Core VS. Swisstool PART TWO!
-
Could someone take a picture of the difference in how wide the pliers open. I'm having a hard time visualizing it (I don't have either tool).
Also, I'm assuming the phillips driver on the Spirit is the same as on the Swisstool... am I correct? I've never felt that the driver on the Spirit is "slippy" at all. At least, no more than any other phillips on a multi that I've used...
-
@665ae said:
Could someone take a picture of the difference in how wide the pliers open. I'm having a hard time visualizing it (I don't have either tool).Also, I'm assuming the phillips driver on the Spirit is the same as on the Swisstool... am I correct? I've never felt that the driver on the Spirit is "slippy" at all. At least, no more than any other phillips on a multi that I've used...
The philips on the Swisstool is 2-3 mm londer than the one on the spirit and it's got a wider head :)
-
Interesting review mate :)
Before I get into it, let me just say that I've owned a few leathermans (Supertool, sideclip, 2x micra's and now a charge :)) but no core, so while I cant compare like to like, I can compare company to company :)
Up until I bought my first swisstool I was dead against the whole multi tool concept, as due to my leatherman experiences I found all multi tools an ergonomic nightmare especially against the humble SAK :(
Not to mention the problems I had with my leatherman's, my supertool was impossible to use with cold numb fingers, it rusted constantly (surface rust only though) the medium flat head chiped while tightening a screw (no reason to as i don't think it was under a lot of stress at the time >:() and worse of all was the less than perfect fit and finist and the slightly rattley pliers and bendy handles ::)
My side clip wasnt much better ::)
Enter Swisstool, superb lock up and ergo's, no hint of rust, no chips or rolled edges to the screw drivers despite a bit of abuse from time to time, build quality on a par with your average main battle tank :)
In fact to take the tank analogy further, if the leatherman was a good workman like design like the Sherman M4 the Swisstool is a Konigstiger :o ,they both have there uses but I know which one I'd rather be in ;D
Now the Charge is a lot better than the old Leathermans I had, but even then I consider it inferior to the Spirit
As for the whole slippery screwdriver issue, In 14 years of Victorinox usage I've never had a problem with them, but maybe I've subcontiously adjusted my technique to compensate ???
Even so I'm inclined to belive that the slippery screwdrivers are just another urban myth :)
-
@micky d said:
As for the whole slippery screwdriver issue, In 14 years of Victorinox usage I've never had a problem with them, but maybe I've subcontiously adjusted my technique to compensate ???Even so I'm inclined to belive that the slippery screwdrivers are just another urban myth :)
I'm sure we all adjust, consciously and not, to the tools we use, but it's definitely no myth. Vic drivers slip. My last experience of direct comparison confirmed that for me once again.
Actually, for decades I have carried and use SAKs, in particular a Swisschamp and Tinker, both of which have performed very well. However, I don't expect SAK tools to equal dedicated ones, and treat them accordingly. Vic implements are good enough for the field expedient purposes they were made to handle, and over the years they have been so indispensible that I actually get emotional about them (a weakness of character, but I confess among the few who understand :-[).
OTOH, I expect more "tool-like" behavior from a multitool. It is in that mind I find deficiencies in the Swisstool screwdrivers. If I am to take on the extra weight and provide space on my person, the darn old thing had better perform to a higher standard, or what's the point? I'm well aware that other people may see things differently, but the multitool characteristics I want most are more likely to be found in Leathermen than Swisstools. If others prefers the Vic concept, that's nice and I wish them peace and good fellowship in life's journey.

-
@micky d said:
As for the whole slippery screwdriver issue, In 14 years of Victorinox usage I've never had a problem with them, but maybe I've subcontiously adjusted my technique to compensate ???
Even so I'm inclined to belive that the slippery screwdrivers are just another urban myth :)
I'm sure we all adjust, consciously and not, to the tools we use, but it's definitely no myth. Vic drivers slip. My last experience of direct comparison confirmed that for me once again.
Actually, for decades I have carried and use SAKs, in particular a Swisschamp and Tinker, both of which have performed very well. However, I don't expect SAK tools to equal dedicated ones, and treat them accordingly. Vic implements are good enough for the field expedient purposes they were made to handle, and over the years they have been so indispensible that I actually get emotional about them (a weakness of character, but I confess among the few who understand :-[).
OTOH, I expect more "tool-like" behavior from a multitool. It is in that mind I find deficiencies in the Swisstool screwdrivers. If I am to take on the extra weight and provide space on my person, the darn old thing had better perform to a higher standard, or what's the point? I'm well aware that other people may see things differently, but the multitool characteristics I want most are more likely to be found in Leathermen than Swisstools. If others prefers the Vic concept, that's nice and I wish them peace and good fellowship in life's journey.

I do take you point about multi's being more tool like, and like you I to get emmotionaly attached to saks/multi's (there I've said it) But i can honestly say that I haven't had a problem of tool slippage, but then maybe I don't use them as much, as I tend to use the cutting tools far more than I do the drivers :)
-
I use both, and have never detected any significant slippage in the screwdrivers myself. I'm not saying it's not there, but perhaps as you say, after many years of using and carrying SAKs, I am familiar (conscious or not) with the limitations of polished tools, and use it accordingly.
Personal preference is the foundation of a forum like this one, and I welcome the disagreement!
Def
-
My SwissTool X and Spirit's phillips screwdrivers require more clearance and don't grab fasteners as well as the Leatherman. The Victorinox tools would be the bee's knees if they incorporated the superior Leatherman screwdrivers. ;D
Overall, I prefer the Spirit and SwissTool X, but the Leatherman screwdrivers work better for me.
-
And the Leatherman diamond file as well...
Def
-
@znapschatz said:
could not work first a large capnut, then a stuck filler screwcap on a camp stove, both because the pliers jaws wouldn't open wide enough.The early versions of the Swisstools pliers opened wider then the newer version

Dunc
-
could not work first a large capnut, then a stuck filler screwcap on a camp stove, both because the pliers jaws wouldn't open wide enough.
The early versions of the Swisstools pliers opened wider then the newer version

Dunc
Oh, that is really interesting! If that had been the version I owned, maybe my decision would have been different. Or not. Why do you supposed Vic changed the design?
-
I'm not sure but its the same style ( although a little bigger ) then the Spirits .The strange thing is with the pliers deployed but closed the handles on the new version are slightly further apart . When you grip something thin you can notice this and the older ones are more comfortable.
Dunc
-
@znapschatz said:
Oh, that is really interesting! If that had been the version I owned, maybe my decision would have been different. Or not. Why do you supposed Vic changed the design?*That * is a good question, one that we have pondered for some time now. Check out the picture below; the changes were quite significant.
-
I didn't know that either ???, I'd be interested in an answer too :)
-
Bob if you dont mind me using your pic ( its better then mine ) I will email Robert Elsener and ask him .
Dunc
-
-
Email sent . I will post the reply as soon as I recieve it .
Dunc
-
Just got a reply and started a new post here /topic/2463
Dunc
-
WOW, I just re-read my review.. I had a complete biased opinion!
-
@Leatherman123 said:
WOW, I just re-read my review.. I had a complete biased opinion!Wise men always change their minds... ;)
Carlos
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



