Survival kit minimum size blade?
-
Like you said in a previous post, it's a calorie game. Can you field dress a deer and cut through his tendons and bones with a farmer? Sure, but why work harder than you need to when a 4.5" blade can make shorter, and safer work, of an animal? However, working smart instead of hard is the name of the game. Otherwise we would just pack ourselves and venture out into the woods to make stone and bone tools.
Personally, I would love to see someone here tackle bamboo with a saw. There is a reason nobody in the world uses a saw on bamboo, way too slow and too work intensive. You could, don't get me wrong, but then we are going right back to that "work smart" thing.
I'm glad you've never had to split wood before, but that is something I've had to do a lot, especially with bamboo. Can't just throw whole bamboo on the fire or it can explode. We also have to split it to make cordage, fish traps, spear guns, etc with it.
-
3" if a folder, 2" for a fixed.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@dmanuel said:
Personally, I would love to see someone here tackle bamboo with a saw.I'm in the midwest U.S. There is no bamboo here. Well, except some used in landscaping at the zoo.

Lol fair enough, we use it for everything here. I'm soaking it up as much as I can while I am here because there is a lot of bamboo at home in SE Texas/SW Louisiana. I'm hoping to learn which ones are edible, how to make permanent structures, and of course all the other tricks.
-
I'm fairly certain there are varieties of bamboo that WILL grow here, and I've seen it used for everything in Florida. Just never had to deal wit hit myself.
It's fair to say that survival kits WILL have to be tailored to your specific living location.
-
@dmanuel said:
Like you said in a previous post, it's a calorie game. Can you field dress a deer and cut through his tendons and bones with a farmer? Sure, but why work harder than you need to when a 4.5" blade can make shorter, and safer work, of an animal? However, working smart instead of hard is the name of the game. Otherwise we would just pack ourselves and venture out into the woods to make stone and bone tools.Personally, I would love to see someone here tackle bamboo with a saw. There is a reason nobody in the world uses a saw on bamboo, way too slow and too work intensive. You could, don't get me wrong, but then we are going right back to that "work smart" thing.
I'm glad you've never had to split wood before, but that is something I've had to do a lot, especially with bamboo. Can't just throw whole bamboo on the fire or it can explode. We also have to split it to make cordage, fish traps, spear guns, etc with it.
Sometimes it's about the tool you have not the tool you wish you had. A Farmer is always in my pocket if I had a hatchet or machete in my pocket that would be great but they don't fit in my pocket but a Farmer dose.
Just my .02
-
I think a Farmer or Harvester would be a very respectable choice for an Altoids tin ..... although, personally I'd still prefer a 3.1/2" to 4.1/2" fixed blade knife. Cold Steel's Finn Bear or Roach Belly are very cheap, very lightweight, very versatile and easy to sharpen. They're not completely bomb proof with not being full tang, but as a budget multipurpose knife I've found them very useful (my preference being the Roach Belly). If used with due dilligence (not mistreated), they would handle most tasks with ease
-
I think it is rather important to have an independent blade in a survival tin/package, so we are not solely assume/relying on having a large blade on our side.
My logic is to assume the worst case scenario that if you are stuck/lost with nothing(yes, clothed, I ain't Arno :D) but a 'survival package'(mine includes a 2 person mylar sheet and a large mirror), will the package still prove to be useful?
-
^^^ That must be where the saying "two is one and one is none" comes from! :)
-
Like you said in a previous post, it's a calorie game. Can you field dress a deer and cut through his tendons and bones with a farmer? Sure, but why work harder than you need to when a 4.5" blade can make shorter, and safer work, of an animal? However, working smart instead of hard is the name of the game. Otherwise we would just pack ourselves and venture out into the woods to make stone and bone tools.
Personally, I would love to see someone here tackle bamboo with a saw. There is a reason nobody in the world uses a saw on bamboo, way too slow and too work intensive. You could, don't get me wrong, but then we are going right back to that "work smart" thing.
I'm glad you've never had to split wood before, but that is something I've had to do a lot, especially with bamboo. Can't just throw whole bamboo on the fire or it can explode. We also have to split it to make cordage, fish traps, spear guns, etc with it.
Sometimes it's about the tool you have not the tool you wish you had. A Farmer is always in my pocket if I had a hatchet or machete in my pocket that would be great but they don't fit in my pocket but a Farmer dose.
Just my .02
It's always about the tool that you have on you, and you should never dwell on what you do not have. That is a quick way to let things spiral out of control and lose any morale you did have.
I understand this idea, however the question was what is the ideal knife size for a survival kit. While I don't do much in the line of "survival" I do practice bushcraft, which many would say is the same thing. The assumption on my part is that this scenario plays into me carrying that kit with me, otherwise this just becomes a discussion on best EDC blade size for survival purposes.
Now that being said, I have never suddenly found myself in the midst of the wilds while being unprepared. I've never experienced sudden, and unwanted, teleportation that dropped me off in the swamps or forest at home or in a jungle here. Everytime I go out camping, kayaking, rafting, hiking, hunting, or fishing I have a small lumbar bag that goes with me. It doesn't matter if it's a quick day hike or a week long camping trip, that pack, or more, is with me. Short of me ditching the pack I will have my supplies with me, and even if I do that my knife and a few other pieces of kit are located on my belt.
While a person could get by with less, why would they want to? Cleaning a game animal and cutting through the chest cavity would be a seriously difficult chore with a folding knife that exerts all of it's force on a small brass pin, not to mention the safety hazards that accompany using a non locking, folding knife in such a situation. I've hunted with many people that used nothing more than a Buck 110, and it worked great for them until they tried to go through bone. While it is plausible it is not ideal, and ideal was the topic of discussion.
-
Of course a non-locking 93mm SAK isn't the tool of the choice for skinning a game, but there are different types of survival, depending on your location and situation.
I think of those small "Altoids kits" primarily as a small personal bare-essentials container, kept in a trouser/jacket pocket for an expected urban bug-out expected-72h-rescue disaster situation. They can also be used for the "abandon-civilisation-completely" situations too, but that's a completely different story and I think a fixed knife is a must-have item for these situations. For example, everyone in Europe/America could afford at least a Mora Companion - affordable and solid general-purpose light knife, it can be bought for less than $20, so there's no real excuse for not owning at least one knife like that.
-
@Subterranean said:
Of course a non-locking 93mm SAK isn't the tool of the choice for skinning a game, but there are different types of survival, depending on your location and situation.I think of those small "Altoids kits" primarily as a small personal bare-essentials container, kept in a trouser/jacket pocket for an expected urban bug-out expected-72h-rescue disaster situation. They can also be used for the "abandon-civilisation-completely" situations too, but that's a completely different story and I think a fixed knife is a must-have item for these situations. For example, everyone in Europe/America could afford at least a Mora Companion - affordable and solid general-purpose light knife, it can be bought for less than $20, so there's no real excuse for not owning at least one knife like that.
I think you kinda hit it on the head here. Are you talking about a kit you keep in your (urban) back pack that you almost always have with you? Then I'm thinking 91mm minimum.
Are you talking about a micro-kit/altoid sized kit? Well, then you want smaller because the emphasis is on portability. Too big and you'll never care it with you always, so smaller is better than nothing here.
Are you talking a kit for your car? Or that goes in a wilderness backpack? Then I'd say go for a larger and/or fixed blade.
-
A fixed blade is a stronger design then a folder. But many of us can't carry a fixed blade in day to day life. The point of a small survival kit is to keep you alive for the short period of time it takes to find help and be rescued. If we knew that today you well be in a survival situation we wold pack a ruck sack with all we would need. But bad things happen when you dont expect them and when they do whats in your pockets may be the difference between life and death.
I don't have a BK9 in my pocket but I do have one or two of my trusty SAK's and the odds are that if something bad happens to me I well have one or more of my trusty SAK'S in my pocket.
We can debate fixed blade vs folder all day long but when it comes down to it if you only have a Classic SD on you and you get stuck then be glade you at least have that.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
