The Nessmuk Challenge
-
hope all goes well Barry
-
Hope it's nothing serious Barry, best wishes for a healthy recovery !
-
Barry, hoping for the best.
-
Thank you my friends. It's my father in law. His health has really taken a dive lately, which has thrown quite a bit at my wife. I work out of town, so I'm trying to help out when I'm home. It's looking like the Spyderco Challenge will be my last one for a little while.
-
I've been thinking hard about my choices.
September is a working month for me, either home office or office setting with semiformal dresscode with a couple of formal days in the pipe.
Some homestead chores but nothing major planned.
Sparetime will be IPSC, hopefully some timersports like axe workouts and powerlifting with few date nights here and there.Currently I have 3 options:
-
Mountain man route:
As close to original as possible. So, a tomahawk (Cold Steel Trailhawk, I think), simple knife (Iisakki Järvenpää puukko, Whiskey Corvid or my Texas Ranger knife - this has flintstone storage in steath) and traditional pocket knife (Boker Johnny Reb or similar)
Pros: classic and period.
Cons: when looking at my calendar I can see that other tools will be used if my days shape out as currently foreseen. -
Tactical route:
Maximizing carry time, at least 2 with me (courier/backbag or briefcase) or on me all the time when dressed and active.
This would be Tops Microhawk, a larger knife than tradional puukko or the Corvid and 'haps a Swisstool or Swisscard as a pocket knife.
Pros: maximum carry time.
Cons: again, other tools will be used. Something with scissors would cut out normal scissor use though. -
Tailored mountain man route:
Simply looking at what I think I will be doing and what I might encounter. Not necessary maximizing carry time but usage in terms of time and times somekind of tool/blade etc. is used.
In this case I'm thinking of my spanking new Rinaldi Racing Axe, a simple true working knife ('haps the Mora that lives at the door pocket of my old truck) and Swisschamp. The Rinaldi is a full sized, large axe, but the Viking design makes me think that people have carried similar axes about as general tools and not just as specific tool for lumberjacking. Still, the manufacturer calls it competition level and it would be intersting to do whatever sessions I can squeeze in with it. A knife of little value can be (ab)used in situations where some other might not and versatility of good, large SAK is obvious methinks.
Pros: maximum usage
Cons: tools not available for Nessmuk or 'haps seen too heavy to carry on foot.
Opinions, views, comments as to me sticking to the rules and spirit of the game plus usability of currently considered choices mostly welcome!
Lähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
-
-
@Barry Rowland said:
Thank you my friends. It's my father in law. His health has really taken a dive lately, which has thrown quite a bit at my wife. I work out of town, so I'm trying to help out when I'm home. It's looking like the Spyderco Challenge will be my last one for a little while.Barry, that's considerate of you, after all family always come first. If you ever need to take a breather, always feel free to come join us for some R&R.
-
Hope all works out well for you and family Barry

-
@old Lefty said:
I've been thinking hard about my choices.
September is a working month for me, either home office or office setting with semiformal dresscode with a couple of formal days in the pipe.
Some homestead chores but nothing major planned.
Sparetime will be IPSC, hopefully some timersports like axe workouts and powerlifting with few date nights here and there.Currently I have 3 options:
-
Mountain man route:
As close to original as possible. So, a tomahawk (Cold Steel Trailhawk, I think), simple knife (Iisakki Järvenpää puukko, Whiskey Corvid or my Texas Ranger knife - this has flintstone storage in steath) and traditional pocket knife (Boker Johnny Reb or similar)
Pros: classic and period.
Cons: when looking at my calendar I can see that other tools will be used if my days shape out as currently foreseen. -
Tactical route:
Maximizing carry time, at least 2 with me (courier/backbag or briefcase) or on me all the time when dressed and active.
This would be Tops Microhawk, a larger knife than tradional puukko or the Corvid and 'haps a Swisstool or Swisscard as a pocket knife.
Pros: maximum carry time.
Cons: again, other tools will be used. Something with scissors would cut out normal scissor use though. -
Tailored mountain man route:
Simply looking at what I think I will be doing and what I might encounter. Not necessary maximizing carry time but usage in terms of time and times somekind of tool/blade etc. is used.
In this case I'm thinking of my spanking new Rinaldi Racing Axe, a simple true working knife ('haps the Mora that lives at the door pocket of my old truck) and Swisschamp. The Rinaldi is a full sized, large axe, but the Viking design makes me think that people have carried similar axes about as general tools and not just as specific tool for lumberjacking. Still, the manufacturer calls it competition level and it would be intersting to do whatever sessions I can squeeze in with it. A knife of little value can be (ab)used in situations where some other might not and versatility of good, large SAK is obvious methinks.
Pros: maximum usage
Cons: tools not available for Nessmuk or 'haps seen too heavy to carry on foot.
Opinions, views, comments as to me sticking to the rules and spirit of the game plus usability of currently considered choices mostly welcome!
Lähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
I think if Nessmuk is around to join this challenge, he probably won't limit himself to the tools once used, but will try to use whatever best suits his needs. I think he did search for the right axe for a long time and seemed to me paid most attention/money for finding the right tool, and did value that as his 'main' tool in woodcraft. On the other hand, he is a pioneer minimalist, so he'd probably choose nothing too excessive large or heavy.
So if I were him, and choosing to pick the tools, I probably will go with Cold Steel Trailhawk, simple knife and Swisstool/Swisschamp(or a smaller SAK than Swisschamp).
-
-
@Barry Rowland said:
Guys, I'm really sorry to have to do this but I'm going to have to bow out of the Challenge. We've got some family health issues going on, and I'm not going to be able to keep up with it. I'll follow along as best as I can.Sorry to hear that Barry. Best wishes to you and your family.
Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
Lefty, I see the challenge as a way to test either the old traditional trio or a new "modern practical" trio. I think it is all up to what you want to do with the challenge!

Challenges are only as much fun as you make them, so ...

-
@Barry Rowland said:
Guys, I'm really sorry to have to do this but I'm going to have to bow out of the Challenge. We've got some family health issues going on, and I'm not going to be able to keep up with it. I'll follow along as best as I can.Truly hope everything works out ok for you and yours. I can relate to the challenges going on right now taking care of my parents (and missed the Spydie challenge). These are strange waters to navigate right now. Gonna miss you in this challenge, Barry. Again.. hope everything works out for the best for you and yours.
-
Hey all, I'm sorry to do this but I'm not going to be doing this challenge after all, I'm going to take the sidelines on this one. I'll be sure to check and see how the challenge is going. Best of luck to you all
-
@Spartan19 said:
Hey all, I'm sorry to do this but I'm not going to be doing this challenge after all, I'm going to take the sidelines on this one. I'll be sure to check and see how the challenge is going. Best of luck to you allSorry to see you go, but I do understand and please do come visit whenever you are free.
-
After a quick chat with Nix yesterday I decided to give it a try even though it might not be the most exciting uses.
Anyway, here is my tool pick for the challenge
Axe: Øyo sporting axe
Belt knife: Cold Steel Pendleton hunter lite
Folder: Leatherman RebarHopefully I'll be able to get out in the woods at least once during the challenge.
Looking forward to seeing your picks gentlemen


Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
Good choices RF52!

-
I've made some heavy changes.
I've got a military surplus 111mm GAK on the way. It will likely be my folder. Modern, but will tackle everything I should need, including in the outdoors. One hand opening as well, albeit, the old oval hole style.
The axe is definitely gonna be the Marble's #3. Similar to ones available in Nessmuk's day, but updated to have a lightweight polymer handle and guard, as well as a stainless steel head (now that is something I'm not a fan of).
Fixed blade. Still not sure. I'm really wanting to use one of the ones my great-Granddad made; but for the most part, they're all 7" blade or longer. My great-aunt is supposed to give me a few more he made, and I'm hoping there's a 4-5" bladed one in that bunch. I've got a ton of Moras to choose from, and an Ontario Spec Plus Pilot's Survival Knife that'll be here soon.
-
Decisions, decisions..... :D
-
@Spartan19 said:
Hey all, I'm sorry to do this but I'm not going to be doing this challenge after all, I'm going to take the sidelines on this one. I'll be sure to check and see how the challenge is going. Best of luck to you allTake good care, Spartan! Check in when you can.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
