Favorite SAK by Layer.
-
-
- Bantam Alox, Waiter close behind
- Pioneer/Mod61 but more likely to carry a Compact or Cadet

- Climber
- FarmerX …or Huntsman :ahhh
- Ranger
-
Favorite that I have, or favorite that I want?
Goodness gracious.
- Have: Sentinel Clip Serrated. (Don't want to keep it). 1. That I want: Not a fan of 1-layer SAK's.
- Have: Tinker. 2. Want: Not a huge fan of 2-layer SAK's, but I like my Tinkers and Spartans kicking around.
- Have: Farmer. 3. Want: Uh... i like lots of 3-layer knives, have Super Tinker, Climber, Camper, Hunter. Can't think what I would like more....
- Have: (coming) Fieldmaster. 4. Want: Deluxe Tinker?
- Have: Ranger . 5. Want: TRADESMAN. This is actually my holy grail knife.
- Don't have. 6. Want: Late Craftsman with pliers.
- Have: (Under repair) Champion. Want: CTL
- Just Sold: Swiss Champ. Want: Swiss Champ.
- Not real excited about getting an 11-layer one, but hey.
-
@Sos24 said:
Actually, I’m thinking more of the Alox Bantam.Sorry Sos! I misunderstood your intent there.

...
This thread is so much better than any thread asking about your ONE favorite knife. Even if it does narrow the scope in some way. I can’t ever seem to whittle an answer down to one.

Even the what to grab in a fire situation...I mean I have two hands and can grab like 5 in each. :D
-
@kamakiri said:
Sorry Sos! I misunderstood your intent there.
...
This thread is so much better than any thread asking about your ONE favorite knife. Even if it does narrow the scope in some way. I can’t ever seem to whittle an answer down to one.

Even the what to grab in a fire situation...I mean I have two hands and can grab like 5 in each. :D
Speaking like a true SAKnight, not family album or pets, but 5 SAKs in each hand. -
@kamakiri said:
Sorry Sos! I misunderstood your intent there.
...
This thread is so much better than any thread asking about your ONE favorite knife. Even if it does narrow the scope in some way. I can’t ever seem to whittle an answer down to one.

Even the what to grab in a fire situation...I mean I have two hands and can grab like 5 in each. :D
I understand completely. That was li,e the question, which would you grab if running out to help a relative after some disaster. I just what is packed in items that I would bring, I came up with 5-6 different SAKs
-
@Jim the Brave said:
Favorite that I have, or favorite that I want?Goodness gracious.
- Have: Sentinel Clip Serrated. (Don't want to keep it). 1. That I want: Not a fan of 1-layer SAK's.
- Have: Tinker. 2. Want: Not a huge fan of 2-layer SAK's, but I like my Tinkers and Spartans kicking around.
- Have: Farmer. 3. Want: Uh... i like lots of 3-layer knives, have Super Tinker, Climber, Camper, Hunter. Can't think what I would like more....
- Have: (coming) Fieldmaster. 4. Want: Deluxe Tinker?
- Have: Ranger . 5. Want: TRADESMAN. This is actually my holy grail knife.
- Don't have. 6. Want: Late Craftsman with pliers.
- Have: (Under repair) Champion. Want: CTL
- Just Sold: Swiss Champ. Want: Swiss Champ.
- Not real excited about getting an 11-layer one, but hey.
Jim, which Tradesman? The Victorinox 111mm, or the Wenger 85mm?
David
-
Going strictly by what I have:
1 layer-Bantam is the only single layer I have, and it will stay that way. I really don't like them.
2 layer-Tie-Tinker/Spartan
3 layer-Climber. It was the first SAK I bought, and I still have it.
4 layer-Huntsman
4+-Deluxe Tinker. It really is a tiny bit skinnier than a 5, and wider than a 4, so I slipped in an extra category.
5 layer-Ranger
6 layer-Handyman now has a competitor, the Craftsman
7 layer-Champion
8 layer-SwissChamp -
- Bantam
- Soldier/Pioneer
- Climber
- Explorer
- Troubleshooter
- Handyman
- Champion
- SwissChamp
Fun topic!
-
Thick: CTL.
Thin: Executive.
No favs in between. Anything with pliers. I would almost take up modding to try to come up with an EXECUTIVE with nano pliers!!!
-
@SgtTowser said:
Thick: CTL.Thin: Executive.
No favs in between. Anything with pliers. I would almost take up modding to try to come up with an EXECUTIVE with nano pliers!!!
I would love to see that!
-
@SgtTowser said:
Thick: CTL.Thin: Executive.
No favs in between. Anything with pliers. I would almost take up modding to try to come up with an EXECUTIVE with nano pliers!!!
Have you tried carrying Executive + Knipex Cobra?
-
@Steelej1976 said:
I was thinking about my favorite SAKs by layer and it is odd that I prefer different styles in different layers.Great idea!
My 2p worth
- Bantam Alox 84mm
- Cadet Alox 84mm (Pioneer and Compact close contenders!)
- Pioneer X 93mm
- Huntsman 91mm
- Ranger 91mm
- Handyman 91mm
- Champion 'c' 91mm - discontinued - my first SAK from 38 years ago...

-
@nate j said:
Have you tried carrying Executive + Knipex Cobra?I forgot about the Baby Cobra XS. Thx for reminding me!!!! I was going to order one a few months back after reading of them here. That might be nifty.
I found a baby Vice-grip awhile back also, but I carry it in my utility waist pack. Here it is with my EXECUTIVE.
The Knipex Baby Cobra XS in a leather slip might carry quite well even in dress slacks. Thx again.

-
Nice thread

-
Waiter 84mm
-
Compact 91mm
-
Rangergrip 55 130mm
-
Farmer X 93mm
-
Ranger 91mm
-
Workchamp 111mm
-
CyberTool L 91mm
-
Swisschamp 91mm
-
Is there any SAK with 9 Layers?
-
Evolution S54 85mm
-
-
- ?
- Pioneer
- Pioneer X
- Farmer X
- Cybertool M
- Craftsman
- Cybertool L
- Swisschamp
- Workchamp XL
- Swisschamp XLT
-
- I don’t own any, but would likely be the Solo
- Pioneer or Tinker
- Super Tinker
- Fieldmaster
- CyberTool M or Troubleshooter
... I don't own anything past 5 layers though


I'll pick up a Swiss Champ at the next factory sale though.
-
@SgtTowser said:
I forgot about the Baby Cobra XS. Thx for reminding me!!!! I was going to order one a few months back after reading of them here. That might be nifty.I found a baby Vice-grip awhile back also, but I carry it in my utility waist pack. Here it is with my EXECUTIVE.
The Knipex Baby Cobra XS in a leather slip might carry quite well even in dress slacks. Thx again.

-
1 layer: Bantam Alox
2 layers: Tinker Small (for now... it's a contested category!)
3 layers: Super Tinker
4 layers: Farmer X
5 layers: Cybertool M (indoors) / Woodsman (outdoors)
6 layers: Craftsman
8 layers: SwissChampChoosing a favourite is like trying to choose a favourite colour... they're all great in certain applications and it's nice to change them up.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login