Advice Choosing An EDC Multitool
-
Hello everyone. I live on a small rural farm. I am interested in a multi tool for EDC on the farm. I keep a folding knife and flashlight on me. I want more functionality. I am interested in function over pretty. I am interested in a tool that is built to last. I am more interested in tried and true rather than bleeding edge. Tools I want include: plain blade knife, wood saw, file, various screwdrivers, pliers, pry bar, awl, good quality control. I am thinking a full size/heavy duty tool that is belt carry via sheath. I have been considering the Gerber mp600, Leatherman Super Tool 300, and Swiss Tool x. Thank you for the help.
-
Welcome to
Bigger and heavier doesn't necessarily mean better. I consider the ST300 my go to tool for adverse conditions, so much so that I had to have a second one as a backup in case anything happened to the first one. As soon as I get a storm warning on the weather radios the ST300 goes on my belt for the duration. The Leatherman Surge, however, is considered their flagship heavy duty tool and it has one hand opening tools. I also have an MP600 Pro-Scout that I'm using in the MP600 challenge that is going on this month (see Gerber forum) and it is a fine tool. If you go with a Gerber and you want heavy duty and usable ergonomic tools with one hand opening blades you need to consider the Dual-Force but it doesn't have everything else you wanted in a tool (no awl, or pry tool). Then there's the Swiss Tool. I have one. It truly seems indestructible, and has pretty much everything you're looking for, but the slightly smaller Swiss Tool Spirit is equally well built and more ergonomic. A Spirit has been my EDC for about the last 8 or 9 years and I have a second one of them in reserve too. Highly recommended.Out of your initial 3 choices I would go with the ST300 or the Swiss Tool. I would have a hard time choosing as far as hard use capability is concerned, but ultimately would have to pick the Swiss Tool for the variety of actually useful tools and because it has scissors. I have to have scissors in my EDC to the point that I carry electrician's scissors or a small Swiss Army Knife with scissors with me when I carry the ST300. I would suggest you try to go to a shop with a good selection of multitools before you buy one so you can handle them and decide which is most comfortable and has the best selection of the tools that you wanted. Or, just buy a Spirit and be done with it.

-
Hello and welcome to the forum !

To be honest, I don't have much experience with the MP600, which probably only has the one-hand plier operation for it, but you can't go wrong with the swiss tool or LM ST300, which have a more complete set of tools. The first one is fancier/shinier, the ST300 would be less expensive in the US. But there are other considerations :
• Does it matter to have the tools open from the outside (Vic) ?
• Is a one-hand opening blade a concern ? The Swiss tool upgraded MX beats the ST300 on that count, weirdly enough considering LM beat Vic to that game with the Surge)
• Is having scissors important to you (go for the swiss tool MX) ? Replaceable wire cutters and really good pliers (in general go for the LM) ? Serrated blade ? You need the LM.
• Do you work in a slippery environment ? Go for the LM
• Is rust a problem ? the swiss tool sounds better and easier to maintain.
• Best sheath ? LM in my opinion.
• Is the list of tools you gave in order of importance ? People here can give you good advice on which one of the two tools has the better saw, or awl, etc.) to help you in your final choice. I've heard the LM drivers are betterIn general, I think out of the selection of tools you propose, most people would recommend the swiss tool.
Even more people are going to tell you to include the LM Surge in your comparison.
And everyone here will tell you, half jokingly, to buy all three. Don't listen. Run while you can. Or start a collection and join the fun !PS. Some good comparison pics here : /post/950842
-
@Frenchephaistos said:
• Is having scissors important to you (go for the swiss tool MX) ? Replaceable wire cutters and really good pliers (in general go for the LM) ? Serrated blade ? You need the LM.
In general, I think out of the selection of tools youSwissTool also has serrated blade. (Regular serrated blade, MXBS models and RS model has curved serrated blades)
But i would choose SuperTool 300. There is few good reason why i would choose it:
1st: reason and maybe huge factor for people using gloves (like me) while working, this where ST300 beats SwissTool 100-0. Yes SwissTool has outside acces tools but you cant acces them easy as ST300 tools, SwissTool has good selection of tools but you need another tool just to open them while wearing gloves and i hate taking gloves of just to open tool, It seems small problem for someone but those who need time to time those tools along day it start annoying remove gloves everytime.
2nd reason is replaceable cutters, it doesnt matter if you accidentaly dent cutters, you can easily swap them. You cannot change solid cutters to new.Alltought SwissTool beats ST300 on quality and rust resistance, ST300 is probably cheaper but still very capable tools with solid selection of tools.
Reason for not choosing MP600 for this comparsion is that even it has fastest acces for pliers with one hand but tools arent after all so great, it has short tools and its missing tools you want like saw, yes there is version with u-shank but honestly its bad choice (u-shank blades are usuallu harder to find than t-shank) also it lacks awl and if we compare cutters solid or replaceable cutters to ST300 or SwissTool it cant acutally compete agaisnt those.
Dont get me wrong on this it has ok cutters but not good as SwissTool or ST300 and overall quality on new MP600s is lower than LM or Victorinox.
I have used all 3 tools (6 diffrent swisstool version, 2 of them being Spirit), 3 gen of SuperTool, 2 diffrent tool set on MP600 (solid cutters) i have tested MP600 with replaceable cutters but never had change to carry that tool (only tested little bit when my friend let me use it while cutting wires)
But if we add few tools to list like Surge, Spirit, CenterDrive or Dual Force (even it lack some tools) it would be actually harder to choose winner, since those tools have some features what others lacks, example CenterDrive and DualForce have have imho best BitDriver to use, DualForce pliers is great desing, outside acces tools, even DualForce misses tools other have it would be good choice.
CenterDrive has fast acces pliers like MP600 (just need better cutters) and outside tools like that BitDriver and large plainedge blade, it has file,serrated blade, awl and Pry bar w/ nail puller & bottle opener it lacks saw.
Surge has outside acces tools lile Blade, serrated Blade, big Scissors and T-Shank (comes with diamond file and Saw) you can find more options for Saws and it has same Pliers as ST300,even tho it has Awl w/ Thread Loop, Can Opener/Bottle Opener (this tool has really little use while working,
Large Screwdriver and Small Screwdriver, it does come with Large Bitdriver with Flat/Phillips 2d bit. Large Bitdriver is kinda bad choice since 2d bits wear fast and if you want use 1/4" hex bits you need extender what you need remove when you want fold pliers and make it compact again.
Spirit has great set of tools like Saw, File, Scissors (more mini shears than Scissors) Awl, Large Flathead/Bottle Opener/PryBar, Phillips, Small Flathead, Can Opener with Screwdriver Tip, and Combo Tool with 2 diffrent wire stripper, chisel box opener (imho its better than on SwissTool) it has all tools outside like on SwissTool but bit better to acces tools, those tools isnt still easy acces with gloves without removing gloves or using tool to open those, also Spirit has solid cutters. Quality is Superb like on SwissTool It has really good ergonomics but its smaller than other tools mentioned, not to mention Spirot lacks Serrated blade (yes mxbs has one but its curved with rounded head)
Spirit and SwissTool has OHO blade models what are nice to use, MXBS models lack saw.Bit long post but overall i would still choose SuperTool 300 cause its just have good tool set even if all tools are inside. These tools are also easiest to deploy with gloves thanks to all tools raising up while opening tools.
But this is just my opinion, best option would be that you could actually handle those Multitools so you could find best to fit for you, also see in live whatkind those tools are and how to open those tools that would tell what tool fit you and your work.
Edit: i would also consider Rebar, it has same tool set and same desing (also replaceable cutters) and its usually cheaper. It looks flimsy and cheap but dont let appearence fool since its actually really good tool (imho best option along SuperTool 300)
Only Tools Matters
-
Another vote for the ST300. The Gerber is fine, but it is somewhat inartfully designed with those inside-opening tools. The Swisstool is the the best made of the bunch, but its tolerances as so tight I don't know how well it would handle the dirt and muck of farm life. It would probably be fine, but who knows. The ST300 has somewhat looser tolerances on the tools that might be more agreeable to being dropped in the the mud and run over by a tractor. Leatherman has a 25 year warranty which can be handled here in the U.S. if that's where you are. Not sure about the Victorinox warranty nor how they handle warranty issues.

-
I’d agree with ST300 of your options. Rebar is similar I don’t think anyone mentioned it. Both would be solid options.
I personally use a Spirit X as my outdoor and farm tool. I find the Spirit toolset more extensive and useful; particularly the wire stripper/chisel tool, scissors are more like snips, pliers are robust, the screwdriver assortment fits all sorts of screws on tractors, mowers, other power equipment, and the file and saw are superior than leatherman in my experience as the file works well cutting through metals and still sharpens blades.
That said, if you’re working with a fence line and barbed wire the replaceable wire cutters are a highlight on the leatherman. I’ve done a bit of damage to mine on wire.
Also, I tend to use mine when I just need a quick tool or I’m walking about the property. I usually have a toolbox within reach somewhere either on a tractor or SxS.
-
I like the Swiss Tool X toolset better than the ST 300's, but the ST 300's pliers are better. And if I break a tool through misuse, I can repair the ST 300 myself.
-
Hello everyone. I was able to look at some various models. First off, I have short finger nails. I got to see the Victorinox Spirit but an old model. A guy at the True Value was wearing it. He said it had a serrated knife blade but he ground it smooth. He said he has used it for 13 years with no issue. It seemed well made, however, getting the tools out was a pain. I do not have finger nails so the combo of the spring tension and finger nail slots makes the Victorinox Spirit a pain to use. Another dude had a Leatherman Wave that he bought in 2010 for $50. I liked the outside opening blades on it, but that was it. The Wave has the same issue as the Spirit. Trying it get the tools out without finger nails is a pain. I have to pry the but driver up, then use the bit to open the tools. The tool is not at fault, it is my short finger nails. By this time, dudes are gathering around to compare knives and multi tools. An older guy pulls out a Gerber MP600 bluntnose. Due to its much looser tolerances, it was the easiest to use of the three. You could use the pad of your finger to open any tool. The Spirit felt like a precision tool. The Gerber was more like a "git it done no matter what" type of tool. The Gerber was clunky, would rattle , and those pliers. The MP600 felt like it would still function if I dropped it in mud. Dunk it in water and keep going. Dry it and oil it later. All of this from the local True Value while there getting a load of hay. I did not see a Leatherman MT300. I am curious about that model.
-
Before reading this thread I read the New Member one you started and gave a few options as well
Most here have already said what I said but here was my post in that thread :DWelcome to
A Supertool 300 would probably make for a nice farm EDC
if you need something a bit smaller then a Rebar would just be a downsized ST300
and if you need one hand open capabilities then I suggest a Wave or Surge if something a bit larger is needed 
-
Hello, I would suggest either the supertool 300 or the surge. I have carried the wave for years and just got a surge a few months ago. I think the surge just feels like a much more substantial tool and I am able to tackle bigger jobs because of it. The size of the pliers, blades, screwdriver, scissors etc are all much more useful. Especially the scissors. The waves a great option, but on a farm I think you'd really benefit from the surge. Plus one handed opening blades, file or saw, and scissors are helpful. You can also replace one of the knives with another t shank adapter (ebsy) if you wanted to keep a file and saw on it at all times. I keep a metal cutting jigsaw blade in mine so I can cut through steel or wood.
-
@BlindFarmer said:
Hello everyone. I was able to look at some various models. First off, I have short finger nails. I got to see the Victorinox Spirit but an old model. A guy at the True Value was wearing it. He said it had a serrated knife blade but he ground it smooth. He said he has used it for 13 years with no issue. It seemed well made, however, getting the tools out was a pain. I do not have finger nails so the combo of the spring tension and finger nail slots makes the Victorinox Spirit a pain to use. Another dude had a Leatherman Wave that he bought in 2010 for $50. I liked the outside opening blades on it, but that was it. The Wave has the same issue as the Spirit. Trying it get the tools out without finger nails is a pain. I have to pry the but driver up, then use the bit to open the tools. The tool is not at fault, it is my short finger nails. By this time, dudes are gathering around to compare knives and multi tools. An older guy pulls out a Gerber MP600 bluntnose. Due to its much looser tolerances, it was the easiest to use of the three. You could use the pad of your finger to open any tool. The Spirit felt like a precision tool. The Gerber was more like a "git it done no matter what" type of tool. The Gerber was clunky, would rattle , and those pliers. The MP600 felt like it would still function if I dropped it in mud. Dunk it in water and keep going. Dry it and oil it later. All of this from the local True Value while there getting a load of hay. I did not see a Leatherman MT300. I am curious about that model.I have the same problem with short fingernails. I will say overtime with the spirit I think I either just got used to it. I keep mine fairly clean and well oiled and it doesn’t give me too much trouble. It’s definitely not a gloves tool, which is also annoying and I didn’t mention that earlier. The Leatherman FREE series are easy to open without nails, but the P2 and P4 are out of production I think replaced by the overpriced in my opinion ARC.
-
@BlindFarmer said:
Hello everyone. I was able to look at some various models. First off, I have short finger nails. I got to see the Victorinox Spirit but an old model. A guy at the True Value was wearing it. He said it had a serrated knife blade but he ground it smooth. He said he has used it for 13 years with no issue. It seemed well made, however, getting the tools out was a pain. I do not have finger nails so the combo of the spring tension and finger nail slots makes the Victorinox Spirit a pain to use. Another dude had a Leatherman Wave that he bought in 2010 for $50. I liked the outside opening blades on it, but that was it. The Wave has the same issue as the Spirit. Trying it get the tools out without finger nails is a pain. I have to pry the but driver up, then use the bit to open the tools. The tool is not at fault, it is my short finger nails. By this time, dudes are gathering around to compare knives and multi tools. An older guy pulls out a Gerber MP600 bluntnose. Due to its much looser tolerances, it was the easiest to use of the three. You could use the pad of your finger to open any tool. The Spirit felt like a precision tool. The Gerber was more like a "git it done no matter what" type of tool. The Gerber was clunky, would rattle , and those pliers. The MP600 felt like it would still function if I dropped it in mud. Dunk it in water and keep going. Dry it and oil it later. All of this from the local True Value while there getting a load of hay. I did not see a Leatherman MT300. I am curious about that model.Gerber is easy to use and tolerance allows it to operate even if dropped on mud, like i said MP600 lacks tools you mentioned, if you go with Gerber i would look for Dual Force, if MP600 then modding it to have needed tools. But like i and many other i would choose basic SuperTool 300 since it checks everything you mentioned and if you pair it with Leatherman Removable bit drive (it goes top of Phillips) it gives ability to use 1/4" hex bits.
Only Tools Matters
-
Err, right place wrong question, that’s like asking which car manufacturer they prefer, some will never touch a ford vs some will never touch a Chevy, you can do a vote on here I’d suggest getting like 10 tools you really like and then doing a vote where everyone can just check a tool and give you numbers, then ask questions in regards to the top three and go from there,, but if you had to go from the three you posted I’d go leatherman,,
JR -
ST300 is the way to go !

-
@MadPlumbarian said:
Err, right place wrong question, that’s like asking which car manufacturer they prefer, some will never touch a ford vs some will never touch a Chevy, you can do a vote on here I’d suggest getting like 10 tools you really like and then doing a vote where everyone can just check a tool and give you numbers, then ask questions in regards to the top three and go from there,, but if you had to go from the three you posted I’d go leatherman,,
JRI thought you were going to say “right place wrong question…. Should be asking which one I get first” because we all know what’s going to happen

And our new friend got his ST and was gifted a MP600 so already starting off with 2!
But, the poll is a good suggestion.
-
Sounds like easy opening, clumping tools are important so I will revise my suggestion and say you should get the ST300. You can't go wrong with that choice.

-
@Grand_Banana said:
I thought you were going to say “right place wrong question…. Should be asking which one I get first” because we all know what’s going to happen
And our new friend got his ST and was gifted a MP600 so already starting off with 2!
But, the poll is a good suggestion.
Well yeah, if anything putting your credit card in a tote full of water and putting it in the freezer would be a good idea! lol..
JR
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
