New Forum Issues
-
  
-
@gustophersmob said:
Also, is there a way to go directly to the end of a thread? So far the only way I can figure out is to scroll all the way to the bottom of a page and click the right arrow, and repeat.You can change the display from oldest post to newest or newest post to oldest.
Best wishes, G -
Thanks, that does get me to the end faster. In each subforum, there are arrows to take you all the way to the last page. It would be nice if those were duplicated in each individual thread.
It would also be nice to be able to hide the badge display under each person’s post. Takes up a lot of space on mobile.
-
I want to start out by recognizing all the behind the scenes work on this. I've seen much smaller forum migrations that went much worse, so kudos for getting us over here functionally and mostly intact.

That being said, I'm also going to give you guys the laundry list, since I think you honestly want it.

Mostly dittoing other posts. New interface is substantially chunkier, but actually has less options and information.
There's a lot of dead space. Using a highly scientific method (SAK ruler) I think we're losing ~40% of the horizontal resolution. I'm not sure what it was on the old site, but not that much.
I don't see a way to change pages or jump to last post from the top of a thread (Gary's work around is just that).
I don't see any user adjustable settings besides dark mode. We used to have a fair amount for theming, etc. We also lost a lot of the information (post count, last post, etc.) from the profile screen.
The new badges menu can't be ctrl-clicked to open in a new tab. I'm 50/50 on the new unlimited? badge display on posts. It's nice to be able to show off more, but it does get a little cluttered for some of us with 3+ rows. I think the badges are one of the few things that got smaller, which makes them harder to read.
Similar on the new in-line preview. I like not having to hit an extra button, but can it be a horizontal split instead of a vertical one? Or expand to use some of the blank space? I can barely get one sentence on a line, which is weird.
Colors/theming are messy. Light mode is just kind of a bunch of hovering blocks in different shades of grey, dark mode has elements overlapping/split, neither one has a color scheme that's easy to read.
The new edit sort of combines both of the old modes, and I think is worse than either?
There's no easy way to get back to the thread when you're replying.
Good stuff!

The new messages view, (more like a regular thread) is nice, I like that.
Both the in-profile badge display and the badge menu are nicer to see/navigate.
Thanks for getting us here! I hope the notes help.
-
All of the notes help- from everyone.
Many of these are issues that I have fixed already, some of them multiple times.

Unfortunately a forum is like an ecosystem- change one thing and there are a lot of unintended consequences.

The good news is, the things that have already been fixed are likely to be able to be reset, so shouldn't be a significant issue- and most of the things you are all bringing up fall into that category.
Others are things that we intended to fix along the way. We had to concentrate on getting this forum running as close to the old forum as possible, and get all of the critical things (like Private Messages, Smurf filter and Merit Badges- none of those things existed in this software and had to be built from scratch) functioning- I don't think anyone would have been happy without those things (and rightly so) because these are the things that make us all feel at home here.
Rest assured, most of the issues that have been mentioned are already on the list, or have to be taken into consideration on how to act on them.
So, I ask that you all bear with us while we get all the details just so, and absolutely, keep bringing them up.
This is YOUR forum, and you need to be happy with it.

Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
All of the notes help- from everyone.Many of these are issues that I have fixed already, some of them multiple times.
Unfortunately a forum is like an ecosystem- change one thing and there are a lot of unintended consequences.
The good news is, the things that have already been fixed are likely to be able to be reset, so shouldn't be a significant issue- and most of the things you are all bringing up fall into that category.
Others are things that we intended to fix along the way. We had to concentrate on getting this forum running as close to the old forum as possible, and get all of the critical things (like Private Messages, Smurf filter and Merit Badges- none of those things existed in this software and had to be built from scratch) functioning- I don't think anyone would have been happy without those things (and rightly so) because these are the things that make us all feel at home here.
Rest assured, most of the issues that have been mentioned are already on the list, or have to be taken into consideration on how to act on them.
So, I ask that you all bear with us while we get all the details just so, and absolutely, keep bringing them up.
This is YOUR forum, and you need to be happy with it.
Def
Hopefully my comments don't come across as overly critical. I think you guys are doing a great job, especially given the scope of the task. I'm usually just more direct in my posts as I'm too lazy to type out a bunch of stuff.
Here are a few things I've noticed including those I've mentioned above:
- The content is cramped as everything is squeezed into a narrow column. This is especially difficult on mobile. ON desktop it's not bad. Though I agree with the comment about the community links and donations tiles taking up too much room on the right side on desktop. On mobile, the different links in the top menu bar get cut off and can't be scrolled to. This image is in landscape, so its best case. You can tap the badges icon, but log in/out is inaccessible:

- There is no easy way to navigate within a thread. No page up/page down, and on mobile there are only back and forward arrows for one page. On desktop, I see multiple page numbers between the arrows, which is better. It would be ideal to have arrows to go all the way forward and all the way back. A nice QOL feature would be a way to directly enter which page to jump to.
- On mobile, I do not see the camera icon to upload an image. I am able on iPhone to drag and drop, but it generates an error. This pic shows the lack of camera button:

This pic shows the error from drag and drop:

- Also notice in the above image the floating arrow bar. This shows up most of the time, but not in threads. It's there on the main page, subforms, the reply page as above. Sometimes it adds a little note looking icon with numbers in the middle, but I can't figure out what that's for. See the image below:

When I click them, it brings up a tile with nothing in it but a scroll bar. See the image below:

When in a subform, the arrows seem to advance forward an backwards through the pages of the sub forum, but the double arrow to go all the way to the oldest (right hand side) gives an error when clicked:

- There are other, more minor things, which I assume will get worked out over time for example, I don't see a way to view me or some else's post count.
One thing I love is that I don't seem to need to resize photos anymore.

Hopefully this is helpful. Thanks again for all you're doing to keep MTO running!

- The content is cramped as everything is squeezed into a narrow column. This is especially difficult on mobile. ON desktop it's not bad. Though I agree with the comment about the community links and donations tiles taking up too much room on the right side on desktop. On mobile, the different links in the top menu bar get cut off and can't be scrolled to. This image is in landscape, so its best case. You can tap the badges icon, but log in/out is inaccessible:
-
@gustophersmob said:
Hopefully my comments don't come across as overly critical. I think you guys are doing a great job, especially given the scope of the task. I'm usually just more direct in my posts as I'm too lazy to type out a bunch of stuff.Here are a few things I've noticed including those I've mentioned above:
The content is cramped as everything is squeezed into a narrow column. This is especially difficult on mobile. ON desktop it's not bad. Though I agree with the comment about the community links and donations tiles taking up too much room on the right side on desktop. On mobile, the different links in the top menu bar get cut off and can't be scrolled to. This image is in landscape, so its best case. You can tap the badges icon, but log in/out is inaccessible:
There is no easy way to navigate within a thread. No page up/page down, and on mobile there are only back and forward arrows for one page. On desktop, I see multiple page numbers between the arrows, which is better. It would be ideal to have arrows to go all the way forward and all the way back. A nice QOL feature would be a way to directly enter which page to jump to.
On mobile, I do not see the camera icon to upload an image. I am able on iPhone to drag and drop, but it generates an error. This pic shows the lack of camera button:This pic shows the error from drag and drop:
Also notice in the above image the floating arrow bar. This shows up most of the time, but not in threads. It's there on the main page, subforms, the reply page as above. Sometimes it adds a little note looking icon with numbers in the middle, but I can't figure out what that's for. See the image below:
When I click them, it brings up a tile with nothing in it but a scroll bar. See the image below:
When in a subform, the arrows seem to advance forward an backwards through the pages of the sub forum, but the double arrow to go all the way to the oldest (right hand side) gives an error when clicked:
There are other, more minor things, which I assume will get worked out over time for example, I don't see a way to view me or some else's post count.
One thing I love is that I don't seem to need to resize photos anymore.
Hopefully this is helpful. Thanks again for all you're doing to keep MTO running!
Disregard #3. @nate-j pointed out that I need to rotate to landscape and now I see the camera icon. Using that I was able to load an image without the error!
-
I like the new modern look. Good job Grant and Whoey.

A few issues:
-
Groups (user groups?) aren't working as expected. I can see I'm in both Swiss Army Knights and Admin Team but the Admin section of the forum isn't visible.
-
There's no way I can see on the desktop site to adjust some settings. On mobile if I tap my avatar (bottom right) I can get to https://forum.multitool.org/user/[username]/settings - I can't see anywhere on desktop that I can get to this. /settings does allow me to change them on desktop though.
-
in light mode, the forum name isn't visible under the topic title when looking at Unread or Recent posts lists. White text on white-ish background.
-
-
As the others above, I want first to congratulate you for the huge work that this migration must have been.
I have a few questions, mostly regarding read/unread messages. A quick survey of the thread titles suggests that the read/unread status has been carried over, but I don't see a way to jump straight to the first unread message in a thread (what clicking on the green button used to do in the previous version). And I didn't find the "unread replies" page which used to be my landing page (there's one that lists all unread threads but not specifically the threads I'm participating in).
Thanks again for the hard work! -
Is it possible to have the breadcrumbs (awlso) on top of the pages? Sometimes, if you want to go back one level, you have to go to the bottom of the page before being able to do thast.
The other option is just to go back to the root/index page.
-
Just noticed that in daylight mode, it's easy to see which threads have new messages (different font colour).
It doesn't show in nightlight mode, the font colour is the same in awl thread's titles.
-
Hey everyone,
I appreciate all of your input!
That said, I have decided to completely ignore all of you, especially.... Well, you know who you are and what you did.

Seriously, most of the observations you guys have made are things that are already on our list to address, and I promise I will get at them ASAP.
We are absolutely not ignoring your thoughts, I am just getting some work done at the camp this weekend.
I know, I know, what kind of idiot does a major software change and then goes away for the weekend?

This kind of idiot apparently.

I should be back at work tomorrow evening (Sunday) and I should be able to get onto most of this then. I'll also be at work for the next twelve nights straight, which should give me ample time to address many of these issues.

So hang in there, keep letting me know what issues you are seeing and I'll get on them shortly- like I said, most are ones that we already fixed but got broken either during the import or whole fixing something else.

In the meantime, if anyone felt like doing a few tutorials to help other folks figure out what you figured out, I'm sure a lot of folks would appreciate it!

Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Hey everyone,I appreciate all of your input!
That said, I have decided to completely ignore all of you, especially.... Well, you know who you are and what you did.
Seriously, most of the observations you guys have made are things that are already on our list to address, and I promise I will get at them ASAP.
We are absolutely not ignoring your thoughts, I am just getting some work done at the camp this weekend.
I know, I know, what kind of idiot does a major software change and then goes away for the weekend?
This kind of idiot apparently.
I should be back at work tomorrow evening (Sunday) and I should be able to get onto most of this then. I'll also be at work for the next twelve nights straight, which should give me ample time to address many of these issues.
So hang in there, keep letting me know what issues you are seeing and I'll get on them shortly- like I said, most are ones that we already fixed but got broken either during the import or whole fixing something else.
In the meantime, if anyone felt like doing a few tutorials to help other folks figure out what you figured out, I'm sure a lot of folks would appreciate it!
Def
Um, hey, hi, um, may I make one little suggestion? I even showed the Mrs and she read it wrong, but the “unread” subject at the top, I think the symbol should be diff cause I keep thinking it’s mail, maybe something like these hear, the book, vs the envelop the same but diff shape,, but you the boss, I’ll get used to it,,
but thank you!
JR & SR
📖🎬📎. VS .✉️📨
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




