how about can openers???? useless!!!!
-
I like the can opener, always have.
First, it has history within the multi-world. The idea, borrowed from the SAK and appearing on the first PST has been a feature of almost every full-size multitool since then. It hearkens back to the early days of multitooldom when the tools were aimed at outdoorsman and campers. Also, keep in mind that us poor people can't necessarily afford pull-top cans so it's still useful for us in a wide range of applications.
That and most modern can openers are useful for slightly more than opening cans.
The Leatherman model has a wire stripper ground into the tang and doubles as a (poor) bottle opener and awl in certain instances.
SOG and Victorinox add a small flathead to their openers.
For those who want it replaced with something else, what would you like to see? It's not too terribly hard to mod it into an awl if the tool doesn't have one of those but I can't think of much that would be potentially as useful to replace it.
- Can openers can easily be substituted by using the flat screwdrivers already on the MT.
Does that really work? I can't imagine it being anything but a messy pain in the butt.
-
@Spoonrobot said:
I like the can opener, always have.First, it has history within the multi-world. The idea, borrowed from the SAK and appearing on the first PST has been a feature of almost every full-size multitool since then. It hearkens back to the early days of multitooldom when the tools were aimed at outdoorsman and campers.
I've carried an original LM PST along on outdoor trips for quite a few years. So far as I can remember, it's never been used to open a can while outdoors. Opened a few cans at home right after I got it, just to check out its functionality.
Even on a multitool used exclusively outdoors, I'd rather have any other implement in that slot. I certainly see no need for canopeners or bottleopeners on multis not purchased for outdoor use.
@Spoonrobot said:
For those who want it replaced with something else, what would you like to see? It's not too terribly hard to mod it into an awl if the tool doesn't have one of those but I can't think of much that would be potentially as useful to replace it.I'd prefer nearly anything to a canopener.
Any implement that might see some use - a small Phillips or slothead screwdriver for example. An awl on those multis lacking an awl. Anything.
.
-
Can openers, bottle openers, and corkscrews should be relaced with:
- small phillips
- dedicated small flat head screwdriver with longer reach than a can opener
- small scissors for certain MTs which lose a file or blade to make room for scissors (eg Swisstool RS)
- scraper
- small manual drill like the new Swiss Tech 19-in-1 keychain MT
- small crescent wrench
- bit driver (exchangeable tips for flat or phillips)
- replaced with nothing so the MT get slimmer for better ergonomics
- the list can go on......
-
Can openers, bottle openers, and corkscrews should be relaced with:
- small phillips
The Vic can opener can be used as a Phillips screwdriver. In fact it's pretty darn good at it.
- scraper
Again, the Vic can opener can be used as this too.
I could understand if the can opener could open cans but do nothing else but the Vic can opener is so much more. Supposedly the Wenger one is too but you'd have to ask Ringzero about that ;). Both can be used as MANY other tools. It is the 2nd most implement on my SAK, the 1st being the small blade. I have used it to bend wire, as a makeshift chisel, a hook for carrying things, washing dishes, a "pokey thingy", screwdriver, makeshift drill, etc etc.
With its unique shape its usefulness is limited only by your imagination.
-
@ducktapehero said:
With its unique shape its usefulness is limited only by your imagination.I think you,ve summed it up there mate :)
-
@ducktapehero said:
I use the can opener on my SAK almost daily. It's great for opening cans(obviously), as a makeshift Phillips screwdriver, a scraper, a lightweight chisel, small flathead screwdriver etc etc. In fact if a multi-tool doesn't have a can opener it's pretty much a deal breaker for me. I always thought that it would be terrible to starve to death in a fully stocked bunker because you didn't have a can opener.+1. Exactly what DTH said.
-
I remember reading about some guy who fell into a cave during an expedition. His collegues couldn't get to him and, since he was uninjured, threw him every can of food they had and went back to get help. When help arrived, they found a very pissed off tourist and a pile of flattened cans.
Could be an urban legend, but I'm not taking any chances. Anything of mine that can have a can opener attached to it, does.
-
@ducktapehero said:
I could understand if the can opener could open cans but do nothing else but the Vic can opener is so much more. Supposedly the Wenger one is too but you'd have to ask Ringzero about that ;). Both can be used as MANY other tools. It is the 2nd most implement on my SAK, the 1st being the small blade. I have used it to bend wire, as a makeshift chisel, a hook for carrying things, washing dishes, a "pokey thingy", screwdriver, makeshift drill, etc etc.With its unique shape its usefulness is limited only by your imagination.
The canopeners on both Vic and Wenger SAKs are versatile implements indeed, useful for a whole lot more than just opening cans.
I like both designs, but lately am liking the Wenger design better than the Vic. I've discovered that I actually use it more on a daily basis, dealing with various small tasks for which the Vic implement isn't that handy.
Both are useful implements to have on a SAK, even if they rarely get used to open cans.
Although I do like the canopener implements on my SAKs, I'd rather not have them on bigger, plier-centric mulits.
When attached to a bigger, bulkier tool, they don't seem to be nearly as handy to use as when they are on a smaller SAK.
.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login