91mm Non-plus Scale Comparison
-
The engraved sterling is pretty cool...
-
I am sorry if I forgot any colors... :-\
I think you can count the stamped ones (like those on the fisherman and camper)
Regular Red ones... sorry for any inconvenience :) -
I voted for Genuine Horn. I really like the look (and feel) of that.
But the nices one are on my metallic blue (cellidor) Spartan :)

-
Love that metallic fleck. Available anywhere?
-
I voted regular old red. While I think it's cool that you can now get Vic's in a number of colors, they aren't part of a nearly universal language. A red pocket knife with a white cross on it (Vic or Wenger logo) is a statement.
Besides having a sort of immediate meaning, it's also a very practical color. Red isn't a color that occurs in nature with high frequency. Dropping a red object in almost any environment means it will still be visible. Sure, the Stay Glow Yellow might be even better for visibility, but then you lose the universally recognized aspect.
I recently got a Swisslite in Ruby. It's very pretty, and I can certainly see how people might like the transparent scales, but I still prefer just plain red.
For other material, horn, wood, etc. it looks nice, but is not what you put on a knife you intend to use. My first pocket knife (a little Buck) had wooden scales, and looked nice. Some of the more exotic materials (like the stuff Ong works) is gorgeous, but makes what used to be a practical implement into a shelf-queen. Nothing wrong with that for collectors, but I'm not a collector.
Also, I wouldn't want to have to change all the SAK icons.
:tool:
:sak: 
-
@J Mackrel Jones said:
Love that metallic fleck. Available anywhere?Mine is the only one I've ever seen. It was probably a special order by some company I can't remember right know. EMS or something like that.
Some company... apparently they are the ones who make the plastic for Victorinox scales. This info was posted today: </post/712407>
What a coincidence :) -
@Lynn LeFey said:
For other material, horn, wood, etc. it looks nice, but is not what you put on a knife you intend to use.Red EcoLine is my personal preference apart from Alox. Lynn Lefey's post pretty much sums up my point of view except I don't have a Swisslight. I think the EcoLine stuff makes a good handle material and that red is one vibrant colour in my eyes. I like genuine horn and mother of pearl for their looks and I would love to at least see a metallic dark green as well. That blue one is quite something!
-
For non alox, definitely the silvertech!
-
Why only non Plus? The best I have ever seen and touched and own is a Plus scale, the Ruby Soft. From the ones I only show in pictures or stores, second comes the Emerald Green and third the Silvertech. But the Metallic Blue is also great. It doesn't matter if they contain a pen or not, the color and feel are the same.
Here's my Mountaineer. I love the touch of it!
-
@kkokkolis said:
Why only non Plus? The best I have ever clearly superior seen and touched and own is a Plus scale, the Ruby Soft. From the ones I only show in pictures or stores, second comes the Emerald Green and third the Silvertech. But the Metallic Blue is also great. It doesn't matter if they contain a pen or not, the color and feel are the same.As you said Plus scales are clearly superior to the regular Cellidor cales when compared independent of price
As they add a pen and pin, two useful implements. I thought the regular red and black scales would nearly never be voted because of that, and thus I wanted to make a vote of non-plus scales to make it fair. And then I forgot to add some of the colors/variations
-
I liked any color made before Vic started producing the hollowed out version with stiffener ribs. I guess I just don't like change. I swear the thinned blade tangs and hollow scales changed the heft and sound of knives. However,I would not want prove that in a blind test.
-
I voted for horn.
(anything but cellidor :D)
-
Ok, I've gone for stay glow,just because its the one I'd like to see brought back

-
i hate to agree with Kirk but i do :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
(this might get me in trouble, it's against the rules i think) -
What about the SoftGrip, or are they considered plus scales? I don't own one, but from what I've read, they don't include the pen.
-
Classic red for me, although the vast majority of my SAKs are not red.
-
I voted plain old black
I'm also a fan of the original red as well, but the black just looks nice and slick :D -
BUMP.
5 days left! :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login