The Nessmuk Challenge
-
Comis, using a steel is honing the edge not sharpening it so you are not removing material from the edge you are realigning it. Squaring away any microscopic chips, cracks, waviness, or edge roll that developed from use. I only use a sharpener on a very poor edge when I am basically creating a new edge from scratch, and that does remove material from the edge and eventually wears down a blade.
I have not encountered any weakness in any edge after honing with a steel. My edges last a long time. You see chefs honing their knives with a steel frequently but kitchen knives are different than field knives. -
Day 2:
SwissChamp attending moonclipping duty:

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Day 10
I found these pieces of a broomstick and I cut off the broken ends. Looks like I have a spindle.


I also got to strip the bark off the slingshot. The Light My Fire Mora has a thinner blade and is better at this task, but the Companion Spark did the job just fine. The wood is not completely dry. Should be good enough.

-
@old Lefty said:
Day 2:
SwissChamp attending moonclipping duty:

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
After your post, I just went on youtube and learn about the moonclip. Learn something new today, thank you!
@ReamerPunch said:
Day 10I found these pieces of a broomstick and I cut off the broken ends. Looks like I have a spindle.


I also got to strip the bark off the slingshot. The Light My Fire Mora has a thinner blade and is better at this task, but the Companion Spark did the job just fine. The wood is not completely dry. Should be good enough.

Cool! Any plan to make fire with that?
:D -
Nothing says 'bushcraft' more than a bowdrill fire.

The broomstick spindle is as straight as it can be, and a good diameter. A little too smooth, so I'll scrape it with the Mora's spine to rough it up a little, to get the cord to bite into it. I'll keep an eye for the other parts, and give it a go. -
Day 10


Use the GB Wildlife hatchet to crack open a coconut. I used to chop into the young coconut with brute force, using either a big blade or axe, to cut a square and crack open the coconut. But lately I did some quick research on internet, and turns out I could first remove the husk and to pry the coconut at a weak point to open a perfect hole on top. I will try to open more coconuts in the next few days with my fixed blade and my SAK(don't know whether that's feasible, but worth it's trying) :D
-
Nice job, there, comis!

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Nothing says 'bushcraft' more than a bowdrill fire.

-
@Alan K. said:
Comis, using a steel is honing the edge not sharpening it so you are not removing material from the edge you are realigning it.I think it is confusing because people use the terms differently. I think I use 'honing' and 'sharpening' the same way you do. However, I've heard people say they use a steel to 'sharpen' a knife. (True, the knife is sharper after being steeled.) And I've heard people say they 'honed' an edge on whetstone....which to me was always 'sharpening.'
At this point, it's a semantics issue. I did a quick check of an online dictionary. Merriam-Webster for Hone: "to sharpen or smooth with a whetstone". They seem to feel honing and sharpening are used interchangeably.
Cook's Illustrated: "A so-called sharpening steel–also called a honing rod–which is the metal rod sold with most knife sets, doesn’t really sharpen a knife, but rather hones the edge of a slightly dulled blade."
Mr Johnson, we have a problem here......

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Nothing says 'bushcraft' more than a bowdrill fire.
I'll keep an eye for the other parts, and give it a go.Use a wooden coat hanger. Just remove the metal bits first.

-
@Alan K. said:
Use a wooden coat hanger. Just remove the metal bits first.
I don't have any. I'll look for a branch for my bow. It's the easiest part to make, so I'll go au naturel for the bow.
-
@old Lefty said:
Day 1:
Test run of making kindlings with Corvid:

Welcome aboard!

Why don't you have the Axe Challenge badge?
Have you requested it from the badge list? -
@Nix said:
I think it is confusing because people use the terms differently. I think I use 'honing' and 'sharpening' the same way you do. However, I've heard people say they use a steel to 'sharpen' a knife. (True, the knife is sharper after being steeled.) And I've heard people say they 'honed' an edge on whetstone....which to me was always 'sharpening.'At this point, it's a semantics issue. **I did a quick check of an online dictionary. Merriam-Webster for Hone: "to sharpen or smooth with a whetstone". They seem to feel honing and sharpening are used interchangeably. **
Cook's Illustrated: "A so-called sharpening steel–also called a honing rod–which is the metal rod sold with most knife sets, doesn’t really sharpen a knife, but rather hones the edge of a slightly dulled blade."
Mr Johnson, we have a problem here......

Yeah, but what do they know.
Like AK I've always thought, and been brought up to believe, that honing is realigning the tiny serrations and not the same as sharpening which removes stock and produces new micro-serrations or whatever you want to call them.

-


Use the GB Wildlife hatchet to crack open a coconut. I used to chop into the young coconut with brute force, using either a big blade or axe, to cut a square and crack open the coconut. But lately I did some quick research on internet, and turns out I could first remove the husk and to pry the coconut at a weak point to open a perfect hole on top. I will try to open more coconuts in the next few days with my fixed blade and my SAK(don't know whether that's feasible, but worth it's trying) :D
Now that is cool!
Lähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
-
@ReamerPunch said:
Nothing says 'bushcraft' more than a bowdrill fire.
The broomstick spindle is as straight as it can be, and a good diameter. A little too smooth, so I'll scrape it with the Mora's spine to rough it up a little, to get the cord to bite into it. I'll keep an eye for the other parts, and give it a go.
:D@Nix said:
I think it is confusing because people use the terms differently. I think I use 'honing' and 'sharpening' the same way you do. However, I've heard people say they use a steel to 'sharpen' a knife. (True, the knife is sharper after being steeled.) And I've heard people say they 'honed' an edge on whetstone....which to me was always 'sharpening.'At this point, it's a semantics issue. I did a quick check of an online dictionary. Merriam-Webster for Hone: "to sharpen or smooth with a whetstone". They seem to feel honing and sharpening are used interchangeably.
Cook's Illustrated: "A so-called sharpening steel–also called a honing rod–which is the metal rod sold with most knife sets, doesn’t really sharpen a knife, but rather hones the edge of a slightly dulled blade."
Mr Johnson, we have a problem here......

That's another interesting phenomena that I never quite understand, maybe that's why that's also an urban legend that using a knife can 'sharpen' another knife?

@Alan K. said:
Comis, using a steel is honing the edge not sharpening it so you are not removing material from the edge you are realigning it. Squaring away any microscopic chips, cracks, waviness, or edge roll that developed from use. I only use a sharpener on a very poor edge when I am basically creating a new edge from scratch, and that does remove material from the edge and eventually wears down a blade.
I have not encountered any weakness in any edge after honing with a steel. My edges last a long time. You see chefs honing their knives with a steel frequently but kitchen knives are different than field knives.Alan, thanks for the input! I never do using honing steel much, so I wouldn't know there's any truth in realigning steel lead to potential weaker edge retention. Your answer lead me to think--would steel also be playing a factor in proving this 'theory' right or wrong?
I ask because I do a fair amount of SAK sharpening/touch up on Spyderco sharpmaker, and one interesting phenomenon I observe is most of the time I could get a SAK edge to pretty sharp(paper whittling or arm hair shaving sharp) just by using the ceramic rod > ultra fine ceramic rod > strop on leather;
But once in a blue moon, I will not be able to bring it to that same level of sharpness, regardless how long I sharpen on those fine ceramic rods/strop. But if I do a more substantial sharpening by going all the way using diamond rods > grey whetstone rods > ceramic >ultra fine ceramic > strop, then the edge is fully restore and the said level of sharpness is easily attainable.
One youtube Sharpmaker user would explain the very edge of the knife could be 'weaken' steel or "realigned burr", and if I don't sharpen/strop enough to remove all the burr in sessions, they tend to stay on and edge retention may not be optimal(if it's on internet, it must be ture...j/k). I don't know enough to affirm or debunk the theory, but all I know is this phenomenon seems to happen to my SAK mostly, but to be fair, I do use my SAK more majority of the time and Vic steel do have less edge retention than more 'premium' steel.
Maybe that's why I am curious about honing, especially on softer steel like SAK. But Alan seems not to have the problem with his knives, so maybe that could be just another urban legend?

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Welcome aboard!
Why don't you have the Axe Challenge badge?
Have you requested it from the badge list?Thanks!
I think I did, maybe just a delay in the processLähetetty minun SM-T515 laitteesta Tapatalkilla
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


