Partially Serrated vs. Plain Edged Blade?
-
I have a nice industrial sized butcher's steel that I use from time to time. I usually only use it on the bigger knives...
One other thing that bugs me about serrations in general, and not partial serrations, so I suppose it's a bit OT, but some of the tactical knife manufacturers have gone a little overboard with them. Cold Steel is a prime example. I love Cold Steel stuff, but the serrations are insane! It's like three little needles and an arc repeating across the blade. They catch on everything, they don't cut worth beans (unless you are cutting those pesky ninjas that keep attacking) and are a pain in the arse to sharpen.
Def
-
I prefer a PE blade, but then when you really need to get some dirty work done it's nice to have the serrated kind. I do like a combo edge sometimes but it depends on the knife. Serrations do come in handy though, I remember one guy whom I sold a Kerhsaw Boa too, he used it to cut a 5 gallon pail in two. He used the point to enter the plastic and the teeth to literally saw the thing in half, after all that was said and done, it was still very sharp. I will never forget that moment and my respect for serrations, PE is wonderfull but there are just some things you can't do with it.
David
-
@micky d said:
I prefere straight edges too, i think that combo edges are just too compromised, and that serations are fine for rescue knives or jobs where you just cutting cordage all day long, and for those poor sod's who can't sharpen knives ;) ;D
But I don't understand why she gets mad at me for using her honing steel...

Neither do I. Why would she get mad if you used her steel? How could you mess it up?
-
What I hate is when knives/multitools have a fully serrated blade, and a half-serrated blade, but no plain blade.
-
I hate combo blades and prefer to have one of each on my multitool . Combo edges are too hard to sharpen very easily .
Sparkey Spyderco serrations are very agressive and tend to snag a bit , but are great for heavy duty cutting and wont let you down , they are not very good at fine work . Victorinox serrations are the opposite to Spydercos and are more of a wavy edge and I find very usefull for cutting meat and rope .This may not help much but I use both and wouldnt be without either of them .Dunc
-
I use a Gerber Ridge (combo edge) as my EDC and I like having the ability to use it for both light and somewhat heavier jobs like for breaking down boxes or for cutting through the plastic bands that seal the copy paper boxes.
As for multitools, I thought a combo edged blade would be more beneficial because it wouldn't take up as much space as two separate blades and it would reduce the weight.
-
@Papacat said:
I use a Gerber Ridge (combo edge) as my EDC and I like having the ability to use it for both light and somewhat heavier jobs like for breaking down boxes or for cutting through the plastic bands that seal the copy paper boxes.As for multitools, I thought a combo edged blade would be more beneficial because it wouldn't take up as much space as two separate blades and it would reduce the weight.
While I agree with what your saying and this is usefull on smaller multitools I think on larger tools which have the room then one of each is the way to go .
dunc
-
Plain edge is usually the way to go. I carry both though. You just can't cut through a cardboard box with a PE as you can a serrated. Now if they could just come up with serrated edge that retracts (similar to the LM Ukiah) then we'd be set. Oops, just gave away a new product idea.

Rick
-
I usually tend toward plain edge myself. I think it's easier to sharpen, and it should be able to do all the same jobs a serrated one does (although it might be harder), but a serrated can't really do all that a plain can. But if you have room for both, great!
-
@Defender said:
While this may be handy on a single bladed knife, a multitool more often than not has enough room for multiple blade, and I personally would prefer a whole serrated blade and a whole plain blade to half of each.Exactly.
After getting used to my Gerber Suspension with its plain-edge Wharncliffe and serrated-edge sheepsfoot blades, I'd hate to go back to using a multitool with only one blade.
In fact, lately I've been thinking of getting a Buck CrossLock or similar for EDC. Unfortunately, the CrossLock lacks a pocket clip.
Anyone know of a small locking folder with pocket clip and one-hand opening of both blades, with one plain-edge blade and one serrated-edge blade?
Ideally, would have Wharncliffe blades or a Wharncliffe plain-edge and sheepsfoot serrated.
.
-
I'm also confused as to why on tools that have both blades, no matter what style the PE blade is, 90% of the time, the serrated one is sheepsfoot style. Can anyone explain this?
-
@Viper said:
I'm also confused as to why on tools that have both blades, no matter what style the PE blade is, 90% of the time, the serrated one is sheepsfoot style. Can anyone explain this?Its mainly for use as a safety/rescue blade . Theres no point on the blade to stab if the knife is dropped or the user slips ( good for use on a boat ) . But ideal for cutting away seat belts , clothing and equipment as the blade can be slipped underneath with no fear of the point injuring the casualty .
Dunc
-
Personally I find serrated blades a pain in the butt. I have a number of folders with either fully or partial serrated blades,a nd when I go to use them on thin items (branches, rope, wires, etc.) they "catch" and dont cut smoothly. I strong prefer a plain edged blade.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



