Core vs ST300 vs Swisstool vs Grappler vs Diesel vs Swissgrip
-
Your turn for the review next time then
:D You could always get one of the younglings to upload the piccies for you :) -
@50ft-trad said:
<u>**Core: **</u>
I was right! I could have sworn the pliers handles on the Core were closer in the closed position than with the ST300, but at the UK meet I allowed myself to be convinced the reverse was true. Maybe there’s variations on one or both of these tools that sets the spacing differently.You're correct. We compared a Core and the ST300 and the ST300 handles were noticeably closer together. They gradually got wider apart from the ST to the ST200 to the Core, then the ST300 was half way between the Core and the ST200.
The fact there is variation irritates me. I have a Core and I can't really grip things with it because I have fairly small hands too. I'm a medium and a half, medium gloves are very tight, large are loose.
-
Tom, can you take some measurements of your two, and I'll take measurements of mine. It would be nice to see which of the tools is varying and by how much. We prob need to standardise the measurements so we're both measuring the same thing. Centre distance of tool pivots?
-
Oooohhh! Although in the pics above, the ST300 appears more splayed, the measurements on mine are actually identical. Confirmed by offering them up side by side. Maybe the ST300 handles hadn't fully "latched" open in the pic

Both tools:
Measuring at the widest point across the handles - 58mm
Pivot Centre distance - 42mmNOTE: The Core still "feels" better though
-
You BROKE the canon camera? I see you are not using it for these pictures.
Your need to do some batoning tests and some ninja throwing tests too for the review to be more related to real life use.
-
@dks said:
You BROKE the canon camera? I see you are not using it for these pictures.Your need to do some batoning tests and some ninja throwing tests too for the review to be more related to real life use.
Nope the Canon is doing fine ... other than the missing charger :-[ I'm hoping that turns up soon. Ther Lumix is a great little camera though.
As for the extra tests, the last time I tried to throw a ninja I put my back out ::)
-
Al: I'll get my Core out of my car later. I don't actually have a Supertool to measure.
-
Whereas people were caught up in the megapixel war not many noticed the Huge increase in picture quality that hapenned in the past few years. Most cameras produced in the past 3-4 years that you can buy for 100- 200 euros take outdoor / in good lighting pictures that are comparable to what you would have expected from a DSLR 8 years ago.
even mobile phone cameras are pretty good now. I use the phone camera as my main camera most days and I am happy with the pictures. -
@dks said:
Whereas people were caught up in the megapixel war not many noticed the Huge increase in picture quality that hapenned in the past few years. Most cameras produced in the past 3-4 years that you can buy for 100- 200 euros take outdoor / in good lighting pictures that are comparable to what you would have expected from a DSLR 8 years ago.
even mobile phone cameras are pretty good now. I use the phone camera as my main camera most days and I am happy with the pictures.I think you quite right there.

I used to be heavily into photography years ago. I left college and went to work as a press photographer for a brief period. Digital was still just emerging and everyone thought it'll be decades before the quality would be better - lolI think digital is amazing - I just wish I had more freedom to embrace it fully.
-
Great stuff Al!

The only thing I might question is about the cutters on your Diesel, are you sure they are anvil rather than bypass? I've just been looking at mine and, while the overlap is shallow, they definitely do bypass each other.
I do agree about the seeming trend for Leatherman to make the spacing between the handles wider and wider. It's one of the reasons I don't own either the Core or Supertool 300, I just don't find them comfortable enough in use.
-
The only thing I might question is about the cutters on your Diesel, are you sure they are anvil rather than bypass? I've just been looking at mine and, while the overlap is shallow, they definitely do bypass each other.
I do agree about the seeming trend for Leatherman to make the spacing between the handles wider and wider. It's one of the reasons I don't own either the Core or Supertool 300, I just don't find them comfortable enough in use.
Check the cutters on the Diesel, and you're quite right
Rather odd looking cutters, but they go in fact bypass 
As for the handle spacing, if it wasn't for the fact that the Swisstool has such a comprehensive toolset and all the other peripherals in the sheath, I might even feel the same way about that too. It's certainly not a tool I'd want to be using all day, every day, but thankfully the Spirit offers all the onboard features (other than a square (which I omitted from my comments earlier
) but has better ergos.I also appreciate that those with particularly large hands may find the larger framed tools more to their liking. It's not that the ergonomics are bad for ALL users, just for those who wear less than an XL glove size
-
Hello, 2014. I just wanted to tell my Gerber Grappler story. I needed to take a rear tire off an old mountain bike--14 mm nut. I had my newly purchased GG in my pocket, so I thought here was a legitimate use for the tool other than cutting up carrots or prising nails out of Masonite.
I heard a little pop and the action felt mushy. I tried the adjustment, but it still felt mushy. I looked at the tool and saw that a major pivot rivet had sheared. There is not a lot of room in that area, so I did not attempt to source or make a new pin with circlips. I live in Gerbertown, so I took it in. They said that if they cannot fix or replace it, they will give me a credit for the last manufacturer suggested retail price for the tool.
That's my story. I guess the carrots weakened that rivet head somehow. If they give me a credit, what Gerber item should I purchase? All I wanted was the Grappler, and that failed pretty badly!
-
Welcome to the forum.
Sorry to hear the GG failed you. :-\
Maybe one of the MP600 models would be a good replacement. Also the Diesel, but some like it, some don't. Everybody likes an MP600 tough. ;)
-
@sheer said:
That's my story. I guess the carrots weakened that rivet head somehow. If they give me a credit, what Gerber item should I purchase? All I wanted was the Grappler, and that failed pretty badly!If you want a robust, compact MT with locking pliers then a LM Crunch is the obvious choice (but it isn't a Gerber :( ).
-
Welcome to the forum

Thank you for confirming my suspicions
I did a review on the Grappler here http://www.multitool.org/reviews/gerber/large-tools/261-gerber-grappler.html and felt the duty level was lighter than the tool's size implies.Was the break on yours where I though it looked weak, or somewhere else?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

