Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Capability-to-Size ratio

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved General Tool Discussion
44 Posts 1 Posters 5.0k Views
  1. Home
  2. General Tool Discussion
  3. Capability-to-Size ratio
Capability-to-Size ratio
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • supratentorial Offline
    supratentorial
    Posts: 692
    supratentorial Offline
    supratentorial
    wrote on last edited by
    #28 Quote Reply

      @Raukodur said:
      ...Of course, this is easier said than done, but I do believe that if some time is spent, a rather general framework can be built to 'score' the different tools found on multitools.

      You're welcome to try it. There may be a point of diminishing returns but calculating volume by water displacement would also give better results. I'd be interested in seeing what you come up with. In case they are helpful for your calculations, here are the weights and volumes I used:

      1 Reply Last reply
      • I'm Still Bison Offline
        I'm Still Bison
        Posts: 3,592
        I'm Still Bison Offline
        I'm Still Bison
        wrote on last edited by
        #29 Quote Reply

          @J-sews said:

          @Bison56 said:

          I don't know how it would work out in your calculations,but for a few grams more,with the PST II.you get scissors.

          (I don't know how it works out in YOUR calculations either, but if that's a picture of you in your new avatar, I think you have more serious issues to worry about!) :P

          Not to worry ! It's only my yardwork attire,never know when the urge to tiptoe through the tulips will strike.

          I

          1 Reply Last reply
          • parnass Offline
            parnass
            Posts: 1,653
            parnass Offline
            parnass
            wrote on last edited by
            #30 Quote Reply

              The following examples demonstrate the difficulty in determining a tool's capability.

              Both the Victorinox Spirit and the original Leatherman PST have Phillips screwdrivers. My PST's driver is more capable than my Spirit's driver because the PST grips the screw better and I can drive screws faster without deforming them as much.

              Another example is that the Leatherman SuperTool's Phillips driver is longer than the driver on my original Gerber palm-pinching multitool, so the SuperTool's driver can reach deeper recessed screws.

              Retired engineer, author.

              A man with one multitool always knows exactly which to use. A man with many multitools is never quite sure. - parnass

              Merit Badges
              Flashlight OCD Squad BO Tools Level 2
              1 Reply Last reply
              • supratentorial Offline
                supratentorial
                Posts: 692
                supratentorial Offline
                supratentorial
                wrote on last edited by
                #31 Quote Reply

                  @parnass said:
                  The following examples demonstrate the difficulty in determining a tool's capability.

                  Both the Victorinox Spirit and the original Leatherman PST have Phillips screwdrivers. My PST's driver is more capable than my Spirit's driver because the PST grips the screw better and I can drive screws faster without deforming them as much.

                  Another example is that the Leatherman SuperTool's Phillips driver is longer than the driver on my original Gerber palm-pinching multitool, so the SuperTool's driver can reach deeper recessed screws.

                  Good points!

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • Grant Lamontagne Offline
                    Grant Lamontagne
                    administrators
                    Posts: 68,016
                    Grant Lamontagne Offline
                    Grant Lamontagne
                    administrators
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #32 Quote Reply

                      I agree that it's a good point, but that's also more subjective than quantitative, which is what I think we are going for here. If it's one thing we have proven here, it's that what works for one person really doesn't work for another. Many times I've looked at something and wondered what the heck they were smoking when they designed something, only to have someone else say how great it is. Of course it all sounds more in-depth than I think is necessary, it's still an interesting concept.

                      We did something similar to this in SOSAK with SAK usefulness vs size, and that's a great concept, but as we eventually decided there, it boils down to which model has the tools you need. The Waiter for example has the absolute highest function to size ratio of any SAK available (especially when using Plus scales) and yet is virtually useless when you need to cut a branch or file your nails. Going with a function/size ratio often favors the smaller tools, but neglects the number of overall functions.

                      Def

                      EDC-TV
                      SAKWiki
                      GearFeed
                      SAKSelector

                      Merit Badges
                      Charge Collector Reviewer Outdoor Cook MTO Tool BO Tools Level 3 Time Lord Level 3 One Piece Collector Airgun User Duct Tape Scale Changer EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Def's 50k Challenge Santa
                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • supratentorial Offline
                        supratentorial
                        Posts: 692
                        supratentorial Offline
                        supratentorial
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #33 Quote Reply

                          @Defender said:
                          Of course it all sounds more in-depth than I think is necessary, it's still an interesting concept.

                          Gotta agree with that also.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • Sea Monster Offline
                            Sea Monster
                            Posts: 4,261
                            Sea Monster Offline
                            Sea Monster
                            wrote on last edited by Sea Monster
                            #34 Quote Reply

                              Okay, this topic wasn't quite what I had in mind when I decided to look for a good topic to be revisited, but I like it none the less.

                              Functions / Blades x Weight = Usefulness?

                              (/ is divide, for those of us not used to using a numpad as a calculator)

                              Ignoring for now the relative usability of one brand's version of a Screwdriver, file, or whatever vs another brands', let us focus of Multi-funtion "Blades"

                              If a screwdriver is worth 1 point, and a cap lifter is worth 1 point, and a wire stripper is worth 1 point, I suppose a Vic Caplifter/Screwdriver/Wire stripper is worth 3 points? Four if it's on a Spirit, because they say it's "toughened for crate opening".

                              This seems to favour any company (Atwood? Frog tool?) who wants to put more nooks and crannies in a tool.

                              Most cheapo Multis have combination Fish-Scaler, Hook Remover, File, and Ruler tools. (Why did I say that? It's not even relevent to my argument at the moment)

                              Onwards!

                              for math sake, let's add a .25 point reduction in worth for each addition "Function" in a blade.
                              So a Two-Function blade is worth 1.75 points, a three function blade is worth 2.5, a four function worth 2.75, and whatever blade in this world claims five functions is worth 3 points to the overall score. (no further because - A, it buggers up my system, and B, anyone who can shove five tools in a blade has probably earned it)

                              The Exception, perhaps, to this rule, is the Plier Head itself - I'm happy to count Plier and Wire Cutter as separate deeds (Why the double standard? I don't know, it seemed like a good idea when I started typing it)

                              Onwards!

                              PST -
                              Fine Slothead Screwdriver - 1 Point
                              Med Slothead Screwdriver - 1 Point
                              L SS - 1 Point
                              "Combination" plier head - 1.75 points
                              Soft & hard wire cutter - 1.75 points
                              Cap lifter can opener - 1.75 points
                              Three side/grade files - 2.5 points
                              Phillips Screwdriver - 1 point.
                              Plain Knife blade - 1 point
                              Spike - 1 point

                              Total - 12.75 (someone check my math)

                              Vic ST Spirit -
                              Saw - 1 point
                              Sheepsfoot blade - 1 point
                              Isolation cutter/wire scraper/chisel/wire stripper - 2.75 points
                              Cap Lifter, Wire Bender, crate opener, slothead screwdriver - 2.75 points
                              spike/hook - 1.75 points
                              2mm slothead - 1 point
                              can opener/3mm slothead - 1.75 points.
                              phillips - 1 point
                              Blade (or scissors) - 1 point
                              File/saw - 1.75 points
                              Plier - 1 point
                              Hard/soft wire cutters - 1.75 points

                              total - 16.75

                              The Spirit still comes out on top (well duh, it has additional blades per handle to start with), but the game brings the PST at least closer to the running.

                              Those of you with a preference for Dedicated tools may appreciate this styling more.

                              I won't make a vote either way - but one assumes (perhaps at one's detriment) that a dedicated tool is better at its one job than a combination tool.

                              There are few here who sniff at the LM Core's drivers, so there may be something in that.

                              While I love to abuse my Vic Cap Lifter like the devil, I can not honestly say I've turned a bolt with it and say to myself "You know, when it comes to turning them bolts, this is a quality tool!" (I have never encountered a better lever in my life though, and I've broken a lot of expensive levers that come in boxes with "SCREWDRIVER SET" written on them. I think Screwdriver must be German for Lever.)

                              As someone already mentioned, one could also take into account the relative frequency with which one uses any given function.

                              Wire or Electrical functions in particular are somewhat niche - I myself am involved with wire or cabling perhaps once a month, and I generally know ahead of time when this is going to happen, so I can prepare myself adequately for this event.

                              I suppose if I was a keen chap, who really liked the thrills, I could bust out and repair the taillights en-route, but unless I've got designer stubble, strategically placed dirt stains, and a few cameras rolling, I see no reason not to wait until I get home and do my fixing with the comfort of a beer and my toolbox full of the right tools.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • toytoy Offline
                                toytoy
                                Posts: 96
                                toytoy Offline
                                toytoy
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #35 Quote Reply

                                  We may grade each component tool. Let's say you use pliers, knife and screw drivers most of the times, you may have A pliers, A knife and A scrfew drivers build into a MT.

                                  Now you want to use wood saw, can opener, metal/diamond files maybe once a week. You can live with B wood saw, B can opener, B metal/diamond files. Since they add weight to the MT, the added weight and inconvinence make your new MT A- pliers, A- knife, A- scrfew drivers, B- wood saw, B- can opener, and B- metal/diamond files. After a pointy, the more you put in, the less functional a single tool can be. Would you bring that 50,000 lb Wenger monster to work?

                                  A multi-tool may never be as handy as a dedicated tool. There are great hammers, pliers, saws. You probably would not see an industrial staple gun built into a MT. To judge a MT's value, you have to take into consideration how often you may use one of the "unuseful" tools and how often you have to get a dedicated tool. Let's say my tool does not have an awl. How many times a year, an awl at hand can help me finish my job, or even save the whole Northern Hemisphere from Martian invasion?

                                  giant_swiss.jpg

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • Biru Offline
                                    Biru
                                    Posts: 618
                                    Biru Offline
                                    Biru
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #36 Quote Reply

                                      If I may respectfully add, I believe the standard Bear Jaws MT to be superior to my PST with the notable exception of the Phillips screwdriver. The Bear Jaws, for its size, is a VERY strong tool, with a reinforced bolster/pivot in the plier area for added strength. It also has thicker steel in the handles, front-accessible tools, comfortable handles and slightly thicker plier ends for added strength. Unfortunately, it has an overly thick, slightly oversized and blunt Phillips which precludes getting into recesses (the square Phillips shaft was intended, if I recall, to be a driver for a Bear proprietary bit system). It also has a somewhat cumbersome locking system (I would have preferred an original Supertool-type lock to the standard Bear lock). For such a small tool, it gives great confidence in its strength.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • toytoy Offline
                                        toytoy
                                        Posts: 96
                                        toytoy Offline
                                        toytoy
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #37 Quote Reply

                                          I've been using LM Surge for a few weeks. I find some of its tools are not very efficient.

                                          The small eyegalss screw, when attached to the Surge body, can be difficult to use. If you detach it, it lacks a handle. This tool is mostly wasted.

                                          The replaceable saw is short. If versatility is what you want, you may like this design because you can buy various replacement T-shanked saws so you can cut brass, concrete, everything. If you only use Surge as a saw handle, you can carry additional longer saws with you (most T-shank saws are too long to be foldable). If you use the saw all the time, you may like the fact that you can change the saw once it becomes dull. However, if you use saw everyday, why don't you bring a hacksaw?

                                          The Wave design allows one to open the outer four blades without opening the whole tool. However, It also creates "waste." Whether the two extra compartment walls shall be called waste really depends on how you see it. They do enhance the structure.

                                          waste.gif

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • Sea Monster Offline
                                            Sea Monster
                                            Posts: 4,261
                                            Sea Monster Offline
                                            Sea Monster
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #38 Quote Reply

                                              Those bits are not "Waste", they are "Sports Inserts for Improved durability and easy access"

                                              Geez!

                                              I turned down the Surge because (aside from the fact it was too big to use, which I likely could have got used to), I just didn't feel I was getting enough bang for my buck. Maybe that was shortsighted of me, I don't know, but it certainly gives the impression of a lot of tool doing less than it could.

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • Leatherman123 Offline
                                                Leatherman123
                                                Posts: 6,568
                                                Leatherman123 Offline
                                                Leatherman123
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #39 Quote Reply

                                                  Alright guys, I am going to go out on a limb here and say the LM Surge! Has many tools and has the large bit adapter which gives you about 44 screwdriver tips, if you buy the bit kit that is! I don't even want to start rambling about how great the Surge really is!

                                                  B

                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • Sea Monster Offline
                                                    Sea Monster
                                                    Posts: 4,261
                                                    Sea Monster Offline
                                                    Sea Monster
                                                    wrote on last edited by Sea Monster
                                                    #40 Quote Reply

                                                      I don't even want to start rambling about how great the Surge really is!

                                                      That's good, because I didn't want to hear it anyway. :D

                                                      the *Charge ALX *has three bit drivers, so wouldn't that make it outrank the Surge by your reasoning?

                                                      (I don't put a great deal of value on Bit drivers or 1/4" socket drivers on a multi. Has uses sure, but I think I'd rather carry a dedicated tool for them.)

                                                      on the Charge topic, how're the crimpers?

                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • toytoy Offline
                                                        toytoy
                                                        Posts: 96
                                                        toytoy Offline
                                                        toytoy
                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                        #41 Quote Reply

                                                          I think LM has done a bad job selling the bits. They should have bundle the bits with all their tools at a deep discount (for the bits). These bits are not very costly to manufacture. Selling them cheaply may help LM to make more money.

                                                          I agree that the extra thin bits may greatly increase Surge's value. The universal adapter may be even more useful.

                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • Sea Monster Offline
                                                            Sea Monster
                                                            Posts: 4,261
                                                            Sea Monster Offline
                                                            Sea Monster
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #42 Quote Reply

                                                              They should have bundle the bits with all their tools at a deep discount (for the bits). These bits are not very costly to manufacture. Selling them cheaply may help LM to make more money.

                                                              SSSSHHH!

                                                              just quietly - They do, but we sell them separately anyway.

                                                              Buwahaha!

                                                              I jest - the bit kit costs something like $35 AU.
                                                              It confuses and enrages me too - I generally sell the universal adapter at cost, and even then customers sometimes baulk at the price.

                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • Leatherman123 Offline
                                                                Leatherman123
                                                                Posts: 6,568
                                                                Leatherman123 Offline
                                                                Leatherman123
                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                #43 Quote Reply

                                                                  Well you are partially right- the charge alx does indeed have three bit drivers but I find that extremely unecessary! I can just switch bits with the SURGE if I need a different screwdriver: no need to have an extra one when you lose the great fixed flathead! Plus, the SURGE has all the features that many ceratain models leave out: awl, crimper, scissors, and a serrated blade. I find that the SURGE has the most needed tools without needing to sacrifice other tools.. The Swisstools is a prime example: how their is three models.. The SURGE basically has all the tools that all three swisstools combined has ( besides the chisel)! But by this I mean like file, serrated blade, and scissors... That is how I see it!

                                                                  B

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                  Register Login

                                                                  • 1
                                                                  • 2
                                                                  • 3
                                                                  1. Home
                                                                  2. General Tool Discussion
                                                                  3. Capability-to-Size ratio
                                                                  Reply
                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                  0% funded
                                                                  • Login

                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                  • First post
                                                                    Last post
                                                                  0