SAK's - Corkscrew or Phillips?
-
@shamus said:
Vic offers an inline Phillips on the Champ and Explorer, the tinker series has a t-mounted Phillips driver, the can opener tool can just about fit into any Phillips screw out there, and the Cybertools and Swisstools have torx and Phillips bits. I’m not sure how one could see Vic as being hostile towards Philips screws.
You have missed a few:
Minichamp
Rambler
Manager
Midnite Manager
RallyProbably more as well.
There are also the Victorinox SwissTool and SwissTool multitools that all have Phillips screwdrivers.
-
Another corkscrew preference here. Love being able to carry the eyeglass screwdriver. And so many models have the can opener with the driver that can handle many philips screws.
if the screw is torqued too tight & you slip u can damage the can opener and the screw
And if the screw is torqued too tight, you can with surprising ease screw up the peening of the knife with the backmounted Philips. ;) We have some threads lying around with pictures and expletives somewhere around this place. :)
-
This is the thread that keeps coming back to life.
The whole world is held together with phillips screws, not wine corks.

-
@powernoodle said:
This is the thread that keeps coming back to life.The whole world is held together with phillips screws, not wine corks.

The Philips screw is slowly being replaced, while the need for a good wine rather seems to grow. :D
-
I guess that if one drinks enough wine, he no longer cares if screws need tightening.
I may test that theory.
-
@powernoodle said:
I guess that if one drinks enough wine, he no longer cares if screws need tightening.I may test that theory.
What screws?

-
I am totally sold on the in-line philips, and the corkscrew driver (as a glasses wearer). I use the in-line philips regularly and wouldn't feel ok putting the same pressure on the back-side driver - more likely to shear/distort.
The CS can also be used to house a temporary lanyard;
<a href="http://s923.photobucket.com/user/magentus2112/media/WP_20160122_003_zpsbnbkwicj.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i923.photobucket.com/albums/ad80/magentus2112/WP_20160122_003_zpsbnbkwicj.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a> -
Logic path:
I like SAKs
SAK pliers can't handle what I need pliers to do
I need to carry a pliers tool
The pliers tool will usually have a Phillips and assorted flat drivers
The pliers tool is unlikely to have a corkscrew
The pliers tool is unlikely to have scissors as good as a SAK
My SAK should have scissors and a corkscrewThis formula works very well for me indeed
That said, I have found that a Gerber Dime is sometimes all I need on the pliers front, and as such have been considering a DofE with a blade modification. If I do this, it will be the only SAK with backspring Phillips I carry (except for the Mega84 which has both backspring Phillips AND corkscrew)
-
Excellent logic!!!
-
@50ft-trad said:
Logic path:I like SAKs
SAK pliers can't handle what I need pliers to do
I need to carry a pliers tool
The pliers tool will usually have a Phillips and assorted flat drivers
The pliers tool is unlikely to have a corkscrew
The pliers tool is unlikely to have scissors as good as a SAK
My SAK should have scissors and a corkscrewThis formula works very well for me indeed
I have a modified formula, the scissors goes in a Swisscard, but otherwise I fully agree with you!
-
Old thread, but the topic seems to be not discussed to its end it seems... will this ever be possible here?!
I doubt...
But as it goes for me - I have no preference. I like 'em both. The canopener is a good phillipshead screwdriver. The backlayer one is a good one as well, but too much pressure is not fine for it. I use the backlayer one mostly when unscrewing something.
But nothing beats the good ol' inlayer phillipshead like on the Explorer on the Swisschamp.
The corkscrew is fine for untying knots of shoelaces that are maybe wet and very well tied together, so that they are actually bombproof. I´m no wine drinker - being a bavarian, I highly appreciate good beverage. But the small eyeglass screwdriver is also used for me to open the tools on the SAK when I cut my nails too short and I can hardly reach nailnicks, or when the hands are really cold, a great little tool there.
So each has its pros and cons.
It is a tie for me

-
Phillips driver. It can handle No. 1 and No. 2 Phillips, unlike the inline model which can only handle No. 2. The can opener can handle No. 2s on models that do not have a Phillips, (i.e. Soldier '61, Spartan), but is limited by the fact it can't reach recessed screws.
Sure, I often carry a pliers based tool, but almost as often as I carry it, I usually leave it behind. I only have two models with corkscrew out of my almost one dozen SAK collection--German Army Knife and Explorer. GAK I usually carry because it's so light and thin, and the Explorer because I do occasionally use the mag lens.
The Duke of Edinburgh Award Tool I've considered getting myself--problem is the darn idiot-proofed blunt tip blade, and since I don't think I have the skills to reprofile it, guess I'm stuck with that blade. At least that blade would be better for emergency situations and when I'm in extremely close quarters to others.
-
Corkscrew all the way!!!
I actually use mine frequently, as Mrs. sLaughter is a wine drinker, and more often than not my SAK with CS is closer than a dedicated Corkscrew. Plus, I enjoy any excuse to use my SAKs and multis, so I actually get enjoyment out of a bottle of wine I otherwise wouldnt get anything out of (im more of a beer and liquor guy).
The corkscrew makes a decent marline spike as well, which is important when you have kids with shoes with laces.

-
@50ft-trad said:
Logic path:I like SAKs
SAK pliers can't handle what I need pliers to do
I need to carry a pliers tool
The pliers tool will usually have a Phillips and assorted flat drivers
The pliers tool is unlikely to have a corkscrew
The pliers tool is unlikely to have scissors as good as a SAK
My SAK should have scissors and a corkscrewThis formula works very well for me indeed
That said, I have found that a Gerber Dime is sometimes all I need on the pliers front, and as such have been considering a DofE with a blade modification. If I do this, it will be the only SAK with backspring Phillips I carry (except for the Mega84 which has both backspring Phillips AND corkscrew)
This does make sense to me too. If I'm carrying a Rebar, for example, then it is complimented by carrying the SAK with a cork crew and scissors.
Then Victorinox went and blew that whole line of logic to hell by putting out the Spirit which has their excellent scissors, and an optional accessory cork screw.

-
@cody6268 said:
Phillips driver. It can handle No. 1 and No. 2 Phillips, unlike the inline model which can only handle No. 2. The can opener can handle No. 2s on models that do not have a Phillips, (i.e. Soldier '61, Spartan), but is limited by the fact it can't reach recessed screws.Sure, I often carry a pliers based tool, but almost as often as I carry it, I usually leave it behind. I only have two models with corkscrew out of my almost one dozen SAK collection--German Army Knife and Explorer. GAK I usually carry because it's so light and thin, and the Explorer because I do occasionally use the mag lens.
**The Duke of Edinburgh Award Tool I've considered getting myself--problem is the darn idiot-proofed blunt tip blade, **and since I don't think I have the skills to reprofile it, guess I'm stuck with that blade. At least that blade would be better for emergency situations and when I'm in extremely close quarters to others.
I've been playing around with how to reprofile it. It seems a 2p coin makes a reasonable template for marking out a kind of sheepsfoot style (see pics below)




-
I thought I'd weighed in last time this thread surfaced
But I've changed my mind since then anyway...I used to be 100% in the phillips camp, then came to realize when you need a corkscrew, you NEED a corkscrew. Whereas the phillips can be managed with the can opener.So if I have a second tool with me, the SAK needs a corkscrew/mini SD. All of my kit/bag/car SAKs are CS models. However, around the house, I usually carry a SAK by itself, and it needs to have a phillips (Super Tinker/Evo 16). I have a corkscrew in the kitchen, and the back side phillips is great for replacing kids' toy batteries.
Also, that sheepsfoot looks like a great idea

-
Both are important but I did choose philips. Mostly because corkscrew often mess the use and carry a bit. I would rather have a bit bigger tool where corkscrew is inside scales. Or seperately carried in sheath like in swisstool. Tool itself is good still. And like mentioned, when you need it, you need it.
-
I only arry saks with the inline philips like SC, Champ Plus or Explorerso I get the best of both worlds. I get to use the cork screw to hold the mini screwdriver. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



