Do they actually care?? really?
-
Anyone know the name of the Gerber that has interchangeable pliers heads.
-
That Surge is SWEEEEET!!!

-
@captain spaulding said:
Anyone know the name of the Gerber that has interchangeable pliers heads.That would be the MP650. :)
-
Tosh, I'm wondering what specific tasks you are doing, so regularly, that having the semi-needle nosed pliers are being a PITA?
I use MT pliers every single day at work and, while there have been one or two occasions where the pliers shape has been an issue, far more often they have been a boon.
Yes, options are good, and I really like the blunt nosed MP600 I have, but I'm really struggling to think of the last time I needed them.
-
@Gareth said:
Tosh, I'm wondering what specific tasks you are doing, so regularly, that having the semi-needle nosed pliers are being a PITA?Hi Gareth
Basically, I just don't ever need needlenose, not ever. If I'm grabbing something then its usually because I can't administer the same force by hand.
At work I mainly use M8, M10 & M12 nuts & bolts. Or bending steel that's got knocked out of shape. Prior to that scenario, when I was shopfitting - which covers an enormous spectrum. Building studded walls building partition walls, drylining, hanging doors, suspeneded ceilings, fitting counters, assembling office furniture and so on and so on. Almost never have I ever had the need to use needlenose pliers.Personally, unless its something really fiddly i.e electrician, computers, data com etc etc. I just don't know where the needlenose design fits in.
And TBH I ain't gonna stand there in front of all the lads looking like some sort of geek phaffing about with a multitool that is clearly out of its depth just to satisfy my own personal self satisfaction from using them. The bottom line Gareth is, at work I need to work and so do my tools. And if they can't do the job, then they'll stay at home.
Note : it speaks volumes about leathermans (And victorinox and SOG) faith in their own tools that they dare not create proper bluntnosed pliers! I wonder what they are scared of? No doubt thousands of the damn things coming back for warranty work!
-
@zoidberg said:
Was it my one Lynn? ;) More pics over here.I think it probably was.
Sorry if I attributed it to Metro, but any time there's a mod I'm thinking of, it's a fair chance it's his, so maybe I was just playing the odds.

I honestly don't remember it having cera/dura coated handles, so I'm guessing this actually was it.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Was it my one Lynn? ;) More pics over here.
I think it probably was.
Sorry if I attributed it to Metro, but any time there's a mod I'm thinking of, it's a fair chance it's his, so maybe I was just playing the odds.

I honestly don't remember it having cera/dura coated handles, so I'm guessing this actually was it.
I think (but not sure at all) Metro did one with orange handles.....
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
Was it my one Lynn? ;) More pics over here.
I think it probably was.
Sorry if I attributed it to Metro, but any time there's a mod I'm thinking of, it's a fair chance it's his, so maybe I was just playing the odds.

I honestly don't remember it having cera/dura coated handles, so I'm guessing this actually was it.
I think (but not sure at all) Metro did one with orange handles.....
Destructocon, awesome but not blunt nosed. I have no problem with my hacks being mistaken for Metro mods...
Tosh, I'm wondering what specific tasks you are doing, so regularly, that having the semi-needle nosed pliers are being a PITA?
Hi Gareth
Basically, I just don't ever need needlenose, not ever. If I'm grabbing something then its usually because I can't administer the same force by hand.
At work I mainly use M8, M10 & M12 nuts & bolts. Or bending steel that's got knocked out of shape. Prior to that scenario, when I was shopfitting - which covers an enormous spectrum. Building studded walls building partition walls, drylining, hanging doors, suspeneded ceilings, fitting counters, assembling office furniture and so on and so on. Almost never have I ever had the need to use needlenose pliers.Personally, unless its something really fiddly i.e electrician, computers, data com etc etc. I just don't know where the needlenose design fits in.
And TBH I ain't gonna stand there in front of all the lads looking like some sort of geek phaffing about with a multitool that is clearly out of its depth just to satisfy my own personal self satisfaction from using them. The bottom line Gareth is, at work I need to work and so do my tools. And if they can't do the job, then they'll stay at home.
Note : it speaks volumes about leathermans (And victorinox and SOG) faith in their own tools that they dare not create proper bluntnosed pliers! I wonder what they are scared of? No doubt thousands of the damn things coming back for warranty work!
In general I don't think multitools really belong on the worksite.
I do carry a couple in the truck but they are only used if other tools can't do the job.I think the brands go with pointy pliers because it covers both bases for the mall ninjas.
Here is my most biased opinion.
Most people don't own a multitool.
Of those that do, most complain about misaligned handles.
Of those that do, most don't carry them.
Of those that carry, most don't use them.
Of those that use, most do so badly or are plan abusive.
Of those remaining, most will rather use the right dedicated tool for the job. -
]
@zoidberg said:
I think the brands go with pointy pliers because it covers both bases for the mall ninjas.Here is my most biased opinion.
Most people don't own a multitool.
Of those that do, most complain about misaligned handles.
Of those that do, most don't carry them.
Of those that carry, most don't use them.
Of those that use, most do so badly or are plan abusive.
Of those remaining, most will rather use the right dedicated tool for the job.I couldn't have put it better myself zoidberg

-
As a certified tradesman who does use a MT a lot, I'm not sure how I feel about that description. ;)
-
Four year apprenticeship and eighteen years as a maintenance mechanical engineer. If it has pipes, water, air, oil or steam I get to fix it. I also do a good line in pretty much anything else that involves tools; joinery, electrical, plumbing etc. Just don't expect me to hang any wall paper, when it comes to decorating I am lucky if the paint stays on the wall.

-
I feel like multitools usefulness is being overlooked here. I think multitools do have versatility and are incredibly useful. I especially like them in the outdoors. When you are days from civilization on a mountain or in the forest, you are really glad that you have a few basic tools on you. No they don't compete so much with dedicated tools for functionality, but they win in portability. A tool only works if you have it with you.
-
@Gareth said:
Four year apprenticeship and eighteen years as a maintenance mechanical engineer. If it has pipes, water, air, oil or steam I get to fix it. I also do a good line in pretty much anything else that involves tools; joinery, electrical, plumbing etc. Just don't expect me to hang any wall paper, when it comes to decorating I am lucky if the paint stays on the wall.
So basically you're a walking toolbox?? :D Stilsons, wrenches, spanners, ratchets etc etc. Its not hard to envision where the MT might come in handy

I don't really carry anything like that these days, prior to which was mostly joinery tools, lasers, levels, steps etc etc.
All I want is proper p!iers with top quality long reach drivers and a good quality sharp blade, serrated too if possible, oh, an' maybe a box cutter thrown in as well. Don't want the file, scissors, bottle opener, can opener and god knows what else they throw in to fill the spaces!!
Now, how hard can that really be??
-
I used to be an IT technician and now just plain site maintenance person (with IT on the side). For work you should have a van / tool belt / toolbox full of proper tools.
Multitool is just something you should have "just in case" for an odd job or when you are too lazy to go back to the toolbox.How you can expect a multitool to "work" day in, day out. You can use the best materials and engineering available to create "money no object" MT and it will still loose with normal tools designed for a given job. For professionals time is money and no one will use a MT all day because it will not be efficient.
Multi tools aka "pocket tools" are better than nothing but will never be able to compete with full size tools. They are half way quick fix.
I'm not surprised that on a building site needle nose pliers are not adequate. But in a day to day they do help a lot. Sometimes they do get in a way when undoeing a bolt, but sometimes I have a job only they can solve a problem... -
@BigMatt said:
I used to be an IT technician and now just plain site maintenance person (with IT on the side). For work you should have a van / tool belt / toolbox full of proper tools.
Multitool is just something you should have "just in case" for an odd job or when you are too lazy to go back to the toolbox.How you can expect a multitool to "work" day in, day out. You can use the best materials and engineering available to create "money no object" MT and it will still loose with normal tools designed for a given job. For professionals time is money and no one will use a MT all day because it will not be efficient.
Multi tools aka "pocket tools" are better than nothing but will never be able to compete with full size tools. They are half way quick fix.
I'm not surprised that on a building site needle nose pliers are not adequate. But in a day to day they do help a lot. Sometimes they do get in a way when undoeing a bolt, but sometimes I have a job only they can solve a problem...You make a valid point and I agree with you...to a point.
I personally think its perfectly feasible to create a top quality plier based tool that incorporates a driver of some sort - either fixed or with removable and reversible bits. Plus the addition of a blade that would be able to take the stress meeted out to their stand alone rivals.
Now, are you seriously implying that that's beyond hope?? A basic tool such as that would pretty much be invaluable to many many people. Seriously, why do I need a can opener , or a half serrated blade, cap lifter etc etc on a multitool. I just think the manufacturers are being downright lazy, "let's change the colours and take some more money of 'em" like candy from a baby!!
It's frustrating that patents are held pretty much preventing anyone else from having a go - ( isn't that why victorinox was forced to buying bear & sons) yet these guys now calling the shots just don't want to know!!
-
All Im saying is:
Weight, compactness, number of implements, durability, you can choose two...
Also some features conflict with each other like blunt and needle nose pliers. I use my leat:-)hermans for work, lessure and outdoors and surge/charge setups are almost perfect for me, and for others not so much.It is impossible to create a MT that would satisfy everybody. Or even one person requirements/needs/situations. As long as a given MT is fairly close to my needs it's good enoug for me
-
I use mine every day at work.
Sometimes it's laziness and not wanting to go back to the toolbox to tighten a screw that's a 15 minute round trip to do. Sometimes it's because I've gone to look what tools I need for a job and found I've already got them in my pocket. If I'm expecting to need tools and have thought ahead then I'll probably have my little pouch with me and use that with the MT.
If I'm at my workbench then I won't use it much because I have the tools I need right there and it's more efficient to use them. If someone brings something in the the office then I'll probably get out the MT because I don't have the tools next to me and it's not worth the walk to get to them.
-
I think it depends on what sorts of things one does in an average day. For me, a MT has been ideal in daily use for decades. At work and at leisure.
Pry open the dash on a truck with the large flat head.
Pull a small fuse with the needle nose pliers when my hands are too big to fit the compartment easily.
Cut the spokes off a damaged bicycle wheel so I can salvage the hub.
Use the pliers to pull back some carpet to get a look at the subfloor.
Tighten the screws the crew left loose.
Take the back off the flat screen to replace the power button.
Cut the wire off the tree root ball.
Whittle a stick with my daughter while hiking.
File my jagged nail.
File down the edge of that aluminum transition that was cut poorly.
Saw a branch off a tree in the garden that is rubbing against another branch.
Do the same, but to get my daughter a nice stick to cook her hot dog on over the campfire.
Saw a dead branch down to make a new fire poker.
Assemble my daughters toy.
Assemble the fixture after I first cut open the box.
Pull out and cut all those old electrical lines. Install the new lines and a new switch.
Cut the line on the dingy before the rough surf drowns me.
And so on and so on.. I could continue nearly indefinitely. All of the above are what a multitool is meant for. And I even use it sometimes for jobs beyond its intended use just because I don't feel like grabbing the proper tool. And I have a garage full of them, and a full tool bag in the vehicle.
If I am planning a project, I take the right tools. Always.
But everything in between is MT territory.
I don't want a multitool for the times when I need a proper tool. A multi will always be a compromise, and I don't want to compromise when I have time to take what I actually need. When working, compromise sucks because it means everything takes longer and is harder.
Real tools? Yes.
Multitool? Yes.
"Real tool multitool"? No thank you. What for?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
