Any female here?
-
Geez! Some comments here earlier today were pissing me off a bit, and now it's just making my head hurt! I think I'll just go either try to herd my landlord's cats :), or go pick a fight with my girlfriend. She's going for her masters in English Lit, and a random comment about how <u>The Scarlet</u> <u>Letter</u> was a piece of crap should set it off nicely. >:D Too much psych and computers here for me.......
-
it's that recursive aspect of pattern recognition that produces consciousness in the brain.
That's almost tautological, if one equates consciousness and self-awareness.
I think an essential component of consciousness is that it takes place between individuals in a social context
Nice idea. Reminds me of Private Language.
-
it's that recursive aspect of pattern recognition that produces consciousness in the brain.
That's almost tautological, if one equates consciousness and self-awareness.
I think an essential component of consciousness is that it takes place between individuals in a social context
Nice idea. Reminds me of Private Language.
Strictly speaking I suppose it is tautological. But that's how philosophers commonly define consciousness, as self awareness.
On the other hand it's not tautological in the sense that one description is mechanistic (recursive feedback; can be explained in terms of the wiring of neurons in the brain), while the other is conceptual / abstract. So in that sense, they are indeed two different things.
This all begs the question of the ontological status of nominals though... do they actually refer to real and existing objects in the world (as the philosophical Realists, such as Thomas Reid, argued), or are names all that exist and once there is no name for something, that thing no longer exists? So does ontology precede epistemology, or does epistemology precede ontology? I think it's a false dichotomy myself. Can't have one without the other.
-
@jerseydevil said:
Geez! Some comments here earlier today were pissing me off a bit, and now it's just making my head hurt! I think I'll just go either try to herd my landlord's cats :), or go pick a fight with my girlfriend. She's going for her masters in English Lit, and a random comment about how <u>The Scarlet</u> <u>Letter</u> was a piece of crap should set it off nicely. >:D Too much psych and computers here for me.......Actually, that reminds me of the issue of artificial intelligence. AI systems are the product of computer scientists using the "computer metaphor" of the mind to explain thinking and consciousness. The claim is that the brain is just a very powerful fancy computer, and the mind is just a program running on the brain. They point to things like minds/brains having short term memory storage, which is analogous to RAM in a computer, long term memory storage, which is analogous to a hard disk, input, output, a processor, and so on.
Over the decades, people in computer engineering and artificial intelligence have been trying to make a "thinking" computer, and have failed miserably each and every single time. The most powerful artificial intelligence system ever built and in existence today can't do the simple things my three year old daughter can do. So, they keep saying it's just a matter of not having enough processing horsepower; they say things like "next year, Intel is releasing a new processor which will be ten times more powerful... yada yada yada." So that once they have that processor they'll finally be able to make a "thinking" computer. But they've been saying that for 60 years, and they still haven't made one.
The problem is they've put the cart before the horse. It's not that computers work like minds, but the other way around. We've designed and built computers in the model of our own cognition, so it's the computer that's like the mind. This has lead them to many mistaken assumptions, the most basic of which goes all the way back to Alan Turing and the Turing Test, and assumes that thinking can be described by algorithmic computational processes. But that's a false assumption, and the repeated failure of AI to produce a thinking computer is highly damning evidence of that.
Looking back through history, we see that the most brilliant minds of any era have always compared the most advanced and complicated technology of the times to the mind as an attempt to explain what the mind and consciousness is, and how it works. In Francis Bacon's day, he used the metaphor of the mind like the mechanical clock (Big Ben). Fast forward 100 years or so to Descartes and his metaphor was the hydraulic animatronic figures in the fountains at the palace of Versailles. He proposed that thinking was 'vibrations' in nerve fibers in the brain and body, and that the pineal glad was the point where the mind and the body interacted. Jump forward another 200 years or so to the 18th century and James Watt and the steam engine. Philosophers and scientists in that era used it as the metaphor to explain the mind. Now jump forward to our time, the 19th/20th centuries, and now the metaphor we've chosen is the electronic computer.
I honestly don't think it's really gotten us much further along theoretically than we were back in Bacon's day. The only real advantage it's given us is that we now have a more precise idea of how to quantify cognitive processing, and especially mental content. Thanks to Claude Shannon and the introduction of information processing theory to cognitive psychology and computer science, we can now quantify information in terms of bits. That's allowed us to do all kinds of computer simulations and models, which have been some help, but are still far from hitting the real target. In some ways, it's set us back because of the mistaken assumption of the directionality of the mind-computer metaphor. So for now, it's just another step in the sequence of historical events of how mankind is attempting to know who and what we are. It's just another way for us to try and understand those big metaphysical philosophical questions about what our basic nature is, who we are, how and why we are here, and so on. In many ways its psychological function is no different than that of religion or other forms of spirituality; it's a way for us to try and know ourselves and understand our place in the world. That's all.
But, it sure is a fascinating journey if you ask me... that's why I've more or less dedicated my life and career to studying it and teaching about it. I've given up research for it because I find it far more interesting and rewarding than when I was doing things like sticking needles in monkey's brains to record their neurons during visual attention tasks. I also like to think that teaching this kind of stuff is helping make the world a better place too.
Oh, and I don't have many publications under my belt, since I've chosen a teaching career over research now, but here is one I did when I was working as a neurophysiology researcher. Don't worry about understanding it, it's just to give you guys an idea of what my background is and where I've come from with all this stuff.
Hopefully this link will work right.
-
Okay, sorry guys. I'll shut up now.

-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
Okay, sorry guys. I'll shut up now.
Good grief, never apologise for raising the bar!
It just needs a thread which wasn't started under other pretences.
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
Okay, sorry guys. I'll shut up now.
Please, don't! I have some questions “and stuff”, but I don't have the opportunity to formulate them properly right now, also I want to digest it all a little. Anyway, I'd like to thank you for these last posts, it is an extremely interesting read for me.
-
Just keep these serious discussions out of the WOMEN THREAD !!!

:D
-
Okay, so as a woman, and an ex-programmer, and a lay-person in linguistics, I'll jump in and see if I can make a fool of myself.
Earlier attempts to compare the mind to technology were a great deal further off than comparing it to a computer. They are both collections of electronic connections. I'm not certain with current computer tech we'll ever be able to emulate human brains. The limitations of binary alone pose a problem. My understanding is that neurons aren't 'on' or 'off', but more offer various levels of resistance. You could convert that roughly to multiple bits, for instance saying a byte might represent a single synaptic connection. But that leaves you getting not quite what the brain does. I understand some people can hear the difference between the digitized version of music on a CD and from an analogue LP, as an example of that difference. But all of this sort of comes down to 'close enough', where mathematicians can argue that .999999999=1.
The failing of computers in emulating human thinking is, I think, two-fold. First, they don't have the ability to perceive the world the way we do, and second, they do not have the physiological drives that we do. The word 'orange' is just a collection of symbols to a computer. To a human, it's a collection of symbols, that gets you a connection to an entire database of sensory
input. It connects to visuals in color, dimpling, and a long line of oranges we've seen in our lives. It connects to our memories of smell, taste, texture, memories of a spray of mist from the skin of the orange squirting in our eyes, and the joy of eating them. For a computer, the word has a definition. For a human, the word is just a gateway into our knowledge of the item as experienced. As omnivores, oranges give us nutrition, and vitamins; things we as organic life crave. We WANT them. That want, powered by biological needs, is something a computer does not know, and honestly, I don't think could ever be taught.Language is the shorthand humans use to communicate experience. Two humans who have both eaten an orange can just point at one, and say 'orange', and now both connect that combination of sounds to their experience with the real thing. If only one of them has ever had an orange, the word is kind of meaningless. Even if you know the definition of the word, it is kind of pointless without the experience. If you have never had an orange, and someone asks if you like 'Orange Chicken' at a chinese restaurant, you don't know. If you've had an orange before, and find it not to your liking, then you know you probably won't like orange chicken.
If the human mind is a massively powerful computer used to take sensory input and produce decisions based (in theory) on keeping the organism alive and to motivate it to procreate, then getting a computer to 'think' kind of seems like it'd have to be forced into a situation where it was required to perform the same task. As I'd rather not have Cylon overlords, I suggest we not try. :D
-
Lynn,
No foolishness at all! In fact, very perceptive!
The single biggest problem with AI, which you accurately identify, is that computers are just symbol manipulators, they don't actually associate or assign content to a symbol, with the exception of other symbols, which as Steinar mentioned, is tautological. We on the other hand associate an abstract representation such as the word "orange" with a range of experiences and non-symbolic sensory data that places the word in a larger context of relationships which define it and give it the meaning it has.
Without that contextual background for reference, any symbol is meaningless. An example of this is the arbitrariness of symbols; there's nothing about the idea of "one" that requires we use the letters "O", "N", and "E" to spell/name it, or that we use the digit "1" to represent it either. As a society we could just as easily have decided to use some other symbol(s). The point is that we are capable of such contextualization, and computers aren't. This is because by definition, any information processed by a computer must be explicitly defined, but we have implicit knowledge, information that can be derived by the relationships of meaning between ideas which gives us information by telling us what something is not. There is no way a computer can do that.
In the last couple of decades, a movement that's been going on in cognitive psych is about "embodiment", how the structure and function of our biological/physiological systems defines and constrains our cognitive abilities and experiences. On one level, this shows how the influence of biology/physiology is becoming more pervasive in psychology as we learn more about the function of the brain and nervous system. It's allowing psychology to become more scientific and less philosophical, as we're able to quantify things now we couldn't before.
One way this is coming out is by characterizing cognitive mechanisms in experiential terms, and making greater use of metaphor and analogy to expand and improve our understanding of cognition and consciousness. Psycholinguistics spends a lot of time looking at how metaphor and analogy reveals the organizational structure of knowledge and processes of thinking. George Lakoff did some interesting stuff on this in the late 80's and through the mid 90's, and I took a class from him on it while a student at Berkeley. He talks about how we understand things like time by comparing it to an arrow in flight (classic metaphor of "time's arrow"), etc.
It's also pressing new theoretical issues as well. We've now got to rethink many of the ideas we had about thought, consciousness, free will, and so on because of our new abilities to quantify and predict behavior based on neural and brain functions. Not only that, but it's forcing us to evaluate the nature of knowledge (epistemology) as well. By realizing that our sensory systems only receive a finite range of information, it means that logically, there are things in the universe we might never be able to know, or perhaps even exist (dark matter anyone?), because of the limitations of our physical/biological form.
Again, very insightful!
@Lynn LeFey said:
Okay, so as a woman, and an ex-programmer, and a lay-person in linguistics, I'll jump in and see if I can make a fool of myself.Earlier attempts to compare the mind to technology were a great deal further off than comparing it to a computer. They are both collections of electronic connections. I'm not certain with current computer tech we'll ever be able to emulate human brains. The limitations of binary alone pose a problem. My understanding is that neurons aren't 'on' or 'off', but more offer various levels of resistance. You could convert that roughly to multiple bits, for instance saying a byte might represent a single synaptic connection. But that leaves you getting not quite what the brain does. I understand some people can hear the difference between the digitized version of music on a CD and from an analogue LP, as an example of that difference. But all of this sort of comes down to 'close enough', where mathematicians can argue that .999999999=1.
The failing of computers in emulating human thinking is, I think, two-fold. First, they don't have the ability to perceive the world the way we do, and second, they do not have the physiological drives that we do. The word 'orange' is just a collection of symbols to a computer. To a human, it's a collection of symbols, that gets you a connection to an entire database of sensory
input. It connects to visuals in color, dimpling, and a long line of oranges we've seen in our lives. It connects to our memories of smell, taste, texture, memories of a spray of mist from the skin of the orange squirting in our eyes, and the joy of eating them. For a computer, the word has a definition. For a human, the word is just a gateway into our knowledge of the item as experienced. As omnivores, oranges give us nutrition, and vitamins; things we as organic life crave. We WANT them. That want, powered by biological needs, is something a computer does not know, and honestly, I don't think could ever be taught.Language is the shorthand humans use to communicate experience. Two humans who have both eaten an orange can just point at one, and say 'orange', and now both connect that combination of sounds to their experience with the real thing. If only one of them has ever had an orange, the word is kind of meaningless. Even if you know the definition of the word, it is kind of pointless without the experience. If you have never had an orange, and someone asks if you like 'Orange Chicken' at a chinese restaurant, you don't know. If you've had an orange before, and find it not to your liking, then you know you probably won't like orange chicken.
If the human mind is a massively powerful computer used to take sensory input and produce decisions based (in theory) on keeping the organism alive and to motivate it to procreate, then getting a computer to 'think' kind of seems like it'd have to be forced into a situation where it was required to perform the same task. As I'd rather not have Cylon overlords, I suggest we not try. :D
-
This thread makes me :ahhh :ahhh
Sorry I guess I'm just an idiot. :DSent from Ash forum mobile
-
Sounds like a plan. This other stuff is mind fluttering!
Sent from Ash forum mobile
-
There was something on telly the other night about computers, robots communicating and Alan turing....
Interesting, Intriguing and confusing all at the same time
Can you get orange lego? (That lowered the bar a bit ;) :D )
-
@sparky415 said:
There was something on telly the other night about computers, robots communicating and Alan turing....
Interesting, Intriguing and confusing all at the same time
Can you get orange lego? (That lowered the bar a bit ;) :D )
Oh yes :P

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
**THE ** Women Thread, in the Break room sub-forum... :D

