( red ) light SAKs and they are not good at all IMO. The newer ones seem to be nicer tho I don't have one to compare.
My KeySmart may not be considered but its certainly new age. Light, tracker, USB chargeable, Bottle opener, and there are some add ons from other makers
. I say bring them on and let the market decide. -
I would like to see a programmable remote embedded in the scale of a SAK. Opening a garage or a gate, lowering those pesky poles to access blocked streets. If I could leave the dedicated remote off my keyring, it would be a win.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

