It's not just me!
-
Man, when are they going to get with the program and realize that if they keep going on this path they will eventually no longer be #1. People will only put up with these rusting issues for so long before they give up hope, and stray away from LM. Between the rusting, and other quality issues with fit and finish, LM is quickly falling down the quality totem pole!
-
Well that explains why they are going so cheap now. Saw one for something like $15 new the other day.
These pics make me think I might just spend the bucks on sharpening system I have been eyeing off, and tidy up my old 2nd hand Buck knife.
I am at 3 LM products now. Nearly bought a Raptor but got a new :sak: instead because of this kind of thing.
Awaiting further reports on the Raptor.
Thanks for the intel guys. -
The thing is.. the next level of steel up from 420 to 440c really doesnt add that much cost at all. So I just dont see why they dont go for it. Yes its harder to form 440c like they do with 420 on say the wave folded body design, but there is no reason the blades and tools cant be made from 440. Its cheap compared to super steels, and its a very good steel as long as its heat treated well.
Im still very much an amateur tinkerer of steels, but I sure would never use anything less rust resistant than 440c.
And I'll add my rusty juice parts test pic for dramatic effect. :D

-
Ugh.
I hate to see this. Hopefully Leatherman sees this and makes the tough call to improve materials. I will say, the satin finishes seem to rust faster. Regardless, it seems inexcusable with so many multitools/knives out there with no significant issues of rust.
I love my Leathermans, but dang!
-
I think Leatherman should start putting warning labels on their tools. "WARNING: If using tool for intended use, rust may occur".

-
As long as I treat my leatherman like a gun, it does not rust. I just have to keep it clean and oiled. If I use it in extreme weather where it gets soaked for long periods of time, I clean and oil it at the end of the day. So far it has worked.
sent from Ducttapetech's mobile device -
And that would, but then do you also polish and oil the hammer in your toolbox? The tire iron in your car? The silverware in your kitchen? Do you wipe down the screen on your smartphone with alcohol swabs after every phone call, vacuum the crevices of your keyboard after each computer use, wash, polish and sharpen your shovels every time you dig a hole?
These are all tools that are meant to be used with little to no maintenance, and yet be there, ready to go with no notice whatsoever no matter what. To me, that's what a multitool should be. I have it, I use it, I put it away when I'm done and it stays there until the next time I need it.
Def
-
Wow, that is really something. Maybe 3 months after getting my Wave, it broke out with widespread rusting. The plier head, saw, file (especially the file), and inner tools were hardest hit, but even the handles and blades had some rust on them as well. It looked like my wife and I after the bush we were in turned out to be poinson ivy ;) At any rate, I wasn't using it in wet conditions. Over that time period, I bought the tool in Nebraska and moved to Montana, and it was during summer, so conditions were actually pretty dry. My Skeletool while not as bad, has still had rusting issues. Honestly, the Wingman has been the more rust proof of my 3 large LMs (although the file has been a problem area) I assume due to the higher polish.
This has me wondering, will Leatherman's warranty allow for significantly oxidized tools be returned to them for cleaning? I am guessing probably not since the LM website gives instructions for care/cleaning.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
And that would, but then do you also polish and oil the hammer in your toolbox? The tire iron in your car? The silverware in your kitchen? Do you wipe down the screen on your smartphone with alcohol swabs after every phone call, vacuum the crevices of your keyboard after each computer use, wash, polish and sharpen your shovels every time you dig a hole?These are all tools that are meant to be used with little to no maintenance, and yet be there, ready to go with no notice whatsoever no matter what. To me, that's what a multitool should be. I have it, I use it, I put it away when I'm done and it stays there until the next time I need it.
Def
I don't use silverware, I use my fingers. Lol!
I didn't mean I clean my leatherman everyday. But it gets cleaned and oiled often. and it gets cleaned and oiled when it has been soaked. And yes I wipe my tools clean of grease and dirt when I am finished with them. My grandfather and amoung others, always told me if you take care of your tools, they will take care of you. So far it has held true.
And no, I am not trying to be a smart smurf.
sent from Ducttapetech's mobile device -
Now with me poking fun at LM, I do have to say I just gave my TTi a good look over and it doesn't have a single spec of rust on it. I have been swimming with it in my pocket, cut plants with the blades, cut down a small tree with the saw (still bits of wood in the teeth) and after use it gets put right back in my pocket, wet or not.
Now I do have to admit that when I first got this from Metro, I gave it a good bath of aerospace corrosion inhibitor, so that could be why it hasn't developed any rust yet, but can't say for certain.
-
@rdub934 said:
This has me wondering, will Leatherman's warranty allow for significantly oxidized tools be returned to them for cleaning? I am guessing probably not since the LM website gives instructions for care/cleaning.Extreme rust USED to be a warrantied issue, but they removed that from allowable reasons to return for warranty. Not sure exactly when they made that change though.
-
It is indeed a shame. Nearly every used tool I have picked up, even with factory oil on it, has a few rust spots.
Makes me reach for the Spirit as a user more and more :-\
-
Someone gave me a Micra years back, which has rust on it now.
When I gave away my original SOG Crosscut, there was some rusting just starting on the spring in the gear system, but the handles and tools themselves were free of rust.
My Spirit X is too new to think about rust issues, but I don't suspect there will be any.
I like plain metal tools. Not black oxide, not cera/dura coated, not a finish on aluminum. Just clean stainless metal. That Leatherman tools have a tendency to rust is troubling, because I really like a lot of their tool designs.
I do have the benefit of being nowhere near salt water, so I don't think rust is as big of an issue for me, although humidity certainly is.
I have no answer, and i guess, nothing else all that useful to add. I'm just sorry to hear you all are having these issues. :'(
-
So far ive never had rust problems with any of my Leathermans. I live in Northern Ireland so we have plenty of wet conditions. All my tools are constantly used every day and they get wet at times. I do have a weekly clean out and oil up though and i dont store them in their sheaths when they are not being carried which i think helps. Then again im the guy who oils and polishes the leather sheath for his Fuse!
I really must get out more!
-
i think humidity is more of an issue actually. I have in the past dropped my skeletool on sea water while foraging for wild oysters, mussels and abalone. It stayed in the water for a few minutes and i cleaned it with fresh water after and oiled it a bit then presto - no rust till this day.
My sog powerlock however, has never tasted, nor been near salsmurfer. I have brought it with me on several jungle camping trips and forest adventures. Now Humidity in our local jungles are quite oppressive at times that it dehydrate you to extremes. Consequently, after these said adventures, rust spots have developed on my powerlock but with a little bit of WD40 and a lot of elbow grease, It has happily been restored back to its original luster.
-
I have lived near the coast all my life. I had the old Wave for 12 years before warranty replacement. I used it to cut fruit with the main blade from time to time, using alcohol swabs I had ready access to, before and after. Only the can opener touched food otherwise and only ever got a 2 second rinse with fresh water. The pliers came in contact with water, blood and goodness knows what else on a regular basis. It lived in the nylon sheath on my duty belt. I think it only got one major dunking. Can't remember if it was fresh or salt water. Some time after shelving it for months I found rust mainly inside the corners where the scissors and can opener rest etc. I painstakingly removed the rust with cotton buds and then 1000 grade sandpaper followed by some light machine oil on the previously effected areas. Thought that would be the beginning of the end, but never had another issue. And I don't think it had another clean for the next 5 years or so. My only real beef with LM is the serrated blade. It ain't that sharp. But I digress.
So far. No rust in the Style CS or ST300, but the latter has seen hardly any use. -
My Super Tool 300 gets rust spots on both blades, especially the rescue blade. Cleaned it with mineral oil.
I've never had a problem with my Micra, Style CS or Skeletool.
I did see a Wave in a clamshell with rust spots a year or so ago. Asked a stocker about it, he made a crack about Leatherman quality not being what it used to be. No discounts.Uneducated as I am, I think I prefer the 420 to the higher chrome steels. As I said, only rust problems I have are on the bead blasted parts. If Leatherman insists on matte finishes, they should use a more rust resistant steel in those areas. However, for something I beat on like the Skeletool, I think 420 is alright, if not best.
-
I think you need to change your name, how does Rusty Lamontagne sound?
If only they ditch the bead blast finish they'd have better corrosion resistance, but everyone just loves it because it's quick and cheap to do. Even Victorinox is jumping on the wagon (saw their backlock folder in store the other day, bead blasted, disappointing).
-
@derekmac said:
Now with me poking fun at LM, I do have to say I just gave my TTi a good look over and it doesn't have a single spec of rust on it. I have been swimming with it in my pocket, cut plants with the blades, cut down a small tree with the saw (still bits of wood in the teeth) and after use it gets put right back in my pocket, wet or not.Now I do have to admit that when I first got this from Metro, I gave it a good bath of aerospace corrosion inhibitor, so that could be why it hasn't developed any rust yet, but can't say for certain.
I'm interested now.... Tell me more about the rust inhibitor bath.

-
As a Victorinox user for almost three decades, with SAKs used in snow, mountain dew, rainy and extremely salty sea environments, I am negatively impressed. I wouldn't like to worry about rust on my Surge or Juice, for the price these things have here.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





