A knife/tool legallity thread
-
This is it for the Canada Criminal Code:
*"prohibited weapon" means
( a) a knife that has a blade that opens automatically by gravity or centrifugal force or by hand pressure applied to a button, spring or other device in or attached to the handle of the knife*
Basically, no automatic knives (switchblades), butterfly knives or any folders with a blade that is so loose that it can be flicked open with the wrist.
Def
-
Here's a link that although as far as Ohio is concerned was last updated in 2005,should provide a starting point.
http://pweb.netcom.com/~brlevine/sta-law.htm
Don't forget to check local ordinances covering knife carry. -
I can only comment on Scots Law regarding offensive weapons and bladed or sharply pointed articles
An offensive weapon is anything that is made intended or adapted so basically covers just about anything from a belt swung about your head to a machette strapped to your back
The exceptions are covered by lawful authority (police armed services etc) or reasonable excuse work ,religion
Bladed or sharply pointed articles are self explanitory the only exception are folding non locking blades of less then 3 inches
again the exceptions are lawful authority or reasonable excuse
The reasonable excuse is a huge grey area your reasonable excuse may not be the P.F s idea of reasonable excuse
I personally carry a Wenger toolchest as my E.D.C -
Thanks for your comment's guy's, keep em coming :)
-
Something i forgot to mention that Def brought up is what we are not allowed in terms of knives (not allowed to sell/hire/buy)
* Flick knives
* Automatics
* Switchblades
* Balisong
* Butterfly
Non of the above are legal to acquire (or sell) but i believe if you've had it since before the law came in to being that you are allowed to keep it (but don't walk down the high street waving it in peoples faces!!) -
Any idea when that law was instituted?
Def
-
For automatic and flick knives it was 1959, don't know about the others.
-
I am sure that in some parts of the UK (Scotland??) ANY knife that can be considered offensive is illegal to carry without a good reason. ??? I'm sure this was mentioned before. I'll see if I can find the thread.
-
@Roadie said:
Something i forgot to mention that Def brought up is what we are not allowed in terms of knives (not allowed to sell/hire/buy)
* Flick knives
* Automatics
* Switchblades
* Balisong
* Butterfly
Non of the above are legal to acquire (or sell) but i believe if you've had it since before the law came in to being that you are allowed to keep it (but don't walk down the high street waving it in peoples faces!!)In adition anything that in any way is or can be used as a baton, that even includes a tightly rolled up news paper is classed as a banned weapon. Another thing I have meant to bring up = any form of toggle bar is classed as 'a burglars friend' and is not worth the potential hassle of being found carrying one.
Although they say you can keep what you already own you can not under any circumstance take it outside your home with the exception to take it to a police station to be destroyed under the rules of a amnesty. Even then it is advisable to phone the station to ask them how to go about the carrying of it, letting them know you are on your way with it. I would say to not even play with it outside, were you can be seen by neighbors even on your own property. Also it is 'own property', I would not like to argue any rights you may think you have if you are in rented property. To be suspected means a full house search and the removal of anything they class as a weapon.
You are then given 2 alternatives sign a release for all the weapons in your house to be kept by the law or go to court to fight for your rights that you thought you had but by that time you wonder just what rights anyone has. The UK police work on a points basis and possession of weapons by normal legal owners are easy pray.
Guess what = I was bitten once and it will be my last I hope.Dave
-
@Benner said:
I am sure that in some parts of the UK (Scotland??) ANY knife that can be considered offensive is illegal to carry without a good reason. ??? I'm sure this was mentioned before. I'll see if I can find the thread.Any knife with a less than 3" blade is legal as long as it has a slip lock. All other knives as 'Roadie' said must have a 'good reason' to be carried. Any other form of locking mechanism is classed as a fixed blade no matter what blade length it has. Fixed blades of any kind are illegal without 'good reason'. There is no written 'good reason' you have to defend the reason you are carrying it.
Most multi tools could be illegal here because of the locks, some of the on board tools or blade lengths. Thankfully most officers see them as a tool rather than potential weapons. It is totally at their discretion.Being blunt I would not like to be a young black male with what I daily carry.Dave
-
Thanks for your comment mate, I think we've all fallen foul of ''over enthusiastic copper's'' in our time ::)
-
@Benner said:
I am sure that in some parts of the UK (Scotland??) ANY knife that can be considered offensive is illegal to carry without a good reason. ??? I'm sure this was mentioned before. I'll see if I can find the thread.:D It was one of your posts actually Mike..........
@micky d said:
Don't forget though (boy I hate being the voice of reason) I certain part's of the UK and specifically in scotland, you still need a good reason to carry any kind of knife, regardless if it technically legal edc.I know your all sensible lad's out there, so please don't think I'm being patronising :)
cheers
on this thread /topic/2271
Thought I was imagining it at one point.
-
I am sure that in some parts of the UK (Scotland??) ANY knife that can be considered offensive is illegal to carry without a good reason. ??? I'm sure this was mentioned before. I'll see if I can find the thread.
:D It was one of your posts actually Mike..........
@micky d said:
Don't forget though (boy I hate being the voice of reason) I certain part's of the UK and specifically in scotland, you still need a good reason to carry any kind of knife, regardless if it technically legal edc.I know your all sensible lad's out there, so please don't think I'm being patronising :)
cheers
on this thread /topic/2271
Thought I was imagining it at one point.
I remember it now, but after a while all the post's kinda merge in to one, or it could just be my age :D
-
So is that still the case do you think?
-
@micky d said:
So is that still the case do you think?
Sorry is what still the case mate?
That "in certain part's of the UK and specifically in scotland, you still need a good reason to carry any kind of knife, regardless if it technically legal edc."
Yes it does but only in the context, of where you are and what your doing, if your in a pub, it would be a no - no, if you were on your way to or from work it fine, it more of a common sence thing.
Likewise if you were in an train station and you had something like a UKPK on you, a copper could confiscate it and take you down the station, on the suspition of the fact that it's a weapon, it is completly legal but your average copper has just seen an aggresive looking knife and an easy arrest, you would probably have the knife returned to you but, you'd still lose half your day argueing the point >:(
So in short as long as your not somewhere inapropriate, doing something stupid, your fine :)

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



