First Aid Kits - Why?
-
First and foremost, I hope everyone understands that this is not a shot at any other member(s), but something I'm genuinely curious about.
I've seen a fair bit of discussion around first aid kits. While I have a handful of first-aid related items in the house and in my cars, and could probably justify taking a small kit on an extended hiking/camping trip, I just can't see carrying a first aid kit on a regular basis.
Perhaps I'm oversimplifying, but I see injuries/medical issues falling into two categories: minor and major. In the event of a minor problem or injury (small cut, scrape, ache, bee sting to someone who isn't severely allergic, etc.), I'll wash the effected area with soap and water at the first opportunity if applicable, and call it good.
In the event of a major injury/medical issue, bearing in mind that I've had some basic first aid/CPR training but am not a physician, nurse, EMT, or other medical professional, I would like to think I'm prepared to do any or all of the following as applicable:
-
use my cell phone to call 911
-
perform basic CPR
-
use my handkerchief, bandanna, shirt, or whatever else is available to apply direct pressure to a wound
-
perform the Heimlich maneuver
-
use my belt, or my shirt and a stick, as a tourniquet
-
use an AED, if one is available
I suppose the point is that I can't think of anything I could realistically carry that would significantly improve my capabilities in any of these medical scenarios. However, I'm certainly willing to consider the possibility that this is a blind spot in my general preparedness mindset. What say you?
-
-
I live in an urban area and have some similar background as you, and I can relate your point about necessity.
While help should not be too far away(at least not hours away, taken traffic jam in consideration), I do carry a few extra item with me just in case I need to use it, such as a CPR face shield, 2 pairs of nitrile gloves, gauze pad and bandage in backpack. Also, I always take a long a few immediate meds that may make a difference, an Aspirin(for heart attack), Zyrtec(for anti-allergy) and immodium.
-
I carry a basic fak purely because my son and I cycle everywhere so there's a higher degree of risk of injury, especially with my son as He's 11 and therefore the most skilled cyclist to have ever lived and can do no wrong ::)
Just last week I had to patch him up after lobbing himself at the scenery at speed :D
Sent from the astropathic choir.
-
I agree to some degree
**Minor **(for example a papercut): while washing will solve the problem, you probably still want to work and not bleed (even if its only few droplets) all over. Thats where band-aids are very helpful.
Major: There are all kind of major incidents, some, like chest pain / breathing problems, cannot wait, you give some aspirin and hope for the best (I hike at high altitude and sometimes with very old folks 70+).
As for wounds I agree, that there is no need for sterilization, just patch it up with whatever is available and you are good till the ambulance is here.I think what you are missing is intermediate incidents, that need treatment but not necessarily a doctor. You know, like deeper wound that bleeds quite badly, but doesn't need stitches*. Its why I have a wound patch and some tape to seal this up, after that you are good to go.
Kids: I was doing YMCA for a long time. I often used a water spray to treat my kids, telling them that this is whatever it needed to be to treat a bath in Nettles, Bee-stings, Abrasion, Bruisings... Sometimes its enough if they believe they are treated

- Like a cut with Victorinoxes Man Scaler

- Like a cut with Victorinoxes Man Scaler
-
@nate j said:
I just can't see carrying a first aid kit on a regular basis.Its all about feeling good, I think. The same thing that causes us to carry a knife, MT, light, etc. There is an element of pragmatism too, because these things are functional, but its largely about the good vibes we get from knowing that we are prepared. And we want to be prepared because the world is a big, bad, scary place, and having that feeling of preparedness gives us a sense that we have some control over it. It may be a false sense of control, but we take what we can get.
-
@Etherealicer said:
I agree to some degree**Minor **(for example a papercut): while washing will solve the problem, you probably still want to work and not bleed (even if its only few droplets) all over. Thats where band-aids are very helpful.
Major: There are all kind of major incidents, some, like chest pain / breathing problems, cannot wait, you give some aspirin and hope for the best (I hike at high altitude and sometimes with very old folks 70+).
As for wounds I agree, that there is no need for sterilization, just patch it up with whatever is available and you are good till the ambulance is here.I think what you are missing is intermediate incidents, that need treatment but not necessarily a doctor. You know, like deeper wound that bleeds quite badly, but doesn't need stitches*. Its why I have a wound patch and some tape to seal this up, after that you are good to go.
Kids: I was doing YMCA for a long time. I often used a water spray to treat my kids, telling them that this is whatever it needed to be to treat a bath in Nettles, Bee-stings, Abrasion, Bruisings... Sometimes its enough if they believe they are treated

*** Like a cut with Victorinoxes Man Scaler
**Very nice!
-
@powernoodle said:
Its all about feeling good, I think. The same thing that causes us to carry a knife, MT, light, etc. There is an element of pragmatism too, because these things are functional, but its largely about the good vibes we get from knowing that we are prepared. And we want to be prepared because the world is a big, bad, scary place, and having that feeling of preparedness gives us a sense that we have some control over it. It may be a false sense of control, but we take what we can get.No. The world is by far not so bad or scary that they are "needed".
I´ve been years without any knive, light, tool - and now carrying them made me not feel other than then.
It´s just another gimmick to fiddle around, a new mens toy. And sometimes it´s handy to have the MT available, good for my laziness not to need to walk to my next tool-cart.
Here you are not allowed to drive a car without a standardized first aid kit. Usually that is close enough for most "accidents". But i have a small one packed with my experiences from army and "metal work" - i take it with me when i assume no car-fak around the place i want to go. Nothing fancy....
-
Michael, my post was probably the most brilliant thing ever uttered on MTO.
-
And off course you are completely entitled to that opinion.

-
I have a very small FAK, nothing fancy, but it's better to have something rather then not having anything for that "just in case" we do a lot of walking and everything is on concrete, so those little scrapes are easy to come by, also bikes come flying threw without any notice, so you just never know, I mean every thing I have is for small stuff but if it came to that quick emergency, I also have some rolled up tape and a fold up maxipad, cause even calling 9-11, it's going to take them a few min to get to where ever were at. JR
-
Its all about feeling good, I think. The same thing that causes us to carry a knife, MT, light, etc. There is an element of pragmatism too, because these things are functional, but its largely about the good vibes we get from knowing that we are prepared. And we want to be prepared because the world is a big, bad, scary place, and having that feeling of preparedness gives us a sense that we have some control over it. It may be a false sense of control, but we take what we can get.
No. The world is by far not so bad or scary that they are "needed".
I´ve been years without any knive, light, tool - and now carrying them made me not feel other than then.
It´s just another gimmick to fiddle around, a new mens toy. And sometimes it´s handy to have the MT available, good for my laziness not to need to walk to my next tool-cart.
Maybe for you and where you are. I have lived where knife is life. Any medical help could be days away.
-
Think "boo boo" kit rather than Trauma kit. IFAK for me is a simply a few bandaids, antiseptic wipe, a few Ibuprofens, and baby aspirin.
-
My first aid kit barely makes it beyond 'boo boo kit'.
However, my husband's family has a history of heart attack. So it includes unbuffered aspirin. This is not a feel-good booboo kit thing. This can literally save someone's life. My husband's life. And I like him, so... :D
Mostly, it's about comfort. Psuedoephedrine, for instance, since i'm basically allergic to everything. Pain killers, imodium, that kind of thing. They're not going to save my life, but they can sure turn a crap day into a much more pleasant day.
I've had some folks in office work get fairly serious cuts, not enough to need stitches, but enough that they'd bleed all over stuff if they didn't have a band aid on it. Bandaids ARE actually useful, on occasion.
It's not all peace of mind stuff. It is, in my opinion, needed about as often as a sewing kit. This does really depend on what you do, though.
-
My first aid kits is just basically a roll of duct tape and some cotton rags. Oh yeah, and some super glue.
That's us mobile.
-
I have a massive warehouse first aid kit that I did keep in the Jeep, but I've taken it out. You name it, it was in it. It's easy to get serious injuries when offroading, and can take hours to get out of the woods. I might see if I can get a good, smaller fabric bag to pack the stuff in. The metal container it's in is too big to keep in the Jeep.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
...They're not going to save my life, but they can sure turn a crap day into a much more pleasant day...This is right along my line of thinking. And it's not just for me, it's for the kids and wife and whoever else I'm with.
I don't "EDC" a full FAK, just some over-the-counter pills that come in handy. I also started carrying band aids in my wallet years ago, and I'm surprised how often they're used. Lately I added a antibacterial wipe that fits in the ID slot of my wallet, and let me tell you, if you've got two (soon 3 :P) kids three & under, that gets used and replaced all the time.
I have a bit fuller kit in my "daddy bag", but it's really just more of the same stuff I EDC, plus gloves, tape, and a few extras. :)
-
I too don't think FAK is just about feeling good, especially if you do intend to use the skill you know. And some basic protection is just good safety measure when you want to help strangers, for example, CPR face shield and gloves could come in handy.
-
I carry one all the time. Its just something that I've gotten used to.
Sent from my Cruize W280 using Tapatalk
-
I carry bandaids, a couple of 4x4s, a 2" roller gauze, and some neosporin in my pack. It fits in an case about 4x6x1, along with tylenol, xantac, immodium, benadryl and sudafed for a minimal pharmacopia, a keychain-sized CPR mask (I know the new school method, I also know the old school, and if I'm someplace more than 10 minutes out, I'm going old school and don't want puke in my mouth), two pairs of nitriles, and a bottle of hand sanitizer. It's mostly a booboo and "life sucks" kit- there is also duct and electricians tape in my pack, a standard handkerchief in my back pocket with a spare in my pack (or a shemagh). I carry more when I'm hiking, and quite a bit more that lives in my range bag and I put it in my pack when I'm hunting or going someplace where there will be chainsaws in use.
@Lichtbote said:
It´s just another gimmick to fiddle around, a new mens toy.Really? You're saying that about carrying a couple of bandaids around?
-
It´s just another gimmick to fiddle around, a new mens toy.
Really? You're saying that about carrying a couple of bandaids around?
That was only related to carrying a knife, MT, and/or light as edc all days.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


