life straw advice please
-
got me a 'lifestraw' :D
wanted one for a while, no particular reason and i'll probably never need it but when did that ever stop any of us
loads of youtube reviews check them out if you've never heard of them (one below, picked at random)
LifeStraw Demonstrationnow here's my problem, obviously if I was thrust into a 'survival situation' and had this with me I would use it without a second thought, on the basis "it's got to be safer than not using it" ! I'd rather not drink anything suspect. IF I had to drink filth, I'd rather filter, boil, treat with chemicals then drink through this BUT .....
hopefully I will never be in that situation !
right now back to reality, do I 'test' this for myself ? as I see it I could just be risking sickness (or worse) for nothing, if it doesn't work I'm dead if it does I won't know for sure, I just won't get sick !
not much point in owning it if it never gets some use. Already tried drinking 'fruit squash' through it and it doesn't filter out the taste or the colouring
the next step is ?
I think it will be very counter intuitive to drink filthy water, having been told not to all my life. any thoughts oh trusted ones
-
Taxi Dad,
I am always on the look out for all the survival tech; although I live in one of the most populated city in the world, I always carry all these gears with me when travelling to some really remote locations.
I too have this life straw, but personally favor the Aqua Mira Frontier in terms of size. The logic behind it is I figure I will be able to get to a place with clean water, or be rescued before I consume 30 gallons of water(claimed by Frontier, that volume probably affects by how dirty is the water), and if I can't get my sorry axx get rescued after 90 Liters of water(usually 2-4 liters a day depending on climate/terrain), I deserve to die anyway.
In terms of ultimate space saving, I like the sodium Chloride tabs, but usually it takes 1/2-4 hours for it to be effective, and it doesn't always agree with my stomach.
I strongly suggest to test out these gears before fully dependent on them, and I usually just start with local clean tap water, and gradually test it with other less clean water sources. The best method is still unquestionably boiling water, and when I have to travel to locations where I won't even brush teeth with the water, so as long I have the means to do so, I will boil everything.
-
Lifestraw, while larger than Frontier, is the superior choice due to the wider range of pathogens it removes. More to come when I get back to full-size keyboard.
-
I would just test it on clean water, practising the best way of using it, and then hope it works if I really need it one day.
-
It's solid, test it. Once you get it going it works well. I carry mine in a three day bag, goes almost everywhere.
Swiss Army knives .
-
thanks for your comments
@ Colt, do you 'use' yours ? -
I too am purchasing a Lifestraw, good info , thanks
-
I thought I'd jump in here. I don't have one, but looked into them. For on-person, I carry Chlor-floc packets and ziplock bags. In my get-home bag, I have a filtering water bottle.
What I've heard is that they are great, when you first use them. Now, that might be for days on end, but if you let it sit over a long period and dry out, then it stops working. So, if you ARE in an emergency and use it, you should pitch it when the crisis is over. I'm not certain this is absolutely true, but seems to be a reasonable precaution.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
What I've heard is that they are great, when you first use them. Now, that might be for days on end, but if you let it sit over a long period and dry out, then it stops working. So, if you ARE in an emergency and use it, you should pitch it when the crisis is over. I'm not certain this is absolutely true, but seems to be a reasonable precaution.Shouldn't be an issue per the supplier, although I can't speak from personal experience since (while I have two LifeStraws) I haven't had to use them yet. The following instructions are offered, however:
-
each time you finish drinking, blow back into the straw to clear the filter and flush any remaining water and particulate
-
if the filter is dry, it may be necessary to wait a bit with the dirty end submerged in water and or give several strong sucks to get the filter membrane wet and the water flowing
I can see someone not following either of the above instructions and ending up with a unit that "stops working". Of course, for the $15-$20 that a LifeStraw costs, I probably would just replace one if I had to use it.
-
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I thought I'd jump in here. I don't have one, but looked into them. For on-person, I carry Chlor-floc packets and ziplock bags. In my get-home bag, I have a filtering water bottle.What I've heard is that they are great, when you first use them. Now, that might be for days on end, but if you let it sit over a long period and dry out, then it stops working. So, if you ARE in an emergency and use it, you should pitch it when the crisis is over. I'm not certain this is absolutely true, but seems to be a reasonable precaution.
What is a filtering water bottle ?
-
something like this i'd guess ?
http://images.greenmanbushcraft.co.uk/1/0c66745survivapure.jpg
are they any good Lynn ? -
I've got a Katadyn Mybottle, the older variety with a straw sticking out of the top.
As for how it works... I can't say. I've never used it. Never had to. I trust Katadyn to make good stuff, so i'm not sweating it.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login